Balancing Recognition: Celebrating Top Sales Performers Without Neglecting the Team

Early in my career and shortly after I became a new home sales manager, one of our top performing and most tenured salespeople found herself in a sell-out neighborhood, with no future community in sight. She was a top producer four years in a row, had been with the public builder for over twelve years, and had garnered company and corporate accolades the entire time. Everyone loved to be around her infectious laugh and collaborative style she used when mentoring her teammates.

At the time, she decided to approach the VP of Sales and Division President with an ultimatum; either give her the next prestigious community that was opening (which the sales team had already been chosen for) or she would walk.

After management carefully considered her offer and discussed it with her to make sure they understood her full intent, she was released from her employment.

Being new in my sales management career, I was dumbfounded. She was the lead salesperson on the team, the glue of the group, the one everyone looked up to. ?I could not comprehend why this was the right move for the company to make. ?I went to speak with our VP and Division President.

In questioning the decision, I learned one of the most monumental career cornerstones in managing a sales team; everyone gets treated alike and should be given the same opportunities. This maintains a healthy and sometimes competitive sales environment. Once you start giving special treatment to only a few select team members, the positive culture of the sales team is diminished, and a toxic environment can begin to grow.

Managing a sales team in new home sales is no walk in the park. You’ve got to keep your top sellers feeling appreciated while also making sure the rest of the team doesn’t feel left out. It’s a tricky balance, but with the right approach, you can make everyone feel like a superstar. Here’s how to do it:

1. Give Shout-Outs Publicly

Everyone loves recognition. Celebrate your top performers in team meetings, newsletters, or company-wide emails. Suppose Jane consistently exceeds her sales targets. Highlight her achievements and share how her approach benefits the team. This boosts her morale and shows others what’s achievable.

2. Equal Opportunity for Growth

Provide chances for all team members to enhance their skills. This could be through training sessions, workshops, or industry conferences. Consider offering an advanced sales strategy workshop that anyone can attend based on their performance and interest. Top performers might get additional leadership training but ensure everyone knows these opportunities are based on merit and personal growth.

3. Keep Rewards Transparent

Set up a clear reward system that everyone understands. Recognize not just the top sellers but also those who excel in other areas like teamwork or customer service. Think about creating awards such as "Sales Collaborator of the Month", "Highest NPS Score" or "Customer Service Champion." This way, everyone feels they have a chance at being recognized, not just the highest sellers.

4. Build Team Spirit

Celebrate team success as much as individual achievements. Introduce team-based incentives and rewards to promote collaboration. Imagine if the team collectively hits a sales target, treat them to a team-building day out or a nice dinner. This fosters a sense of unity and shared purpose.

5. Personalized Feedback and Support

Hold regular one-on-one meetings with all team members. Use these sessions to give personalized feedback, acknowledge strengths, and discuss areas for improvement. Suppose you schedule monthly check-ins where you can discuss each person's career goals and offer support to help them achieve these. This personalized attention makes everyone feel valued.

6. Start a Mentorship Program

Pair top performers with those who are still finding their feet. Let’s say Mark is a seasoned pro and Amy is new; have Mark mentor Amy. This helps newer team members learn and grow and gives your stars a chance to develop leadership skills. Mentorship promotes a culture of knowledge-sharing and mutual respect.

7. Be Fair and Transparent

Maintain fairness and transparency in your management practices. Be clear about how decisions are made regarding promotions, bonuses, and other rewards. Picture creating a written policy outlining the criteria for bonuses and promotions and sharing it with the team. Consistency builds trust and prevents feelings of favoritism.

8. Encourage Friendly Competition

Set up friendly sales contests and challenges. Make sure these competitions are fair and motivating for everyone. Think about running a monthly sales contest where the winner gets a gift card, but also recognize different achievements like most improved or best customer feedback. This gives everyone a chance to shine.

9. Flexible Incentives

Not all rewards need to be monetary. Offer flexible rewards like extra vacation days, flexible working hours, or opportunities to work on special projects. Suppose you allow high achievers to choose a special project they’re passionate about (charity they'd like to volunteer at!) or give them an extra day off. Tailor these rewards to individual preferences to make them more meaningful.

10. Listen and Act on Feedback

Repeatedly ask for feedback from your team about what motivates them and what improvements they’d like to see. Consider holding quarterly feedback sessions where team members can share their thoughts. Act on this feedback to show that you value their opinions and are committed to creating a supportive work environment.

Balancing recognition for top performers with motivation for the entire team is a bit of an art. By implementing these strategies and examples, you can create a workplace where everyone feels valued and motivated to do their best. A happy and motivated sales team is the key to success in the competitive world of new home sales.

?