Board Meeting Brilliance: A Guide for New Board Chairs

As a new board chair stepping into the role of leading a nonprofit board, you've got a lot on your plate. Ensuring that board meetings are both engaging and effective is a top priority. One valuable tool in your arsenal is "Robert's Rules of Order." This time-tested framework for parliamentary procedure can help you navigate the complexities of board meetings and ensure that decisions are made efficiently and fairly.

However, like any tool, it comes with both benefits and potential pitfalls. In this article, we will introduce and define Robert's Rules of Order, explore some of the common pitfalls associated with its use, and provide tips to avoid those pitfalls. We will also discuss how to adapt the use of Robert's Rules to fit your board's unique culture and context.

?

Harnessing the Power of Robert's Rules of Order:

Robert's Rules of Order provide a structured framework for conducting meetings. They offer a clear roadmap for decision-making, facilitate orderly discussions, and ensure equitable participation. Here's how board chairs can harness their power:

Structured Decision-Making: One of the primary benefits of Robert's Rules is the structured process for decision-making. Board chairs can use this structure to guide discussions on critical matters, such as budget approval or policy changes. It helps ensure that decisions are well-considered and that everyone has a chance to voice their opinions.

Equal Participation: Robert's Rules ensure that each board member has an equal opportunity to speak and make motions. Board chairs can use this feature to encourage participation from quieter members or prevent any individual from dominating the conversation. It promotes fairness and inclusivity.

Conflict Resolution: When disputes arise during meetings, Robert's Rules provide a mechanism for resolution. The board chair can step in as a neutral facilitator, using the rules to guide the process and help reach a consensus or majority decision.

Time Management: The rules also help with time management. By specifying how much time is allocated to each agenda item and providing a clear process for moving on, meetings can stay on track and prevent unnecessary delays.

?

Understanding Robert's Rules of Order

Robert's Rules of Order is a set of guidelines for conducting meetings and making decisions in an organized and democratic manner. It was first published by Henry M. Robert in 1876 and has since become the standard for parliamentary procedure in many organizations, including nonprofit boards. The rules provide structure, ensure fairness, and promote the orderly conduct of meetings. Key elements of Robert's Rules of Order include:

Motions: These are formal proposals made by board members to take action or make decisions. Motions are essential for moving discussions forward and reaching conclusions.

Debate: Robert's Rules outline a process for debating motions, allowing each board member to express their opinions and provide input on proposed actions.

Voting: The rules establish a clear method for voting on motions, including who is eligible to vote, the voting process, and the criteria for passing a motion.

Order of Business: Robert's Rules provide a standard agenda that boards can follow, ensuring that meetings cover essential topics in a logical sequence.

Amendments: The rules allow for the modification of motions through amendments, providing flexibility in decision-making.

Now that we have a basic understanding of Robert's Rules of Order, let's explore some common pitfalls that board chairs may encounter when using this framework and how to avoid them.

?

Pitfalls of Robert's Rules of Order

Overcomplication: One of the most significant pitfalls is overcomplicating meetings with strict adherence to every rule. This can lead to confusion and frustration among board members, especially those who are new to the process.

Tip: Simplify the rules to match the needs and familiarity of your board. Focus on the key elements, such as making motions, debating, and voting, while being flexible with other aspects.

Lengthy Meetings: Following Robert's Rules to the letter can result in long, drawn-out meetings. Lengthy debates and formal procedures can be exhausting and counterproductive.

Tip: Set time limits for discussions and encourage board members to be concise in their contributions. Prioritize critical agenda items and allocate more time to significant decisions.

Exclusionary Language: The formal language of Robert's Rules may alienate some board members, particularly those who are not familiar with parliamentary procedure. This can hinder effective participation.

Tip: Use plain language and provide explanations when necessary. Ensure that all board members feel comfortable and empowered to participate in discussions.

Rigidity: Strict adherence to the rules can stifle creativity and collaboration. Some decisions may benefit from a more open and informal approach.

Tip: Recognize when to relax the rules for certain discussions, especially when brainstorming or exploring new ideas. Balance formal procedures with opportunities for creative thinking.

Resistance to Change: Some board members may resist the use of Robert's Rules, viewing them as overly bureaucratic or outdated.

Tip: Address concerns openly and highlight the benefits of structure and fairness that the rules provide. Emphasize that the rules can be adapted to suit the board's needs.

?

Adapting Robert's Rules to Fit Your Board's Culture

By adapting the use of Robert's Rules to your board's culture and context, board chairs can maximize their effectiveness. Education, flexibility, and a thoughtful approach to when and how to apply the rules can help create an environment where meaningful discussions thrive, decisions are well-considered, and the organization flourishes.

Your role as board chair is not just to lead meetings but to empower your board to drive positive change and impact within your nonprofit organization. Let’s explore how you can adapt Robert's Rules of Order to align with your board's culture and context:

Training and Education: Ensure that all board members, especially new ones, receive training on Robert's Rules. This education will empower them to participate effectively in meetings.

Customized Procedures: Tailor the rules to your organization's specific needs. Develop customized procedures that align with your board's culture and priorities.

Flexible Use: Recognize that not every decision requires the full rigidity of Robert's Rules. Use the rules selectively, applying them more rigorously for major decisions and allowing for greater flexibility in routine matters.

Plain Language: Encourage the use of plain and inclusive language during meetings. Make sure that everyone understands the discussions and can participate comfortably.

Balance Structure and Flexibility: Find the right balance between structured decision-making and an open, collaborative atmosphere. Adapt the level of formality to the nature of each agenda item.

Continuous Improvement: Regularly evaluate the effectiveness of your board meetings. Solicit feedback from board members and adjust your approach accordingly.

As a new board chair, your role in running engaging and effective board meetings is critical to the success of your nonprofit organization. Robert's Rules of Order can be a valuable tool in this endeavor, providing structure and fairness to your decision-making processes. However, it is essential to use them judiciously, balancing their formal procedures with the culture and context of your board. By educating your board, setting clear expectations, and encouraging open dialogue, you can harness the power of Robert's Rules while maintaining a welcoming and collaborative atmosphere that will lead your organization toward its mission with enthusiasm and purpose.

?

Our nonprofit experts at C&A: Social Impact Consulting have crafted a powerful and practical guide to Robert's Rules of Order called Board Meeting Action Prompts. It’s tailored specifically for new nonprofit Board Chairs. This comprehensive resource demystifies the complexities of parliamentary procedure and provides invaluable insights into conducting effective board meetings.

We are delighted to offer this guide as a free download, equipping board leaders with the tools they need to navigate meetings with confidence, promote productive discussions, and make informed decisions.

Download your copy today and embark on a journey towards more impactful and efficient nonprofit board leadership.

?

Effective board meetings are a continuous learning journey. Explore these resources, participate in relevant training, and stay connected with the nonprofit community to continually enhance your skills as a leader in running productive and impactful board meetings.

Here are some recommended resources for leaders who want to enhance their skills and learn more about running effective board meetings.

The Nonprofit Board Answer Book by BoardSource: A comprehensive guide to nonprofit governance, including tips on conducting effective board meetings.

Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised by Henry M. Robert III: The definitive resource on parliamentary procedure, including its application in board meetings.

National Council of Nonprofits: Offers various resources, including templates and guides on board governance and meetings.

Coursera: Provides courses on nonprofit management and governance, some of which cover effective board meetings.

The Smart Nonprofit Masterclass: Features episodes on board management and leadership, including board meetings.

The Nonprofit Partnership: This local nonprofit association offers workshops, seminars, and resources specifically tailored to Southern California’s nonprofit sector.