The Balancing Act of Acquisition and Retention
I've spent many years in the nonprofit world, and one question keeps surfacing everywhere I go. "Should we focus more on finding new donors or keeping the ones we have?"
I hear it from exhausted development directors, passionate EDs, and concerned board members. You're probably facing this dilemma too. The pressure to grow your donor base often feels at odds with the equally important work of nurturing your existing supporters.
Framing this as acquisition versus retention misses the point entirely. These aren't competing strategies fighting for your limited resources. They're partners in the same dance.
The strongest fundraising programs understand this intuitively. They don't sacrifice one for the other. They recognize that bringing in new donors means little if they walk right back out the door. And only focusing on current donors limits your potential for growth.
The Math Tells the Truth
That's not a small difference. Your fundraising budget stretches over seven times further when directed toward retention.
Yet our sector faces a stubborn reality. Most organizations lose over half their donors every year. New donor retention dropped to just 7.2% in early 2024. If you're nodding along right now, you're not alone. These numbers hit home for almost every nonprofit leader I meet.
For Keeping Your Donors
Make them partners, not ATMs > Organizations turning their retention numbers around have stopped treating donors like walking wallets. They've flipped the script on how they communicate. When you center relationship milestones instead of solicitation opportunities, retention jumps dramatically. I've seen increases of 20% or more.
Show the impact, don't just talk about it > Donors want to see their gifts at work. The days of vague "thanks for your support" messages are over. Concrete examples, specific outcomes, and authentic stories make all the difference. Your donors crave that connection to impact.
Get personal without getting creepy > Smart segmentation isn't about fancy technology. It's about paying attention and responding accordingly. A monthly donor deserves different communication than a first-time giver. A disaster response supporter might have different interests than your education program funders. Notice these differences and acknowledge them.
For Growing Your Base
Mine your existing connections first > The best new donor prospects already know someone connected to your work. Your board members, volunteers, staff, and current donors have networks filled with people who share their values. Creating simple ways for these supporters to introduce friends to your mission often yields better results than cold outreach.
Focus where it matters most > I see too many organizations trying to be everywhere at once. Pick your channels thoughtfully and do them well rather than spreading yourself thin. If your audience responds to email, excel at email before adding TikTok to your strategy.
Make monthly giving your default > The subscription model has changed consumer expectations. People are comfortable with recurring payments for everything from streaming services to meal deliveries. Organizations that lead with monthly giving options (rather than treating them as an afterthought) convert more one-time donors into steady supporters.
Finding What Works For You
No cookie-cutter formula exists for the perfect acquisition-retention balance. Your optimal mix depends on:
A 50-year-old hospital foundation needs a different approach than a three-year-old community organizing group. What matters is finding your balance point and adjusting it as you grow.
Your Next Steps
Look at your fundraising plan with fresh eyes. Ask yourself:
The balance between acquisition and retention isn't something you figure out once and forget. It's an ongoing adjustment that responds to your organization's changing needs and realities.
I'm always been inspired by the creativity and resilience of nonprofit professionals facing these challenges. Let's continue to build more sustainable fundraising programs that power our missions forward.
Paul Durban is an AVP for Filament Essential Services - a nonprofit that offers tailored support and advisory services to help other nonprofits thrive.
Want more insights to help your nonprofit? Subscribe to this newsletter for practical tips, fresh ideas, and tools you can use right away—and don’t forget to explore the archive for past articles packed with value!