Average vs. Equivalent Chip Thickness: What Every Machinist Needs to Know

For a machinist, understanding the concepts of "average chip thickness" and "equivalent chip thickness" is crucial for mastering and optimizing machining processes. As machining technology advances, the shift towards using "equivalent chip thickness" is becoming more pronounced. This guide will break down the differences between these two metrics, explain why it's important to understand them, and how they can be applied to improve your work on the shop floor.

?

Average Chip Thickness (h)

What Is It? Average chip thickness (h) measures the thickness of the chips produced by a cutting tool under typical machining conditions. This measurement gives an estimate of the chip thickness if conditions remain consistent throughout the process.

?

Why It Matters:

• Tool Geometry: Knowing average chip thickness helps in selecting and designing cutting tools that can handle the job effectively.
• Cutting Forces and Heat: It provides insight into the amount of force and heat generated during cutting.
• Chip Control: Understanding chip thickness can help you predict how the chips will behave—whether they’ll curl, break, or form in a way that could cause issues.
• Tool Life: Assists in estimating how long cutting tools will last before needing replacement.

?

Limitations: Average chip thickness is a great starting point, but it doesn’t tell the whole story. It doesn’t fully account for how the chip breaker and the nose radius (the rounded tip of the tool) affect the cutting process, especially when conditions aren’t consistent.

?

How It’s Used: Conversion charts and correction factors are often used to determine the right feed rate to achieve the desired average chip thickness.

?

Equivalent Chip Thickness (h_eq_thickness)

What Is It? Equivalent chip thickness (h_eq_thickness) is a more advanced concept that provides a better understanding of the actual chip thickness when cutting conditions are complex, such as when using tools with large nose radii or at shallow depths of cut.

?

Why It Matters:

• Adapting to Complex Conditions: Provides a more accurate representation of chip thickness when cutting conditions vary.
• How It's Calculated: Takes into account the tool’s varying engagement with the material along the entire cutting edge. This model effectively "straightens out" the nose radius, allowing for a more realistic average of chip thickness.
• Handling Complex Calculations: The equivalent chip thickness model is more intricate, incorporating a range of variables that can make manual calculations time-consuming and impractical in a production setting. Unlike the simpler average chip thickness model, which provides a straightforward approximation, the equivalent chip thickness model requires more detailed analysis. Fortunately, modern software solutions streamline this process. By inputting your machining parameters into these programs, you can quickly and accurately compute the equivalent chip thickness. This efficiency not only saves time but also enhances the optimization of your machining processes, ultimately boosting productivity and profitability.

When to Use It: Equivalent chip thickness is particularly useful in scenarios where:

• Low Depths of Cut: If you're working with low values for the depth of cut (ap) and large nose radii, h_eq_thickness provides a better representation of the forces at play.
• Tool Wear Analysis: It’s also beneficial for assessing tool wear, especially when the cutting edge experiences varying levels of engagement.

?

Why It's Useful for Machinists:

• Avoid Tool Wear: By understanding the true engagement of the cutting edge, you can better predict where and how your tool might wear out, especially at the nose.
• Optimize Cutting Parameters: Using h_eq_thickness allows you to set your feed rates and speeds more accurately, ensuring efficient material removal and prolonging tool life.

?

Why Machinists Should Focus on Equivalent Chip Thickness

1. Greater Precision: h_eq_thickness gives you a better idea of how the chips are forming, allowing you to fine-tune your machining parameters for the best results.
2. Better Adaptability: Machining conditions can change rapidly, especially in complex operations. h_eq_thickness is better suited to these variable conditions, making it a more reliable metric.
3. Increased Productivity: Optimizing your feed rates based on h_eq_thickness can help you remove material more efficiently, reduce tool wear, and minimize downtime.

?

The Evolution from Average to Equivalent Chip Thickness

Why Average Chip Thickness Was Important:

Average chip thickness provided a simple, straightforward way to estimate chip behavior. Given that early machining models assumed constant chip thickness, this metric was a useful approximation that matched the technology of its time. It offered an easy calculation method to address basic machining needs effectively.

Why the Shift to Equivalent Chip Thickness?

Modern machining frequently involves dynamic conditions such as varying feed rates, depths of cut, and tool engagements. The equivalent chip thickness (h_eq_thickness) is better suited to handle these changes due to its more comprehensive approach. With advancements in CNC technology, you can now adjust your machining parameters in real time based on h_eq_thickness, ensuring more accurate and efficient cuts. This shift not only enhances tool life by optimizing feeds per tooth but also improves overall performance by adapting to the complexities of contemporary machining processes.

?

For machinists, embracing the concept of equivalent chip thickness is a crucial step in staying ahead in the rapidly evolving world of machining. By understanding and applying this metric, you’ll be better equipped to achieve precision, adaptability, and productivity in your operations.

References

• De Vos, Patrick. "Chip thickness could well be the most important cutting condition for any machining operation." MENSAT, March 25, 2022.

In this insightful article, Patrick De Vos, Founder & Principal Advisor at MENSAT, explores the critical role of average chip thickness (hm) in machining operations. His detailed examination of average chip thickness, including practical tools and methods for optimization, provides a valuable foundation for understanding the importance of chip thickness in milling operations. For a deeper dive into average chip thickness and its applications, refer to De Vos’s comprehensive discussion.

• De Vos, Patrick. LinkedIn Live Event "Is average chip thickness an outdated concept?" LinkedIn Live Event. Feburary 28, 2023.

In this LinkedIn Live event, Patrick De Vos explores the development and relevance of the average chip thickness concept in machining. The discussion highlights why understanding this metric is essential for machinists aiming to maximize tool performance. The event, available for free on LinkedIn, offers valuable insights into how average chip thickness impacts cutting edge design and machining efficiency.