When Lou Gerstner was given the mantle to turnaround IBM, he did so by steadily changing the Culture of IBM. Changing the Culture of a company is the most difficult endeavour of a turnaround CEO.
Culture is the sum total of values, beliefs, attitudes and behaviors that characterise the functioning of the organisation. Culture sets the tone for how a company operates and how individuals within the company interact.
The single most debilitating factor for any company can be its Culture. Culture takes shape over a long period of time. Once entrenched, it becomes seemingly impossible to change the Culture. Whilst good Culture works towards the progress of the company, poor Culture works towards the ruin of the company.
What practices lead to a poor Culture in any company ? Startups/SMEs should keep in mind the good practices during the formative years of their companies when Culture starts taking shape.
Poor Culture in any company can be due to the following factors:
- Toxic top management - attitude and behaviour
- Toxic HR - attitude and behavior
- Discrimination based on gender, origin, region etc
- Favoritism, partiality to select employees
- Lack of transparency between management and employees
- Lack of diversity - gender, region, institution
- Absence of true values - ethics/integrity/Iegality/respect/privacy/professionalism
- Top management not walking the talk - preaching a lot of things, practicing nothing
- Spying on employees
- Encouraging bad attitude - Tolerance of bad attitude of performers
- Lack of trust factor between management and employees
- Belittling employees openly
- Sharing bad feedback about employees to others
- Harassment of employees who quit
- Encouragement of groupism
- Encouragement of bad and negative politics
- Constant comparison of employees
- Tolerance of nonperformance
- Hiring top management relatives as employees who do not fit into the slots
- Lack of enforcement of discipline (timing, dress code etc) and loosened code of conduct
- Inappropriate personal relationships between hierarchies
- Managers manage personal matters during office time
- Personal relationships seep into professional workplace
- Forcing employees to work on holidays constantly, overwork leading to burnouts
- Micromanagement by top management
- Excessively frugal expense management
- Inappropriate language and bossy communication by top management
- Disregard for employee grievance and feedback leading to disgruntled employees
- Hiring new employees at much higher salaries and perks with no marked difference in skillsets, experience level when compared to existing employees
- Very high salaries (above market standard) to top management and very low salaries (below market standard) to rest of employees
- Indiscriminate hiring and firing of employees
- Managers are hired through internal references but without background checks and no proven track record
- Increments and Promotions to employees based on the whims and fancies of managers - subjective instead of objective performance appraisal framework
- No employee recognition and reward
- Management philosophy - Performance "at any cost"
- Fixed mindset of management instead of growth mindset
- Profit orientation of management with no regard for customer or employee satisfaction
- Top managers have their own silo-divisions wielding their authority, power and influence - driven primarily by egoism/egotism
- Poor managerial skills at the top leading to poor decision making
- Centralised decision making by top management with no delegation of decision making to junior as well as middle management
- Lack of communication from top management
- Dictator style of leadership leading to "yes-men" culture
- Flawed policies, strong and rigid procedures leading to bureaucracy and unfavorable to employees
- Gossips, rumours, passive aggression, cliques leading to insecurity amongst the employees
- Lack of team spirit, collaboration and camaraderie among the employees
- Lack of stimulation for employees to enjoy their work - "all work and no play"
- Lack of clarity regarding chain of command, hierarchy, roles and responsibilities
- Fear of failure amongst employees due to high degree of penalisation
- Low employee morale due to management's indifference and callousness
- Prevalence of Zero-sum and Win-lose relationship
These form an exhaustive list of bad practices that I have witnessed in different companies during my stint with them in different capacities in my career so far. We may not find all of the above in one single company. However, they are present in one form or another across different companies. It is impossible to eradicate all of the above in any company. But Top management and HR can attempt to nullify or reduce some of them.
In the absence of good culture, the company will be able to attract only desperate candidates. Good candidates refrain from joining a company with a poor culture. Top management as well HR play a very crucial role in determining, shaping and sustaining a good work culture.
If culture is lost, then the company will invariably head towards a catastrophe.