Beyond the Job Description: Reinventing Skills-Based Hiring Through Career Design

by Nicholas Alexander Singh

Skills-based hiring—a term that's been bandied about more than a hawker centre's last plate of char kway teow. While the concept sounds promising, the execution often feels like assembling flat-pack furniture without instructions. Many organisations in Singapore have embraced skills-based hiring with gusto, only to find themselves tangled in a web of unfulfilled expectations and mismatched talent. It's time to rethink the narrative and approach hiring through a fresh lens: career design.

The Promise and Pitfalls of Skills-Based Hiring

Skills-based hiring aims to strip away traditional credentials and focus on what truly matters—an individual’s ability to perform specific tasks. For instance, a 2022 LinkedIn report found that companies prioritising skills over degrees saw a 20% increase in candidate diversity and a 15% improvement in employee retention. Such data underscores its transformative potential, but how it’s implemented makes all the difference. On paper, it’s a modern, meritocratic approach to talent acquisition. Yet, despite its merits, many organisations find themselves grappling with common challenges:

1. Overwhelming Complexity

• Creating exhaustive skills lists for roles can overwhelm both hiring managers and candidates. In practice, this often leads to paralysis rather than precision. Organisations inadvertently filter out candidates who might not tick every box but possess the potential to excel.

2. Rigid Assessment Frameworks

• Reliance on standardised assessments or tools can reduce the hiring process to a box-ticking exercise. While these frameworks aim to ensure fairness, they often fail to account for human nuance, such as creativity, adaptability, and emotional intelligence.

3. Disconnect Outcomes

• Skills-based hiring is often treated as an end in itself, rather than part of a broader strategy. Organisations miss the opportunity to connect hiring with long-term workforce development and business goals.

Career Design: A Game-Changer for Talent Acquisition

Enter career design, an approach rooted in the principles of intentional planning and alignment. Popularised by Bill Burnett and Dave Evans in Designing Your Life, this methodology emphasises purpose, adaptability, and growth. Applying career design to hiring doesn’t just fill vacancies—it builds sustainable talent pipelines and fosters employee satisfaction.

Here’s how integrating career design principles can transform your hiring practices:

1. Shift the Focus from Roles to Journeys

• Traditional hiring often concentrates on matching candidates to predefined roles. Career design, by contrast, encourages viewing each hire as part of a larger journey, which can significantly impact employee retention and satisfaction. By framing roles as stepping stones within a candidate’s career path, organisations can foster a sense of purpose and commitment, leading to a more engaged and loyal workforce. This involves understanding candidates’ aspirations and aligning them with organisational objectives.

Practical Application:

• Implement Career Path Mapping: Develop clear career progression pathways within your organisation. For example, a junior analyst role could have a defined trajectory leading to senior analyst, then manager, and so on. This transparency helps candidates envision their future with your company.

• Conduct Aspirational Interviews: Beyond assessing skills, engage candidates in conversations about their long-term career goals. This approach not only aids in role alignment but also demonstrates your commitment to their professional growth.

2. Prioritise Transferable Skills and Potential

While technical skills remain essential, the ability to adapt, learn, and collaborate often predicts long-term success. Career design prioritises these transferable skills and views technical expertise as something that can be cultivated.

Practical Application:

• Utilise Simulation-Based Assessments: Instead of traditional interviews, incorporate simulation exercises that mirror real job scenarios. For instance, a project management candidate might be tasked with creating a project plan for a hypothetical product launch, allowing you to assess problem-solving and adaptability in action.

• Offer Skill-Building Workshops: Post-hire, provide workshops focusing on critical skills like communication, leadership, and technical proficiencies. This investment not only enhances employee capabilities but also reinforces your commitment to their development.

3. Design Roles with Flexibility and Resilience

The rapid pace of change in today’s job market demands flexibility. Roles that are too narrowly defined risk becoming obsolete. For example, consider a customer service role that initially required handling phone inquiries. With the rise of digital transformation, organisations that adapted this role to include chat support and social media engagement ensured its relevance and provided employees with opportunities to develop versatile communication skills. Such flexibility fosters both organisational agility and employee growth. Career design embraces flexibility by designing positions that allow for evolution and cross-functional collaboration.

Practical Application:

• Implement Cross-Functional Projects: Encourage employees to participate in projects outside their immediate roles. This exposure broadens their skill sets and fosters a culture of collaboration.

• Adopt Agile Methodologies: Apply agile principles to role design, allowing for iterative changes based on business needs and employee feedback. This approach ensures roles remain relevant and employees stay engaged.

4. Align Hiring with Organisational Purpose

Today’s workforce is increasingly driven by purpose. Career design emphasises connecting individual aspirations with organisational values, creating a shared sense of mission.

Practical Application:

• Develop Purpose-Driven Job Descriptions: Craft job postings that highlight how the role contributes to the company’s broader mission. For example, instead of a generic "Sales Manager," describe how the role helps bring innovative products to market that improve customers' lives.

• Host Purpose Workshops: Organise sessions where employees can discuss and align their personal values with the company’s mission. This alignment fosters a deeper connection to the organisation and enhances job satisfaction.

5. Measure Success Holistically

Most hiring metrics focus on efficiency—time-to-fill, cost-per-hire, etc. Career design shifts the focus to outcomes such as employee satisfaction, retention, and internal mobility.

Practical Application:

• Implement 360-Degree Feedback: Regularly collect feedback from peers, subordinates, and supervisors to gain a comprehensive view of an employee’s performance and development needs.

• Track Internal Mobility Rates: Monitor how often employees move within the organisation. High internal mobility can indicate a healthy, dynamic work environment where employees see opportunities for growth.

The Singapore Context: Challenges and Opportunities

Adopting a career design approach in Singapore requires adapting to local nuances. For instance, Singapore’s ageing workforce is a critical concern. According to the Singapore Department of Statistics, the median age of the resident workforce increased from 39.5 years in 2010 to 42.2 years in 2020. This demographic shift necessitates a focus on reskilling and creating roles that accommodate older workers. Organisations like DBS Bank have implemented initiatives to upskill older employees, ensuring they remain valuable contributors.

Conclusion

In the ever-evolving landscape of talent acquisition, career design offers a strategic framework that transcends traditional hiring practices. DM me to discuss further.

Citations

BCG Global

Competence over Credentials: The Rise of Skills-Based Hiring | BCG

Know the skills you need. Our research shows that skills-based job ads include a higher number of skills than traditional job ads. Traditional ...

Macdonald & Company

Hiring Trends Shaping Singapore and Southeast Asia's Recruitment ...

Explore key hiring trends in Singapore and Southeast Asia, including skills-based hiring, work-life balance, and evolving job market needs.

SkillsFuture SG

[PDF] SKILLS DEMAND FOR THE FUTURE ECONOMY

SkillsFuture Singapore (SSG) conducted a study using 11 years' worth of job posting data, to investigate the changes in skills required by Singapore's economy ...

SkillsFuture SG

[PDF] Skills-First Workplace - SKILLSFUTURE JOBS-SKILLS INSIGHTS

According to a LinkedIn Workplace Learning report, the skill requirements for jobs have changed by 25% since 2015, a figure projected to double by 2027.

GovInsider

Singapore employers need to hire on skills, beyond degrees, to ...

There was a 5.3 per cent increase in degree requirements for hiring in Singapore. On the other hand, its counterparts in the US, UK and ...

Infocomm Media Development Authority

Skills-Based Hiring for Tech Roles - IMDA

Learn how you can address skill gaps in your organisation and benefit from skills-based hiring.

Infocomm Media Development Authority

Over 100 Companies Pledge to Adjust Hiring Practices - IMDA

As Singapore's economy digitalises at scale, we see an increasing demand for tech professionals, accounting for 5.2% of total employment today.

TestGorilla

Is skills-based hiring the latest APAC hiring trend? - TestGorilla

According to NTUC LearningHub's Emerging Jobs and Skills report, as of 2021, 79% of employers are looking to hire talent with a broader set of skills for ...

BCG Global

Competence over Credentials: The Rise of Skills-Based Hiring | BCG

Know the skills you need. Our research shows that skills-based job ads include a higher number of skills than traditional job ads. Traditional ...

Hatch - Your Digital Journey

Skills-based hiring: a practical, modern approach to talent recruitment

As of June 2020, we reached an unemployment rate of 2.9% (according to the latest MOM statistics), the highest it has been since 2010. What's worth notin