Banking on the Energy Transition

Victory was not delivered in 1945 using weapons available in 1939. So can we nip one thing in the bud: the idea that we have to fix the climate using just the tools we have today. That would hobble us. That would give credence to the denialist rearguard's claims about costs.

Yes, we must get serious now & go on a "war footing". But while solutions currently available will get us started, they won't finish the job. This requires installation of at least ten terawatts of renewable energy generation capacity coupled to all sectors of the economy through electrification & storage, significant demand-side management & behaviour modification, & the planting of at least one trillion trees, in the next decade. 

This needs mobilisation of market mechanisms by cost reduction achieved through innovation & deployment at scale. The denialists' last throw of the dice is to admit there's a problem but assert the solution costs too much, so they must ignore the very mechanisms that drive down costs. The final irony: those who claim to speak for the market deny what it can achieve. No-one thinks every car costs the same as the first car. We don't cross the Atlantic in biplanes. Yet they'd have us believe every MWh of renewable energy will cost as much as the first one generated. 

But this was always a pretext anyway. It turns out they were never arguing in good faith after all. Every objection raised was disingenuous. They would have us run out of canaries for their love of coal mines. 

Instead improved energy assessments & projections using cutting edge instruments and methods will support & enhance confidence in our ability to access zero fuel costs using facilities managed & operated in an optimal manner with a through-life perspective. Innovative financial instruments will emerge that leverage this to provide a pathway for investment. These developments will compound the rate at which capacity grows, until we get past the six-fold increase needed to deliver ten terawatts in time. Vanishing incremental costs of energy will transform the economy. But first a "massive reallocation of capital" is required, as Mark Carney, governor of the Bank of England, has remarked, to avert a Minsky moment due to the stranding of unsustainable assets. 

This massive reallocation of capital is effectively a transformation of the way accumulated wealth is represented. This is required due to the inherent decay of wealth through obsolescence & environmental impacts that erode all value, which I discussed in my article "the wealth of nations". It is how a healthy society responds.

We need to bank on the energy transition to deliver the outcome we seek, a future we can share, and in which we can all prosper.

Paul Behrens

British Academy Global Professor

5 年

Enjoying the writing Peter! Perhaps the circle can be completed?: "This massive reallocation of capital is effectively a transformation of the way accumulated wealth is represented." -> this is what will split the winners from the losers in the economic and metabolic transition, which is essentially politics -> this politics defines the structure of markets. I totally think the current political discussion, predicated on the idea that the transition will be costly without the focus being on the positives (both climate change and other 'externalities' such as energy security/air pollution) etc. is so dangerous. Especially since 80% renewability appears to come at no extra cost and only benefits. And when tipping points for RE costs lower than operating fossil fuels and social change are so close (I hope! perhaps within the next decade?).

John Fursh

Chief Engineer | Maintenance Supervisor | Extensive Deepwater DP Experience | Asset Manager

5 年

I followed up to this point: `confidence in our ability to access zero fuel costs using facilities managed & operated in an optimal manner with a through-life perspective.'? Even if you were to develop perpetual motion, managing will be an expense as well as the maintenance of the facilities.?

Ben Hart

Director of Process Design

5 年

Hell yeah, Peter. Really been appreciating the content you've been creating. Keep it up!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Peter Clive的更多文章

  • Can we extend the power law to accommodate complex shear?

    Can we extend the power law to accommodate complex shear?

    Short answer: yes. Long answer .

    8 条评论
  • Technomass

    Technomass

    On a recent family trip to London I saw many interesting exhibits in the Natural History Museum. We visited the "Our…

    1 条评论
  • A generalisation of the binary entropy function

    A generalisation of the binary entropy function

    The entropy function describes the expected information in the outcome of a source where that source can have n…

  • Some thoughts on Dynamic Energy Yield Assessment

    Some thoughts on Dynamic Energy Yield Assessment

    I was talking at the General Meeting of the International Energy Agency Wind Task 32 yesterday. The title of my talk…

    1 条评论
  • The wind farm is the terrain

    The wind farm is the terrain

    ?rsted recently announced they have revised down the expected internal rate of return and capacity factor for their…

    2 条评论
  • Digitalisation and the implementation of a Peace Treaty with Planet Earth

    Digitalisation and the implementation of a Peace Treaty with Planet Earth

    We talk a good game about digitalisation to ensure we embed our technologies as effectively as possible in our…

    2 条评论
  • Stop recycling

    Stop recycling

    We should stop recycling. At least, we should stop calling it "recycling".

    1 条评论
  • Climate change is market failure

    Climate change is market failure

    Around 6.5% of global GDP is spent annually directly and indirectly subsidising economic activities, such as fossil…

    4 条评论
  • Pons Sublicius

    Pons Sublicius

    Global temperatures are now approximately 0.1°C above the Holocene Maximum.

  • Kardashev 1

    Kardashev 1

    In December 1968 the astronaut William Anders on board Apollo 8 took the "Earthrise" photograph (above) that represents…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了