Banking the Unbanked: The Digital Microfinance Revolution in Third World Countries
Andre Ripla PgCert, PgDip
AI | Automation | BI | Digital Transformation | Process Reengineering | RPA | ITBP | MBA candidate | Strategic & Transformational IT. Creates Efficient IT Teams Delivering Cost Efficiencies, Business Value & Innovation
Introduction
Financial inclusion—the provision of affordable, accessible, and relevant financial services to all segments of society—remains one of the most significant developmental challenges of the 21st century. Approximately 1.4 billion adults globally remain unbanked, with the majority residing in developing countries (World Bank, 2021). This exclusion from formal financial services creates insurmountable barriers to economic participation, vulnerability management, and social mobility for billions of people.
Microfinance, since its formalization in the 1970s, has aimed to address this exclusion by providing small-scale financial services to low-income individuals typically ignored by traditional banking institutions. However, the conventional brick-and-mortar microfinance model has faced significant limitations in scale, efficiency, and reach. High operational costs, geographical constraints, and labor-intensive processes have restricted the sector's ability to serve the most marginalized populations effectively.
The digital revolution has ushered in a transformative era for microfinance, fundamentally reshaping how financial services can be delivered to previously excluded populations. Digital technologies—from mobile phones and digital payment systems to artificial intelligence and blockchain—offer unprecedented opportunities to overcome traditional barriers to financial inclusion. By leveraging these technologies, microfinance institutions (MFIs) and financial service providers can dramatically reduce costs, extend geographical reach, customize products, and improve service delivery.
This analysis examines how the digitalization of microfinance services and products is ensuring financial inclusion for low-income earners in developing countries. It explores the evolution of microfinance in the digital age, analyzes the specific mechanisms through which digital technologies address financial exclusion, presents global case studies of successful digital microfinance initiatives, evaluates impact metrics, and examines challenges and future trends. Through this comprehensive analysis, the essay demonstrates that digital microfinance represents one of the most promising pathways to achieving universal financial inclusion and, by extension, more equitable economic development across the Global South.
Understanding Microfinance in the Digital Age
Evolution of Microfinance
The modern microfinance movement traces its origins to the 1970s, when Muhammad Yunus established Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, pioneering the concept of providing small loans to groups of women without requiring traditional collateral. This innovation demonstrated that the poor were creditworthy and that microfinance could be financially sustainable while addressing poverty. The model spread globally throughout the 1980s and 1990s, with microfinance institutions (MFIs) emerging across Asia, Africa, and Latin America.
Traditional microfinance typically operated through a high-touch, relationship-based model characterized by:
While this model achieved significant success in extending financial services to previously excluded populations, it faced inherent limitations in scale, efficiency, and cost. The high operational expenses associated with traditional microfinance translated into higher interest rates for borrowers and constrained the sector's ability to reach the most remote or impoverished communities.
By the early 2000s, the microfinance industry had begun exploring digital solutions to overcome these limitations. The proliferation of mobile phones in developing countries, even among low-income populations, presented a particularly promising channel for extending financial services beyond physical infrastructure.
The Digital Transformation Journey
The digital transformation of microfinance has not been a single leap but rather an evolutionary process that continues today. This journey can be conceptualized in several stages:
Stage 1: Basic Digitization (Early 2000s) The initial phase focused on digitizing internal processes within MFIs. This included:
This stage primarily improved operational efficiency but had limited direct impact on client experience or outreach.
Stage 2: Mobile Revolution (Mid-2000s to Early 2010s) The explosive growth of mobile phone ownership in developing countries catalyzed the next stage of transformation, marked by:
This stage significantly expanded access points and reduced transaction costs for both providers and clients.
Stage 3: Comprehensive Digital Financial Services (2010s) Building on mobile infrastructure, providers began developing comprehensive digital financial ecosystems:
This stage enabled greater personalization and product diversification.
Stage 4: Advanced Technologies and Embedded Finance (Current) The latest phase leverages cutting-edge technologies and embedded finance approaches:
This stage is blurring the lines between traditional financial services and other aspects of the digital economy.
Key Digital Technologies in Microfinance
Several core digital technologies underpin the transformation of microfinance services:
Mobile Technology Mobile phones serve as the primary interface between microfinance providers and clients in many developing countries. Beyond basic feature phones supporting SMS and USSD services, smartphone penetration is increasing even among low-income populations, enabling more sophisticated applications. Mobile technology facilitates:
Cloud Computing Cloud-based solutions allow MFIs to access sophisticated technology infrastructure without major capital investments:
Data Analytics and Artificial Intelligence Advanced data analysis techniques enable microfinance providers to:
Digital Payment Systems Digital payment infrastructure serves as the backbone of digital financial services:
Biometric Identification Biometric technology addresses identification challenges in countries with limited formal ID systems:
Blockchain and Distributed Ledger Technology Though still emerging in microfinance applications, blockchain offers potential benefits:
The strategic integration of these technologies has fundamentally altered the economics and reach of microfinance, enabling providers to serve previously excluded populations in ways that were unimaginable in the traditional model.
The Financial Inclusion Challenge in Developing Countries
Defining Financial Exclusion
Financial exclusion refers to the inability of individuals, households, or businesses to access appropriate and affordable financial services that meet their needs. This exclusion is not binary but exists on a spectrum, with varying degrees of access and usage across different financial products and services.
The multidimensional nature of financial exclusion encompasses:
In developing countries, financial exclusion disproportionately affects certain demographics, including:
The World Bank's Global Findex database provides the most comprehensive measure of financial inclusion globally. According to the 2021 Global Findex data, approximately 1.4 billion adults remain unbanked worldwide, with the highest concentrations in Sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, and parts of Southeast Asia. Even among those who have basic access, usage remains limited—many accounts are dormant or used only for specific purposes like receiving government payments.
Barriers to Financial Inclusion
Multiple interconnected barriers perpetuate financial exclusion in developing countries:
Supply-Side Barriers
Demand-Side Barriers
Infrastructural Barriers
The Cost of Financial Exclusion
Financial exclusion imposes substantial costs on individuals, communities, and economies:
Individual and Household Level Impacts
Broader Economic and Social Costs
The Asian Development Bank estimates that addressing financial exclusion in developing Asia could increase GDP by 9-14%, highlighting the macroeconomic significance of expanding financial inclusion. Similarly, research by the McKinsey Global Institute suggests that widespread digital financial services could increase the GDP of emerging economies by $3.7 trillion by 2025.
How Digital Microfinance Addresses Financial Inclusion
Digital technologies enable microfinance providers to overcome traditional barriers to financial inclusion through several interconnected mechanisms:
Overcoming Physical Barriers
Extended Reach Without Physical Infrastructure
Digital channels eliminate the need for physical proximity between financial service providers and clients. This transformation is particularly significant in rural and remote areas where establishing conventional branches would be economically unfeasible.
Mobile phones serve as "branches in pockets," allowing customers to conduct transactions from anywhere with cellular coverage. In Tanzania, for example, more than 80% of the population lives within 5 kilometers of a mobile money agent, compared to just 17% within the same distance of a bank branch (FSDT, 2019).
Agent Networks as Physical Touchpoints
Digital microfinance models typically leverage networks of agents—local shopkeepers, retailers, or dedicated representatives equipped with digital tools—who serve as cash-in/cash-out points and sometimes provide additional services like account opening or loan applications.
These agent networks significantly extend the reach of financial services at a fraction of the cost of traditional branches. In Bangladesh, bKash's network of over 230,000 agents has made financial services accessible within a short walking distance for most of the population, even in rural areas. The operational cost per transaction through an agent is estimated to be 50-70% lower than through a traditional branch.
24/7 Service Availability
Unlike physical branches with limited operating hours, digital platforms provide round-the-clock service availability. This temporal accessibility is particularly valuable for clients with irregular working hours or those who cannot afford to take time off to visit a branch during business hours.
Research from Kenya shows that over 30% of M-Pesa transactions occur outside traditional banking hours, demonstrating the importance of time flexibility in serving low-income populations (Cook & McKay, 2017).
Reducing Costs and Increasing Affordability
Lower Operational Costs
Digital channels dramatically reduce the cost structure of providing financial services:
A CGAP study across multiple countries found that digital channels can reduce the cost of delivering financial services by 80-90% compared to traditional branch-based operations (CGAP, 2020).
Reduced Transaction Costs for Customers
Digital financial services significantly lower the direct and indirect costs that customers incur:
In Uganda, a study by the Helix Institute found that the average cost of a digital transaction is approximately 54% lower than its cash-based equivalent when accounting for both direct fees and indirect costs.
Economies of Scale and Network Effects
Digital platforms benefit from economies of scale and network effects that allow for increasingly cost-effective service as customer bases grow:
These dynamics have enabled providers like M-Pesa to progressively reduce fees while maintaining profitability, with some basic services now offered at zero explicit cost to users.
Enhancing Product Appropriateness
Personalization Through Data
Digital microfinance leverages customer data to create more tailored financial products:
Companies like Tala and Branch use alternative data from mobile phones (with permission) to assess creditworthiness and offer personalized loan terms, with repayment rates exceeding 90% despite serving previously "unbanked" populations.
Flexible Product Design
Digital channels enable greater product flexibility to accommodate the irregular and unpredictable financial lives of low-income customers:
M-Kopa Solar's pay-as-you-go solar home systems in East Africa exemplify this flexibility, allowing customers to make micropayments for energy services based on their available resources, eventually leading to ownership of the asset.
Bundled and Integrated Services
Digital platforms facilitate the bundling of complementary financial services that address multiple needs simultaneously:
The Wave Money platform in Myanmar combines remittance services with bill payments, airtime purchases, and merchant payments in a single application, creating a comprehensive financial ecosystem accessible to low-income users.
Building Financial Capability
Embedded Financial Education
Digital platforms incorporate educational content directly into the customer experience:
Juntos Global, which partners with financial institutions in multiple countries, uses automated SMS conversations to guide customers through their financial journeys, increasing account activity by 33% on average.
Nudges and Behavioral Interventions
Digital channels enable the application of behavioral economics principles to encourage positive financial behaviors:
A study in the Philippines found that simple SMS reminders increased saving rates by 15% among microfinance clients (Karlan et al., 2016).
Progressive Capability Building
Digital microfinance platforms can implement "progressive" approaches that gradually introduce more complex financial concepts and products as customers demonstrate readiness:
JUMO's journey pathways in Africa move customers from basic services to more sophisticated offerings based on their digital financial history, with over 70% of customers progressing to higher-value services within two years.
Digital Microfinance Products and Services
The digitalization of microfinance has enabled the development of innovative products and services specifically designed to meet the needs of low-income populations in developing countries. These offerings leverage digital technologies to overcome limitations of traditional financial products while addressing the unique circumstances and preferences of previously excluded customers.
Mobile Banking and Payments
Mobile Money Accounts
Mobile money accounts represent the foundational layer of digital financial inclusion, providing basic electronic store-of-value functionality accessible through feature phones or smartphones. Key characteristics include:
GCash in the Philippines serves over 30 million users, many of whom were previously unbanked. The platform processes over $1 billion in transactions monthly, with services accessible via basic USSD technology on feature phones as well as through smartphone applications.
Peer-to-Peer Transfers
P2P transfer functionality enables direct person-to-person money movement, critical for populations that rely heavily on social networks for financial support:
EcoCash in Zimbabwe processes over 80% of all P2P transfers in the country, enabling critical financial flows during periods of cash shortages and economic volatility. The service charges as little as 1% for transfers, compared to 5-10% through traditional money transfer operators.
Bill Payments and Merchant Services
Digital payment ecosystems extend beyond P2P transfers to include:
JazzCash in Pakistan processes over 80 million monthly transactions across its ecosystem, including bill payments for over 1,500 billers and merchant payments at more than 100,000 retail locations.
International Remittances
Digital platforms increasingly facilitate cross-border remittances, a critical financial flow for many developing economies:
Wave in Senegal and C?te d'Ivoire has disrupted the remittance market by charging a flat 1% fee for remittances, compared to the global average of 7-9%, saving customers millions of dollars annually in transaction costs.
Digital Credit and Lending
Instant Nano-Loans
Digital nano-loans provide small, short-term credit instantly through mobile interfaces:
M-Shwari in Kenya, a partnership between Safaricom and NCBA Bank, has disbursed over $2.5 billion in loans to 15 million customers since launch, with 90% of loans under $30 and repayment rates exceeding 95%.
Alternative Credit Scoring
Digital lenders employ innovative approaches to assess creditworthiness beyond traditional credit bureau data:
Lenddo in Southeast Asia analyzes over 12,000 variables from digital footprints to assess credit risk, enabling lending to customers with no formal credit history at default rates comparable to traditional bank portfolios.
Supply Chain and MSME Financing
Digital platforms connect micro, small, and medium enterprises to working capital and investment financing:
Lidya in Nigeria provides working capital to small businesses based on their digital transaction history, with loan sizes ranging from $500 to $50,000 and approval times as short as 24 hours, addressing a critical financing gap for underserved MSMEs.
Group Lending 2.0
Digital technologies reimagine traditional group lending approaches:
Chama Cash in Kenya digitizes traditional rotating savings and credit associations (ROSCAs), enabling groups to manage their activities through mobile interfaces while maintaining social accountability mechanisms.
Digital Savings Products
Commitment Savings
Digital commitment savings products help customers overcome self-control challenges and build assets:
M-Tiba in Kenya combines health savings with restricted-use functionality, allowing users to save specifically for healthcare expenses with funds usable only at registered healthcare providers.
Micro-Savings
Micro-savings products capture small amounts frequently to build savings incrementally:
EasyPaisa in Pakistan offers DostiBachat, a micro-savings product that allows deposits as small as PKR 1 (less than $0.01) with no minimum balance requirements, enabling saving behaviors previously impossible through formal channels.
Group Savings
Digital group savings facilitate collective saving and borrowing among self-formed groups:
VSLA Online in Uganda digitizes Village Savings and Loan Associations, retaining their social structure while adding digital record-keeping, security, and analytics that strengthen group operations.
Programmed Withdrawals and Pension Products
Digital platforms enable long-term savings with programmed withdrawal features:
Pinbox Solutions has developed micro-pension systems deployed across multiple African and Asian countries, allowing informal sector workers to make small, flexible contributions toward retirement security.
Digital Insurance
Microinsurance Products
Digital microinsurance provides accessible protection against common risks:
BIMA provides microinsurance to over 35 million customers across 14 countries, with premiums as low as $0.60 per month collected via mobile money or airtime deduction, making formal insurance accessible to populations previously excluded from coverage.
Pay-As-You-Go and On-Demand Insurance
Flexible insurance models align with irregular incomes and specific needs:
Inclusivity Solutions in Rwanda offers on-demand health insurance that can be activated for as little as 7 days through a mobile interface, providing flexibility for customers with fluctuating income.
Parametric Insurance
Digital technologies enable parametric insurance products that automatically pay out based on predefined triggers:
ACRE Africa provides satellite-based weather insurance to over 1.7 million farmers across East Africa, with automatic payouts when rainfall falls below predefined thresholds, eliminating the need for traditional claims processes.
Bundled Insurance
Digital platforms facilitate the bundling of insurance with other products and services:
One Acre Fund bundles crop insurance with seed and fertilizer packages for smallholder farmers in East Africa, with premiums and claims managed through digital channels.
Blockchain and Cryptocurrency Applications
Digital Identity and Credit History
Blockchain technology provides secure, portable digital identities and financial histories:
BanQu creates economic identities for refugees and displaced persons across 15 countries using blockchain technology, enabling financial inclusion for populations without traditional documentation.
Cross-Border Payments
Blockchain-based remittance solutions reduce costs and increase speed for international transfers:
BitPesa (now AZA Finance) operates blockchain-based cross-border payment services across multiple African corridors, reducing transfer costs by up to 90% compared to traditional remittance providers and settling transactions in 1-2 days rather than 3-7 days.
Microasset Tokenization
Blockchain enables the fractionalization of assets into affordable digital tokens:
Agriledger uses blockchain to tokenize agricultural produce in Haiti, allowing smallholder farmers to receive financing against future harvest value and enabling fractional investment in agricultural production.
Peer-to-Peer Lending Platforms
Decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols enable peer-to-peer lending without traditional intermediaries:
Ethic Hub connects smallholder farmers in Latin America directly with global investors through a blockchain-based platform, facilitating loans at 8-15% interest compared to local rates of 60-200% from informal lenders.
Global Case Studies
The digital transformation of microfinance has manifested differently across various developing countries, influenced by local contexts, regulatory environments, technological infrastructure, and market dynamics. The following case studies illustrate successful implementations that have significantly advanced financial inclusion for low-income populations.
M-Pesa (Kenya)
Background and Development
Launched in 2007 by Safaricom, Kenya's largest mobile network operator, M-Pesa began as a simple mobile money transfer service designed to facilitate remittances from urban workers to rural families. The system was built on the existing network of airtime resellers, who were converted into cash-in/cash-out agents.
The initial technology was remarkably simple—utilizing USSD (Unstructured Supplementary Service Data) protocols that worked on basic feature phones without requiring internet connectivity. This accessibility was crucial in a market where smartphone penetration was low, particularly among lower-income segments.
Key Features and Innovations
M-Pesa's core functionality includes:
The platform has continuously evolved, adding features like:
Impact and Scale
M-Pesa's impact on financial inclusion in Kenya has been profound:
A study by Tavneet Suri and William Jack (published in Science, 2016) found that access to M-Pesa lifted approximately 2% of Kenyan households out of poverty between 2008 and 2014, with more substantial impacts for female-headed households. The resilience effects were particularly notable, with M-Pesa users able to maintain consumption levels during economic shocks.
Success Factors and Lessons
Several factors contributed to M-Pesa's extraordinary success:
The M-Pesa experience demonstrates the importance of starting with a compelling use case that addresses an immediate pain point, building a robust agent network, and gradually expanding functionality as user familiarity and trust develop.
bKash (Bangladesh)
Background and Development
Launched in 2011 as a subsidiary of BRAC Bank, bKash emerged in a country with one of the world's largest unbanked populations—over 70% of Bangladesh's 165 million citizens lacked access to formal financial services at the time. The service was developed with support from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, aiming to replicate and adapt the M-Pesa model to the Bangladeshi context.
Unlike M-Pesa, bKash began as a bank-led initiative, operating under the regulatory oversight of Bangladesh Bank from inception. This regulatory clarity provided a stable foundation for growth while ensuring consumer protection.
Key Features and Innovations
bKash offers a comprehensive suite of digital financial services:
The platform has been particularly innovative in developing partnerships, including:
Impact and Scale
bKash has achieved remarkable penetration in Bangladesh:
Research by the Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies indicates that bKash users save an average of 3.5 hours and $0.34 per transaction compared to traditional methods—significant savings in a country where the average daily wage for many workers is under $5.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, bKash played a crucial role in government stimulus distribution, with over $130 million in support payments disbursed to vulnerable populations through the platform.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key elements contributing to bKash's success include:
The bKash experience highlights the importance of institutional partnerships, regulatory engagement, and strategic international collaboration in building successful digital financial ecosystems.
Banco Compartamos (Mexico)
Background and Development
Banco Compartamos began as an NGO in 1990, focusing on group lending to women in rural Mexico. It transformed into a regulated financial institution in 2000 and became a commercial bank in 2006. While controversial for its high interest rates and 2007 IPO, Compartamos has been at the forefront of digital transformation in Latin American microfinance.
The bank's digital journey began in earnest around 2012, as it sought to address operational inefficiencies in its predominantly paper-based, high-touch group lending model. Rather than abandoning its core methodology, Compartamos digitized key elements while maintaining the social cohesion benefits of group interactions.
Key Features and Innovations
Compartamos's digital transformation has focused on several key areas:
What distinguishes Compartamos's approach is the hybrid model that combines digital efficiency with human interaction:
Impact and Scale
Compartamos serves over 2.7 million clients across Mexico, Peru, and Guatemala, with increasing digital engagement:
Research by the Financial Inclusion Equity Council found that Compartamos clients who adopted digital channels increased their average loan size by 23% compared to non-digital clients, suggesting enhanced business growth and capacity.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key insights from Compartamos's digitalization journey include:
The Compartamos case demonstrates that digitalization need not eliminate the human element of microfinance and that hybrid models can effectively combine efficiency with relationship-based lending principles.
Aadhaar and India Stack (India)
Background and Development
India's approach to financial inclusion represents a unique public infrastructure model. Rather than being led by a single institution, India has developed a comprehensive digital public infrastructure known as "India Stack"—a set of open APIs and digital public goods that enable government entities, businesses, startups, and developers to build inclusive financial services.
At the foundation of this ecosystem is Aadhaar, the world's largest biometric identification system, launched in 2009. Aadhaar provides each resident with a unique 12-digit identifier linked to demographic and biometric information, addressing the fundamental challenge of identity verification for the unbanked.
Building on this foundation, the government launched additional layers:
Key Features and Innovations
The India Stack architecture consists of four distinct layers:
This public infrastructure enables numerous innovative microfinance applications:
Impact and Scale
The scale of India's digital financial transformation is unprecedented:
The World Bank estimates that the direct cost savings from digital identity and payment infrastructure in India exceed $13 billion annually.
Success Factors and Lessons
Critical elements in India's success include:
The India case demonstrates the potential of government-led digital public infrastructure to accelerate financial inclusion at national scale, creating the foundation upon which private providers can build innovative services.
JUMO (Multiple African Countries)
Background and Development
JUMO, founded in 2015, represents a new generation of digital financial service providers that are "born digital" rather than digitizing existing operations. Operating as a technology company rather than a traditional financial institution, JUMO develops data-driven financial service platforms that enable banks, mobile network operators, and other partners to offer digital financial products to underserved customers.
The company began in Tanzania and has since expanded to Ghana, Uganda, Kenya, Zambia, C?te d'Ivoire, and Pakistan. Rather than building its own customer base, JUMO partners with established entities with large customer networks—particularly mobile network operators—to extend financial services to their existing users.
Key Features and Innovations
JUMO's platform incorporates several innovative elements:
JUMO's product offerings include:
Impact and Scale
JUMO has achieved significant scale across its markets:
Research by the Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) found that JUMO borrowers in Tanzania increased their business revenue by an average of 31% after six months of engagement with the platform.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key elements of JUMO's successful approach include:
The JUMO case illustrates the potential of technology-driven platforms to rapidly scale financial inclusion through partnerships with established networks and sophisticated data analytics.
Ant Financial (China)
Background and Development
While China is not typically categorized as a "third world" country, Ant Financial's approach to serving financially excluded populations offers valuable lessons applicable to developing markets. Emerging from Alipay, the payment platform established by Alibaba in 2004, Ant Financial has evolved into a comprehensive digital financial services ecosystem serving hundreds of millions of users, many previously excluded from traditional banking.
Ant's development path reflects the evolution of digital microfinance itself—beginning with payments, expanding to savings and wealth management, adding credit products, and eventually incorporating insurance and more sophisticated financial services.
Key Features and Innovations
Ant Financial's ecosystem incorporates several innovative approaches:
The platform is distinguished by its comprehensive ecosystem approach, connecting multiple services through shared data and infrastructure:
Impact and Scale
Ant Financial's reach in China is extraordinary:
A Stanford study found that MYbank's lending increased recipients' business revenue by 8-10% on average, with higher impacts for smaller enterprises and those in less developed regions.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key elements of Ant Financial's approach include:
While Ant Financial's model emerged in China's unique technology and regulatory environment, its approach to ecosystem building, alternative credit assessment, and incremental financial inclusion offers valuable insights for digital microfinance globally.
Tala (Kenya, Mexico, Philippines, India)
Background and Development
Founded in 2011 (originally as InVenture), Tala represents the fintech approach to microfinance—leveraging mobile technology, alternative data, and automated processes to provide instant credit to underbanked populations. Unlike traditional microfinance institutions or bank-led initiatives, Tala began as a standalone mobile application focused exclusively on digital lending.
The company initially launched in Kenya before expanding to the Philippines, Mexico, and India. Rather than relying on traditional credit information or collateral, Tala pioneered the use of smartphone data (with user permission) to assess creditworthiness and deliver instant loans directly to mobile money accounts.
Key Features and Innovations
Tala's model incorporates several innovative elements:
The core Tala product has evolved to include:
Impact and Scale
Tala has achieved significant reach across its markets:
A study by the Financial Inclusion Lab found that 62% of Tala customers in Kenya used their loans for business purposes, with 33% reporting job creation as a direct result of access to finance.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key elements of Tala's approach include:
The Tala case demonstrates the potential of technology-driven, data-centric approaches to extend financial services to previously excluded populations without requiring traditional financial infrastructure or credit history.
Wave (Senegal, C?te d'Ivoire)
Background and Development
Wave, founded in 2018, represents one of the newest entrants in the digital microfinance landscape, focusing on building an ultra-low-cost mobile money service for West Africa. Unlike many digital financial services that evolved from banks or telecom companies, Wave was established specifically to address the high cost of financial services in the region.
The company began operations in Senegal before expanding to C?te d'Ivoire, with a deliberate focus on making transactions as affordable and accessible as possible. Wave's unique approach includes operating its own agent network rather than partnering with existing retail outlets, and building a business model sustainable at much lower fee levels than incumbents.
Key Features and Innovations
Wave's model incorporates several distinctive elements:
Wave's product suite remains deliberately streamlined, focusing on core financial needs:
Impact and Scale
Despite its relatively recent launch, Wave has achieved rapid scale:
Research by the Stanford Social Innovation Review estimates that Wave has saved customers over $300 million in fees through its lower-cost model.
Success Factors and Lessons
Key elements of Wave's successful approach include:
The Wave case demonstrates that even in markets with established mobile money providers, innovative business models can create new opportunities for financial inclusion by drastically reducing costs and simplifying user experience.
Impact Metrics and Assessment
Evaluating the impact of digital microfinance on financial inclusion requires a multidimensional approach that captures both quantitative and qualitative changes. While the specific metrics and assessment methodologies vary across contexts, several key categories of measurement provide insight into the effectiveness of digital microfinance initiatives.
Quantitative Metrics of Financial Inclusion
Access Indicators
Access metrics measure the basic availability and uptake of financial services:
The Global Findex database provides the most comprehensive global measurements of these indicators. Between 2011 and 2021, the percentage of adults in developing economies with an account rose from 42% to 71%, with digital financial services driving much of this growth. In Sub-Saharan Africa, the share of adults with a mobile money account grew from 12% in 2014 to 33% in 2021.
Usage Indicators
Usage metrics move beyond access to measure actual utilization of financial services:
The GSMA Mobile Money Metrics report indicates that active mobile money accounts (those with at least one transaction in 90 days) grew from 134 million in 2017 to 372 million in 2022, with transaction values increasing from $26 billion to $87 billion monthly during the same period.
Affordability Indicators
Affordability metrics assess the cost barriers to financial services:
A study by CGAP across 15 developing countries found that the average cost of sending a domestic remittance fell from 6.7% of the transaction value in 2014 to 3.1% in 2020, primarily due to digital channels.
Quality and Appropriateness Indicators
These metrics evaluate how well financial services meet customer needs:
A 60 Decibels survey across digital financial services in eight African countries found that 71% of customers reported that digital products were better than available alternatives, with convenience and time savings cited as primary benefits.
Economic Impact Indicators
Income and Business Performance
These metrics assess the economic benefits of financial inclusion:
A randomized control trial in Uganda found that access to digital loans through JUMO increased micro-merchant profits by 15% compared to control groups, primarily through inventory optimization enabled by timely access to working capital.
Consumption Smoothing
These measurements evaluate resilience to economic shocks:
Research in Kenya found that M-Pesa users were able to maintain 12% higher consumption levels during negative income shocks compared to non-users, demonstrating the resilience benefits of digital financial access.
Cost Savings
Cost metrics evaluate efficiency gains from digital services:
A study in Bangladesh found that digital wage payments saved garment workers an average of 2 hours per month and reduced collection costs by 90% compared to cash disbursements, representing significant value for low-income workers.
Asset Accumulation
These indicators measure wealth building over time:
Research in Tanzania found that users of digital savings products increased household assets by 16% over two years compared to non-users, with particularly strong effects for female-headed households.
Social Impact Measurements
Women's Economic Empowerment
Gender-specific metrics assess the impact on women's financial inclusion:
The 2021 Global Findex found that gender gaps in account ownership narrowed from 9 percentage points to 6 percentage points in developing economies between 2017 and 2021, with the gap closing entirely in some markets with strong mobile money adoption.
Vulnerability Reduction
These metrics evaluate how financial inclusion affects vulnerability:
A study in India found that direct benefit transfers through digital accounts reduced dependence on informal loans by 12% among recipient households, with particularly strong effects during agricultural off-seasons.
Social Capital and Community Effects
These indicators assess broader social impacts:
Research in rural Kenya found that villages with high M-Pesa penetration experienced 60% more business establishments than comparable areas with lower digital financial services adoption.
Formalization and Digital Inclusion
These metrics evaluate progression toward formal economic participation:
A study across six developing countries found that small businesses accepting digital payments were 37% more likely to register formally and 23% more likely to maintain business records compared to cash-only businesses.
Gender-Specific Outcomes
Given the particularly large financial inclusion gaps facing women in many developing countries, specific measurement of gender-related impacts is crucial for comprehensive assessment.
Access and Agency Gains
These metrics focus on women's control and decision-making:
Research by Women's World Banking found that women using digital financial services reported 32% higher financial autonomy scores compared to those using only cash or informal financial mechanisms.
Economic Participation Shifts
These indicators track women's economic activity changes:
A study in India found that access to digital financial services increased women's business ownership by 7 percentage points and shifted female employment from agricultural labor to entrepreneurship.
Intra-household Dynamics
These metrics assess changes in household power structures:
Research in Bangladesh found that women with private digital savings accounts increased their influence over household expenditure decisions by 18%, with particular gains in education spending for daughters.
Intersectional Considerations
These measurements recognize the compounded barriers facing certain groups:
A CGAP study across multiple African countries found that digital financial services closed 40% of the rural-urban financial access gap for women, compared to just 13% through traditional banking channels.
Challenges and Limitations
Despite the significant potential of digital microfinance to advance financial inclusion, important challenges and limitations must be addressed to ensure equitable, responsible, and sustainable progress.
Digital Divide and Technology Access
Connectivity Gaps
While mobile network coverage has expanded dramatically, significant gaps remain:
The GSMA reports that while 95% of the global population lives in areas with basic 2G coverage, only 84% have access to mobile broadband (3G or better), with coverage particularly limited in rural Sub-Saharan Africa and mountainous regions of Asia.
Device Constraints
Device limitations affect the types of digital financial services accessible to different users:
The Alliance for Affordable Internet reports that in low-income countries, the average cost of an entry-level smartphone still exceeds 30% of monthly income for the bottom 20% of earners, creating a significant barrier to digital financial access.
Cost Barriers
Economic factors limit technology adoption necessary for digital financial inclusion:
Research by Research ICT Africa across 16 African countries found that 1GB of mobile data costs an average of 5.7% of monthly income, with rates exceeding 10% in the poorest countries—well above the 2% affordability target established by the UN Broadband Commission.
Digital and Financial Literacy
Technical Capability Gaps
Limited familiarity with digital technologies creates barriers to adoption:
A UNESCO study across nine developing countries found that only 40% of adults who had access to mobile phones could complete basic digital tasks like sending a text message with an attachment or installing an application.
Financial Knowledge Limitations
Lack of financial understanding compounds technology challenges:
FinMark Trust research across six African countries found that only 29% of adults could correctly answer basic financial literacy questions about interest, inflation, and risk diversification, with rates even lower among users of digital financial services.
User Experience Barriers
Design limitations create additional adoption hurdles:
Human-centered design research by CGAP found that first-time digital finance users abandon registration processes at rates exceeding 70% when interfaces require more than 5 steps or involve technical terminology.
Trust Deficits
Psychological barriers affect willingness to use digital financial services:
A Financial Sector Deepening study in Tanzania found that 62% of non-users of mobile money cited trust concerns as their primary reason for non-adoption, with particular anxiety about transaction failures and recourse mechanisms.
Regulatory and Compliance Challenges
Balancing Innovation and Protection
Regulators face complex trade-offs in overseeing digital microfinance:
The Alliance for Financial Inclusion reports that only 36% of developing countries have comprehensive regulatory frameworks specifically addressing digital financial services, with others applying traditional banking regulations that may be ill-suited to digital models.
KYC and Identity Verification
Customer verification remains a significant challenge:
The World Bank ID4D initiative estimates that 850 million people globally lack official identification, with disproportionate concentrations in Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia—precisely the regions where digital financial inclusion is most needed.
Interoperability Issues
Fragmentation of digital financial ecosystems creates barriers:
The GSMA reports that only 27% of mobile money markets globally have achieved interoperability between competing providers, limiting network effects and utility for customers.
Evolving Compliance Requirements
Regulatory complexity creates operational challenges:
Research by the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance found that regulatory compliance costs represent 15-20% of operating expenses for digital financial service providers in developing markets, potentially limiting their ability to serve the most marginalized populations profitably.
Data Privacy and Security Concerns
Data Protection Gaps
Inadequate data governance creates risks for vulnerable users:
Privacy International reports that only 66% of developing countries have enacted general data protection laws, with enforcement capacity significantly limited in many that do have legal frameworks.
Security Vulnerabilities
Technical and operational security challenges create risks:
A study by Caribou Digital across six developing countries found that 23% of digital financial service users had experienced security incidents, with rates higher among less educated and first-time technology users.
Algorithmic Transparency and Fairness
New risks emerge from algorithmic decision-making:
Research by the Center for Financial Inclusion found that 67% of digital lenders in developing markets could not fully explain the factors influencing their credit algorithms, creating transparency and fairness concerns.
Identity Theft and Account Security
Digital identity creates new vulnerabilities:
GSMA data indicates that SIM swap fraud attempts increased by 300% between 2018 and 2022 in Africa, with mobile money accounts increasingly targeted as balance values grow.
Over-indebtedness Risks
Easy Credit Access Concerns
Digital credit can create new consumer protection challenges:
A study in Kenya found that 47% of digital credit borrowers had repaid late, and 12% had defaulted, with limited understanding of terms and conditions cited as a contributing factor (FSD Kenya, 2021).
Limited Credit Information Systems
Information gaps complicate responsible lending:
The World Bank reports that only 23% of adults in low-income countries are covered by credit bureaus or registries, compared to 66% in high-income countries, limiting the effectiveness of credit risk assessment.
Product Design Concerns
Certain digital credit features may exacerbate risks:
Research by MicroSave Consulting across four African countries found that 80% of digital credit users could not accurately state the total cost of their loans when including all fees and charges.
Limited Recourse Mechanisms
Customer protection infrastructure remains underdeveloped:
The Consultative Group to Assist the Poor (CGAP) reports that less than 25% of digital financial service providers in developing markets offer comprehensive complaint resolution mechanisms accessible to low-literacy users.
Future Trends and Innovations
The digitalization of microfinance continues to evolve, with several emerging trends and innovations shaping the future landscape of financial inclusion in developing countries.
Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Enhanced Credit Decisioning
AI is revolutionizing credit assessment for underserved populations:
Lenddo and EFL's merged company, Jumo, integrates thousands of alternative data points into credit scoring models that have enabled lending to more than 10 million previously unbanked customers across Africa with default rates below 4%.
Conversational AI and Voice Interfaces
Natural language processing is making digital finance more accessible:
Wave Money in Myanmar implemented Burmese-language voice assistants that increased successful transaction completion rates by 43% among first-time users and users with limited literacy.
Personalized Financial Coaching
AI enables customized financial guidance at scale:
Arifu's AI-powered financial coaching platform in East Africa has demonstrated 28% increases in savings rates and 19% improvements in on-time loan repayments among users receiving personalized guidance.
Fraud Detection and Prevention
Machine learning enhances security for vulnerable users:
Simility (acquired by PayPal) deployed machine learning fraud detection models in India that reduced digital payment fraud by 73% while decreasing false positives by 35%, improving both security and legitimate transaction approval rates.
Internet of Things (IoT) Applications
Asset Financing and Monitoring
IoT enables new approaches to asset financing for low-income customers:
M-KOPA Solar has connected over 1 million pay-as-you-go solar home systems across East Africa, with embedded IoT enabling flexible payment plans that have resulted in 86% of customers eventually achieving full ownership.
Supply Chain Financing
Connected devices enable financing based on real supply chain activity:
Centrifuge's supply chain financing platform integrates IoT data from warehouses and transportation systems to verify real economic activity, enabling over $100 million in financing to small agricultural producers in Southeast Asia.
Data Collection for Risk Assessment
IoT provides alternative data for financial decision-making:
Apollo Agriculture in Kenya uses satellite imagery and soil sensors to assess farm productivity potential, enabling $30 million in loans to 100,000 smallholder farmers with limited traditional credit history.
Location-Based Services
Geospatial technology enhances service delivery:
TymeBank in South Africa uses geospatial technology to optimize its kiosk network, achieving 40% higher penetration in previously underserved areas and onboarding 3 million customers in its first two years of operation.
Super Apps and Ecosystem Approaches
Comprehensive Financial Platforms
Super apps integrate multiple financial services in unified interfaces:
GrabFinance in Southeast Asia evolved from a ride-hailing service to provide payment, lending, insurance, and investment products to over 25 million users, many previously unbanked, through a unified platform.
Financial and Non-Financial Integration
Ecosystems increasingly blend financial services with other needs:
JioFinance in India leverages its telecom customer base of over 400 million users to offer a suite of financial services alongside communications, content, and retail services, creating an integrated ecosystem with significantly lower customer acquisition costs.
Rural Service Ecosystems
Custom ecosystems address rural financial inclusion:
One Acre Fund's digital platform in East Africa combines agricultural training, input financing, weather insurance, and market access for 1.5 million smallholder farmers through an integrated rural service ecosystem.
Government Service Integration
Public-private ecosystems enhance service delivery:
Argentina's Cuenta DNI integrates national ID with provincial bank accounts, social benefit distribution, transport payments, and merchant services, reaching 5 million previously unbanked citizens in its first 18 months.
Open Banking and APIs
Interoperable Financial Infrastructure
Open APIs enable more connected financial ecosystems:
Mexico's Financial Technology Law established one of the first comprehensive open banking frameworks in developing markets, resulting in 30+ fintech partnerships with traditional banks and a 22% increase in financial inclusion within two years of implementation.
Embedded Finance in Third-Party Applications
Banking-as-a-Service models extend financial inclusion:
Safaricom's M-PESA API in Kenya has been integrated into over 42,000 third-party services, with transaction volumes through these integrations growing at 240% annually and creating financial access points in previously unreached contexts.
Specialized Fintech Partnerships
API-enabled partnerships create specialized solutions:
Smile Identity provides biometric verification APIs across 15 African countries, enabling 30+ financial service providers to safely onboard customers with limited formal documentation, resulting in 7 million previously excluded individuals gaining access to formal financial services.
Developer Ecosystems
Open platforms foster local innovation:
Mojaloop, an open-source payment platform initiated by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, has fostered developer communities across multiple African and Asian markets, resulting in 15+ country-level implementations connecting previously siloed financial services.
Embedded Finance
Contextual Financial Services
Embedding finance in life contexts increases relevance:
Kenya's Equitel combines telecommunications services with full banking functionality, embedding transaction capabilities in the SIM card and increasing financial service usage by 44% among previously underbanked populations.
Value Chain Integration
Sector-specific embedding addresses industry needs:
Apollo Agriculture in Kenya embeds financing directly in farm input supply chains, reaching 100,000 smallholder farmers with customized packages of seeds, fertilizer, insurance, and advisory services bundled with appropriately structured finance.
Invisible Finance Models
Seamless financial services reduce friction:
M-Tiba's health wallet in Kenya automatically converts mobile money deposits into restricted health savings, manages insurance claims invisibly, and facilitates provider payments without user intervention, serving over 4 million previously uninsured users.
Non-Traditional Distribution Channels
New access points extend financial inclusion:
The Postal Corporation of Kenya partnered with Safaricom to transform 625 post offices into full-service financial access points, reaching an additional 1.5 million customers in underserved areas with minimal infrastructure investment.
Policy Recommendations
Enabling the full potential of digital microfinance for financial inclusion requires thoughtful policy approaches that balance innovation with stability, protection, and equity.
Enabling Regulatory Frameworks
Proportional Risk-Based Regulation
Regulatory approaches should match oversight to risk levels:
Tanzania's four-tier regulatory framework for microfinance institutions created appropriate oversight categories from community microfinance groups to deposit-taking institutions, resulting in 72% growth in regulated providers serving low-income segments within three years.
Simplified KYC and Customer Due Diligence
Identity verification approaches should address exclusion barriers:
India's tiered KYC framework for payment banks allows basic accounts with simplified verification requirements and transaction limits, enabling 326 million previously unbanked individuals to access formal financial services.
Competition and Interoperability Policies
Regulatory approaches should foster diverse, connected ecosystems:
Ghana's interoperability mandate for mobile money providers increased cross-platform transactions by 280% in the first year and reduced average transaction costs by 17%, particularly benefiting users in remote areas with limited provider choice.
Consumer Protection Frameworks
Safeguards should be adapted for digital context and vulnerable users:
Peru's digital financial consumer protection regulations mandate simplified terms and conditions with "one-click access" within apps, resulting in a 34% increase in consumer understanding of product features and a 27% decrease in complaints.
Public-Private Partnerships
Digital Public Infrastructure
Governments should invest in foundational digital systems:
India's Unified Payment Interface (UPI) public infrastructure processed 6.28 billion transactions in July 2022, enabling financial inclusion at unprecedented scale with transaction costs approaching zero, demonstrating the power of public digital infrastructure.
Last-Mile Distribution Collaborations
Partnerships should extend physical access points:
Ecuador's "Banco del Barrio" partnership between Banco de Guayaquil and the national postal service converted 1,000+ postal outlets into banking agents, reaching 61% of the country's previously unbanked municipalities.
Data Partnerships
Responsible data sharing can enhance inclusion:
Colombia's Central Bank established a public credit scoring utility using alternative data (including utility payments and rental histories), enabling 1.6 million previously "invisible" citizens to access formal credit within two years.
Digital Financial Literacy Initiatives
Coordinated capability building enhances outcomes:
Rwanda's partnership between the Ministry of Finance, telecommunications providers, and the UN Capital Development Fund created a national digital financial literacy program reaching 2.5 million adults and increasing active digital financial service usage by 36%.
Digital Infrastructure Investment
Connectivity Expansion
Basic infrastructure enables digital financial inclusion:
Kenya's universal service fund financed connectivity for 883 previously unserved areas, resulting in a 17% increase in digital financial service usage in newly connected communities within six months.
Affordable Device Access
Programs addressing device barriers increase inclusion:
Colombia's "Computers to Educate" program expanded to include subsidized smartphones for low-income families, resulting in 1.2 million new devices and a 29% increase in mobile banking registration in targeted communities.
Alternative Energy Solutions
Power infrastructure supports digital service access:
BBOXX's solar-powered "Tomorrow's Connected Community" hubs in Rwanda combine power for device charging, Wi-Fi access, and digital financial service points, increasing digital transaction frequency by 47% in served communities.
Agent Network Development
Physical touchpoints remain essential complements to digital services:
Pakistan's Karandaaz initiative provided startup capital and technical support for 15,000 rural agents, with 40% female agents, resulting in 3.6 million previously unserved individuals accessing digital financial services within 18 months.
Consumer Protection Mechanisms
Transparency and Disclosure
Clear information enables informed decision-making:
Uganda's digital disclosure regulations require interactive cost calculators within loan apps that visually demonstrate total repayment amounts, resulting in a 23% decrease in default rates and improved product selection decisions.
Recourse Mechanisms
Effective complaint resolution builds trust:
Tanzania's mobile money complaint monitoring system reduced average resolution time from 7 days to 24 hours and identified systematic issues leading to regulatory intervention and a 42% reduction in recurring problems.
Responsible Lending Practices
Safeguards prevent digital credit risks:
Kenya's digital credit regulations instituted mandatory credit bureau reporting and cooling-off periods, reducing concurrent borrowing by 19% and improving repayment rates by 12% within six months of implementation.
Data Protection and Control
User rights over personal data should be ensured:
The Philippines' data privacy regulations for financial institutions established consumer-controlled consent management, resulting in increased trust and 28% higher opt-in rates for value-added financial services among previously skeptical consumers.
Financial and Digital Literacy Programs
Integrated Capability Building
Holistic approaches address multiple skill needs:
Kenya's Equity Bank "Financial Knowledge for Africa" program combines digital navigation skills with financial concepts, reaching 2 million participants and increasing digital transaction frequency by 86% among graduates.
Targeted Interventions for Vulnerable Groups
Specialized approaches address specific barriers:
Bangladesh's "Digital Financial Service Sisters" program trained 2,500 women agents who in turn provided hands-on guidance to 350,000 first-time female users, resulting in 68% higher active usage rates compared to traditional onboarding methods.
Sustainable Delivery Models
Scalable approaches ensure widespread impact:
The Philippines' "e-peso" gamified learning app reached 1.7 million users with 10-minute daily financial and digital skill modules, demonstrating a 23% improvement in financial behaviors among consistent users.
Measurement and Continuous Improvement
Evidence-based approaches enhance effectiveness:
Rwanda's financial capability tracking system measures not just knowledge gains but behavioral outcomes across 12 key financial practices, enabling continuous improvement of national digital financial literacy programs and a documented 34% increase in effective financial practices.
Conclusion
The digitalization of microfinance represents a transformative force for financial inclusion in developing countries, fundamentally altering how financial services are delivered to and utilized by low-income populations. Digital technologies have enabled microfinance providers to overcome traditional barriers of cost, distance, and scale while creating entirely new business models and product innovations that better meet the needs of previously excluded customers.
The evidence presented throughout this essay demonstrates significant progress. Mobile money systems like M-Pesa in Kenya and bKash in Bangladesh have brought basic financial services to tens of millions of previously unbanked individuals. Digital credit providers like Tala and Branch have extended formal credit to entrepreneurs without traditional documentation or collateral. Public digital infrastructure initiatives like India Stack have created the foundation for unprecedented scale in financial inclusion. Together, these innovations have contributed to a dramatic reduction in global financial exclusion, with account ownership in developing economies rising from 42% to 71% between 2011 and 2021.
Yet, important challenges remain. The digital divide continues to exclude the most vulnerable populations, with connectivity, device access, and digital literacy presenting significant barriers. Consumer protection concerns have emerged around digital credit, with risks of over-indebtedness and predatory practices. Data privacy and security issues raise questions about the responsible use of personal information. Regulatory frameworks struggle to keep pace with rapid technological change while ensuring stability and consumer protection.
As the field continues to evolve, several key principles should guide future development:
Looking ahead, emerging technologies like artificial intelligence, blockchain, and the Internet of Things promise to further transform microfinance, potentially enabling even more personalized, affordable, and accessible financial services. However, realizing this potential will require thoughtful governance frameworks that balance innovation with protection, inclusion with sustainability, and efficiency with human dignity.
The journey toward universal financial inclusion remains incomplete, but digital microfinance has demonstrably accelerated progress. By addressing remaining barriers with intentional focus on the needs and constraints of the most vulnerable populations, the sector can fulfill its promise of creating truly inclusive financial systems that enable all individuals and communities to build financial health, resilience, and opportunity.
References
Accion. (2022). Digital Transformation: What's next for microfinance. Accion Global Advisory Solutions.
Alliance for Financial Inclusion. (2021). Digital Financial Services Measurement Framework. AFI.
Asian Development Bank. (2020). Digital Transformation of Microfinance and Digitization of Microfinance Services to Deepen Financial Inclusion in Asia and the Pacific. Manila: ADB.
Barboni, G., Cassar, A., Rodriguez Trejo, A., & Wydick, B. (2021). Paying to program? Engineering self-control in savings groups. Journal of Development Economics, 153, 102708.
CGAP. (2019). Digital Banks: How can they deepen financial inclusion? Consultative Group to Assist the Poor.
CGAP. (2022). The Role of Digital Financial Services in Accelerating Financial Inclusion. Consultative Group to Assist the Poor.
Chen, G., & Mazer, R. (2023). Digital Credit: Borrower Experiences and Emerging Risks. Consultative Group to Assist the Poor.
Cull, R., Demirgü?-Kunt, A., & Morduch, J. (2018). The microfinance business model: Enduring subsidy and modest profit. World Bank Economic Review, 32(2), 221-244.
Demirgü?-Kunt, A., Klapper, L., Singer, D., & Ansar, S. (2022). The Global Findex Database 2021: Financial Inclusion, Digital Payments, and Resilience in the Age of COVID-19. Washington, DC: World Bank.
Feyen, E., Frost, J., Gambacorta, L., Natarajan, H., & Saal, M. (2021). Fintech and the digital transformation of financial services: implications for market structure and public policy. BIS Papers No 117.
FinMark Trust. (2021). FinScope Consumer Survey: The Financial Inclusion Journey. FinMark Trust.
Francis, E., Blumenstock, J., & Robinson, J. (2022). Digital credit: A snapshot of the current landscape and open research questions. Annual Review of Economics, 14, 583-614.
GSMA. (2023). State of the Industry Report on Mobile Money 2022. GSM Association.
Jack, W., & Suri, T. (2016). The long-run poverty and gender impacts of mobile money. Science, 354(6317), 1288-1292.
Kaffenberger, M., Totolo, E., & Soursourian, M. (2020). A Digital Credit Revolution: Insights from Borrowers in Kenya and Tanzania. CGAP.
Karlan, D., McConnell, M., Mullainathan, S., & Zinman, J. (2016). Getting to the top of mind: How reminders increase saving. Management Science, 62(12), 3393-3411.
Karlan, D., Kendall, J., Mann, R., Pande, R., Suri, T., & Zinman, J. (2020). Research and impacts of digital financial services. Annual Review of Economics, 12, 57-81.
McKee, K., Kaffenberger, M., & Zimmerman, J. M. (2020). Doing digital finance right: The case for stronger mitigation of customer risks. CGAP.
MicroSave Consulting. (2019). Making Digital Credit Truly Responsible: Insights from Analysis of Digital Credit in Kenya. MSC.
Pazarbasioglu, C., Mora, A. G., Uttamchandani, M., Natarajan, H., Feyen, E., & Saal, M. (2020). Digital Financial Services. World Bank Group.
Rhyne, E., & Rhyne, E. (2019). Financial Inclusion Hype vs. Reality: Deconstructing the 2017 Findex Results. Center for Financial Inclusion, Accion.
Roest, J., & Herrera, D. (2022). Regulatory Sandboxes: A Practice Guide for Policy Makers. World Bank Group.
Sahay, R., von Allmen, U. E., Lahreche, A., Khera, P., Ogawa, S., Bazarbash, M., & Beaton, K. (2020). The Promise of Fintech: Financial Inclusion in the Post COVID-19 Era. IMF Departmental Paper No. 20/09.
Suri, T. (2017). Mobile money. Annual Review of Economics, 9, 497-520.
Suri, T., & Jack, W. (2016). The long-run poverty and gender impacts of mobile money. Science, 354(6317), 1288-1292.
Suri, T., Bharadwaj, P., & Jack, W. (2021). Fintech and household resilience to shocks: Evidence from digital loans in Kenya. Journal of Development Economics, 153, 102697.
UNCDF. (2022). Inclusive Digital Economy Scorecard: Global Report 2022. United Nations Capital Development Fund.
World Bank. (2021). Digital Financial Services. World Bank Group.
World Bank. (2022). Global Findex Database 2021. Washington, DC: World Bank.
World Economic Forum. (2018). The Global Findex Database 2017: Measuring Financial Inclusion and the Fintech Revolution. World Economic Forum.
Zimmerman, J. M., & Baur, S. (2020). Understanding How Consumer Risks in Digital Social Payments Can Erode Their Financial Inclusion Potential. CGAP.