Becoming Unapologetic: The CEO's Rite of Passage in Company Culture Evolution

This article is part of the "Dear Founders and CEOs" series—a collection tailored for Founders and CEOs of fast-scaling tech companies. Dive into HR strategies that fuel sustainable business growth and empower organizations to conquer the challenges of scaling head-on.

Scaling SaaS companies, perpetually in pursuit of customer acquisition, product innovation, and market expansion, often unintentionally overshadow an equally crucial facet: the evolution of their company culture. This change - a shift from the warm, embracing 'family' feel towards a more rigorous, performance-based team dynamic - is the unsung hero in the narrative of organizational transformation. This change in culture is far from a sign of loss or dilution. It is, instead, a sign of maturation, mirroring the organization's growth trajectory.

Cultural Evolution: The Game Changer

In the SaaS landscape, culture plays a pivotal role. It serves as the organization's DNA, providing a blueprint for how it operates and evolves over time. However, when a company shifts from a startup to a mature, late-stage entity, there's a tendency to lament the 'loss' of the original culture, seen as a betrayal of the founding values.

Such a sentiment, while understandable, often stems from a misconception about what company culture represents. It's not a static, immutable entity but an evolving ecosystem that reflects the organization's progression and maturing dynamics. This evolution is not a loss but rather an opportunity to redefine how foundational values translate into the current and future context.

Assessing Loyalty and Building Resilience

Just as a team's roster changes with each season based on performance, and strategic needs, so does the makeup of a company. With the transition towards maturity, the company's talent density increases, and experienced specialists are introduced in lieu of generalists. The emphasis shifts to retaining exceptional performers, with higher attrition of average and low performers being an accepted - and necessary - part of the process.

This phase inevitably tests loyalty. The ambassadors of the company's early days may find themselves grappling with the new realities, sometimes fostering a toxic attitude. Yet, it's during these phases that true loyalty is revealed. Those willing to grow and adapt will embrace the new dynamics, while those resistant to change may need to be managed differently.

A quick note: startups often romanticize the 'family' culture, but it's a paradigm that can do more harm than good. Families function on unconditional love, whereas companies, particularly those in growth or late stages, resemble sports teams more closely, where performance and growth are the conditional variables. Just as sports teams trade players, companies must be willing to let go and bring in new talents as required for the company's growth.

The CEO's Journey: Navigating Common Fears

During periods of cultural change, most CEOs will have to deal with one or more of the following fears:?

• Fear of Culture Loss: Fear is one of the first emotions that a CEO encounters on this journey. The fear of losing the 'culture that made us what we are' is potent and pervasive. When long-tenured employees express concern that "we're losing our culture", it can strike a chord, undermining a CEO's confidence and creating a sense of impending doom.

• Perceived Betrayal: The second emotion lurking in this journey's shadows is a sense of perceived betrayal. As the organization evolves, the CEO might fear losing friends and allies among long-term employees. This fear is particularly acute when loyal employees express dissatisfaction with the changes.

• Fear of Being a Sell-Out: Finally, CEOs might fear being seen as a 'sell-out.' Criticisms from employees, implying that revenue and profit now drive the company's actions rather than its core values, can instigate self-doubt. This fear is exacerbated when employees express feelings that the company has lost its values and become 'too corporate.'

To navigate this emotional terrain, a CEO needs to embrace these fears rather than avoiding them. It is a phase that most CEOs undergo, and it's essential to accept it as part of the journey rather than a deviation. One of the most effective ways to do this is to connect with an executive community or seek the counsel of CEOs who have weathered similar storms. Their experiences and insights can provide the necessary guidance and reassurance that the CEO is on the right track.

Having acknowledged and addressed their own emotional journey, CEOs can then focus on the second part of the equation: dealing with their employees.

Emotional Transition: Employees

• Clarifying the Evolution: The first action item for CEOs is to clarify and communicate the nature of the culture shift. The move from a 'family' atmosphere to a high-performance team isn't a loss of the original values, but a transformation required to support the company's growth. CEOs need to express this clearly to their employees and reinforce that this shift is a necessary aspect of the company's evolution.

• Promote Understanding: It's crucial to foster understanding among the employees about the changing dynamics. CEOs can help their teams understand that the new structure aims to retain exceptional performers and increase the company's talent density, an important growth catalyst. This discussion may include the necessity of higher attrition among average and low performers and the strategic needs driving these decisions.

• Manage Resistance: CEOs must prepare for resistance, especially from long-term employees who may feel displaced or uncomfortable with the changes. This resistance can sometimes become toxic, affecting the team's morale and productivity. Managing this resistance might involve difficult conversations and decisions, but CEOs need to remember that these steps are essential for the company's growth and success.

• Nurture Adaptability: It's also important to nurture a culture of adaptability. CEOs should encourage their teams to embrace change, viewing it not as a threat but as an opportunity for growth and improvement. They should commend employees who demonstrate resilience and adaptability and provide support to those who are struggling with the transition.

• Foster a Performance-Oriented Culture: Lastly, CEOs need to promote a performance-based culture, akin to a sports team, where employees' contributions are valued based on their performance and contribution to the team's goals. This transition can be challenging for some, but it's an essential part of creating a high-performance culture that can drive the company's growth and success.

In conclusion, transitioning from a familial culture to a performance-based culture is a complex rite of passage of all successful CEOs. It involves navigating one's own emotional terrain and effectively managing the emotions and reactions of the employees. The key is to remain unapologetic, resilient, and embrace the change, shaping the culture that will carry the company forward.

Have you traveled this road? What were the unexpected turns you navigated? The triumphs and tribulations that marked your journey? I invite you to share your insights and experiences in the comments below. Let's learn from each other's journeys, and help the community to better traverse this path of cultural transformation.

If you found value in this article, please express it with a like, a share, or a repost. The challenges of evolving company culture are universal, yet often undertold. By sharing this narrative, we can help to bring this conversation to the fore, aiding CEOs and founders across the globe.

Finally, remember to subscribe to our newsletter for more insights, stories, and strategies curated for you, the modern-day SaaS leader.?