The Biggest Mistake Investors Make with New Builds in Expanding Estates

Imagine investing in a brand-new property in a cutting-edge development like Shoreline in Redland Bay, only to watch it sit vacant for months on end. This scenario is all too common when investors make a critical error: expecting new builds to command significantly higher rents compared to older properties in the same suburb. Driven by the belief that a fresh, modern property should inherently be worth more, they set rental prices above comparable homes, leading to long-term vacancies and lost rental income. Here’s why this mistake happens and how a long-term perspective can turn your new build into a successful investment.

The Pitfall of Overpricing New Builds

A common misstep for investors is overestimating the rental value of new builds. This often stems from the assumption that a newly constructed property should automatically fetch higher rents than slightly older properties in the area. At Shoreline in Redland Bay, we see investors setting rents $100 higher than comparable homes, based on the belief that newness equals greater value. This approach can backfire, leading to extended vacancies and lost income.

Why Overpricing New Builds Can Backfire

1. Construction Disruptions: New estates like Shoreline are still in development, which can mean ongoing construction noise, dust, and other disruptions. These factors can make potential tenants hesitant to pay premium rents, especially when established properties offer a more settled living environment.
2. Incomplete Development: New builds may have unfinished aspects or surrounding construction work that can deter tenants from paying higher rents. A property in a partially developed estate often lacks the appeal of a fully completed neighborhood.
3. Market Dynamics: The rental market in new estates is still evolving. Unlike established areas with stable rental rates, new developments are in flux. Rental prices need to reflect the transitional nature of these emerging markets, rather than being based on comparisons with more mature areas.

Smart Pricing: Finding the Right Balance

We are not suggesting that you should price your property below market value. However, it’s crucial to consider the broader context of the estate’s development. For example, if your side fence is down due to neighboring construction, this disruption can impact the attractiveness of your property. In such cases, demanding a premium rent may not be justified and can contribute to longer vacancies.

Real-Life Example: Cost of Vacancy vs. Rent Reduction

To illustrate, let’s look at a real-life example from Shoreline. Currently, a property in the development is listed for rent at $750 per week but has been sitting vacant for 10 weeks. This results in a substantial loss of $7,800 in potential rental income. In contrast, a $50 reduction in rent per week over a 12-month period would total $2,600. Clearly, accepting a modest reduction in rent can be far more cost-effective than enduring prolonged vacancies.

Strategies for Long-Term Success

To avoid the pitfalls of overpricing and make the most of your investment in a new build, consider these strategies:

1. Set Realistic Initial Rents: Begin with a rental rate that aligns with comparable properties in the suburb. Offering a lower initial rate can attract tenants more quickly and reduce vacancies, helping to generate rental income as the estate develops.
2. Remain Flexible: Monitor the market response to your property and be prepared to adjust your rental rate if needed. Flexibility in pricing will help you stay competitive and avoid prolonged vacancies.
3. Plan for Future Growth: Recognise that the value of your property will increase as the estate becomes more developed and established. Regularly review and adjust rental rates based on the growth and maturity of the neighbourhood.

Embrace a Long-Term Perspective

Investing in real estate is a long-term game. The first lease for a new build is often the hardest, but by setting realistic rents, remaining adaptable, and focusing on the estate's growth, you can navigate initial challenges effectively. Remember, while it’s important to price your property competitively, it’s equally crucial to think long-term. By adopting this perspective, you’ll ensure that your investment not only survives but thrives as the neighborhood evolves and matures.

[email protected]