Beyond the Sound: Understanding the Unseen Power of Accents

CLICK FOR SHORT VIDEO MESSAGE FROM LENORA

Cognitive bias, also called unconscious bias, plays a significant role in our daily interactions, influencing our perceptions, decisions, and judgments about others. Among the many biases that affect our decisions about others, accent bias is particularly pervasive, impacting our trust, credibility assessments, and the opportunities we afford to some people versus others.

Accent bias, also known as linguistic profiling, occurs when individuals judge others based on the way they speak. Research in sociolinguistics and psychology consistently shows that accents can profoundly influence our perceptions of intelligence, professionalism, and trustworthiness. For instance, a 2013 study by Lev-Ari and Keysar found that individuals with foreign accents were perceived as less truthful, not because of the content of their statements, but because the cognitive effort required to process accented speech made listeners more likely to doubt their veracity. Our brains use more energy to decipher words spoken different from the way we are accustomed to hearing them, thus distrust is often triggered.

When I was young child, my grandfather constantly corrected my pronunciation. He would say, “Speak the king’s English.” I was too young to understand why my grandfather did not want me to develop a New Jersey accent, and I am sure he did not know about linguistic research, but he did know how people responded to accents.

The British accent has long been associated with authority, intelligence, and reliability. This perception is not coincidental but deeply rooted in historical and cultural contexts. During the British Empire, English and its associated accents became symbols of power, prestige, and education. As English spread across the globe, this accent retained its status as the “standard” or “proper” form of English, a notion perpetuated by media, literature, and education systems worldwide. In England, there is a microadvantage afforded to people whose accent is closest to the “royal accent.”

Media representation has further cemented the trust and prestige associated with British accents. Characters portrayed with this accent in films, television, and radio are often cast in roles of authority, such as leaders, doctors, or other professionals, reinforcing the association between the accent and competence. Moreover, the British accent’s prevalence in educational materials, particularly in English language learning resources, establishes it early on as a model of clarity and correctness.

Why then are British accents so readily trusted by Westerners and others? The answer lies in the interplay of cognitive bias and cultural conditioning. When we encounter a British accent, our brains automatically access a web of associated positive traits (intelligence, authority, reliability) due to repeated cultural and media reinforcement. This automatic processing, influences our judgment subconsciously, leading us to trust the speaker more readily than we might someone with a different accent.

Accent bias towards British English underscores a broader cognitive bias phenomenon where familiarity, repetition, and cultural prestige shape our perceptions. This cognitive shortcut allows us to make quick judgments, which, while useful in some contexts, can lead to unfair assessments and missed opportunities when it comes to interacting with individuals from diverse linguistic backgrounds.

Understanding the impact of accent bias is crucial for fostering more equitable and inclusive interactions and decisions about colleagues and acquaintances. It calls for a critical examination of our unconscious biases and a commitment to valuing content and character over the superficial cues of accent.

As individuals, we can expand our brain’s accent capacity by intentionally listening to others whose accent is different from our own. Business leaders, educators, and media executives can play a role in dismantling accent bias by promoting linguistic diversity and challenging stereotypes associated with non-standard accents. By critically examining and challenging these biases, we can move towards more inclusive and equitable social interactions. In a world that is increasingly interconnected, the ability to look beyond superficial judgments is a necessity for fostering understanding and cooperation across cultural divides.