Autographing the Deal

Autographing the Deal

It seems we all lie. Depending on which lying study you choose to believe, we tell somewhere between a couple and a couple hundred lies a day. The lower number is found among monks who have taken a vow of silence while the higher counts days attending conventions. Most of our lies are harmless enough, pumping ourselves up, making others feel better, beveling society’s hard edges.

But if believed, one persistent lie—“I never sign personal guaranties”—can traumatize a young developer. If she overhears a corrida of aging bulls swearing they haven’t signed a guaranty since 1999 and then complains to her banker of how unfairly she’s being treated, it will likely be unpleasant. And if she decides to shop bankers, she will be wasting everyone’s time.

Oversimplifying matters slightly, two basic loans predominate real estate: lower-risk permanent loans for stabilized assets (a 10 year loan on a fully-leased office building) and higher-risk construction loans (an 18 month loan to build an apartment house). While non-recourse, permanent loans universally contain “carve-out” guaranties in which the borrower promises he will properly maintain the property, use the rent from the property to pay the mortgage, taxes, expenses and so on. If he intentionally wrongs the property or the lender—if he takes the rent to Vegas—he will be personally liable. Commonly known as the bad boy provisions, these are signed by everybody.

And everyone signs guaranties whenever they’re doing construction. Everyone is signing autographs. The rich and sometimes the clever can avoid repayment guaranties—a guarantee that the construction loan itself will be repaid; but everyone inks a completion guaranty—a promise that all construction will be finished and paid-for. Guaranteeing completion rather than repayment is lights-out better for a borrower. Why? Because as long as you finish the building, you can toss the keys on your lender’s desk if your anchor tenant goes bankrupt before your grand-opening party or you find yourself unable to repay the loan for any other sad reason (there are more than a few).

The bull may tell you he doesn’t sign bad-boy or completion guarantees either, but if you press him, he will admit some well-capitalized entity he owns or controls signs for him. The lender still gets the ink. And even though bank underwriting standards may be melting like crayons on a desert dashboard, you will be guaranteeing everything but the outcome of the Super Bowl if you’re trying to finance your first couple development deals.

It’s impossible to argue with the advice you hear at every industry cocktail party—“Never guaranty nothing”. Yet staring one in the face can have a salutary effect. Like rock-climbing Half Dome, it has a way of focusing one’s attention. If it is your personal net worth on the line, you will truly vet the deal, tweak the risks and verify approvals are in hand, construction costs fully quantified, the tenants as creditworthy as advertised, etc. In short, knowing it’s your guaranty may make you climb down from a deal you shouldn’t have attempted in the first place. If not sharing in a project’s potentially fatal abyss makes you a little less careful—it does—and you do a regrettable deal, you may not be personally liable for the loan, but your partners will have lost their investment and you will have nothing to show for a couple years’ worth of effort but a slammed reputation.

“Hear you, dude, but can we skip the pontificating and tell me instead how I get around guarantees?”

You do what the bulls do. You get the bank to waive it by putting up more equity and accepting a higher interest rate on the loan. Or, if you want to keep your equity down, you skip the banks and go straight to the debt funds (Blackstone, Starwood, etc.) and pay a lot more interest. There’s a problem, however, with this approach for a young developer: a rich guy may not care too much if his lender demands more equity because his idle cash is earning .015 percent interest (also known as nothing) in the bank. On the other hand, you should really care because rather than malingering in 6 month CD’s, your idle cash is jingling in your pocket. You are using Other People’s Money (OPM) for your equity, all of which carries a much higher coupon rate than bank debt—the bank’s are in the 2-4 percent range; OPM costs anywhere from 6-12 percent—meaning every dollar of OPM kicks your dented can of profit a little farther down the road. (OPM could also be an abbreviation for “Others Profit instead of Me”.)

But you counter with the old saw that you would rather sleep well than eat well. Not bad as bromides go, but there’s a word for a developer with no money or risk in the deal: consultant. If you’re not taking any risk, you’re going to be starving. Your financial partners may not be theoretical physicists, but they usually have an intuitive feel for business. They know if you are putting up nothing more than your time and your rapidly expiring purchase contract, they can hire you rather than partner with you.

Take this home: there is no way to make real developer profits without taking real developer risks. No risk, no reward. That said, you should try your best to limit risks: have tenants do their own improvements in exchange for a fixed contribution; outsource everything (nothing runs up a tab like employees) and never hire your college roommate as your general contractor. (Having your contractor go belly-up mid-construction is one of the rockier roads to ruin.)

And, of course, listen to the old guys, guarantee as little as possible. Or better yet, choose your deals with infinite caution and then, like diving off the 10-meter board, your guarantee will only look scary.

This article was first published in the Registry Magazine.  All McNellis articles may be viewed at McNellis.com

Chris Viglietta

GTM Engineer @ Clay

8 年

This was a great read, John...all your articles are very interesting!

回复
Robert W. Diel

CEO at Maverick California Development

9 年

Very well said. I loved it.

回复
John Hanna, Esq.

partner at Hanna and Van Atta

9 年

Well said- and colorful as well.

回复
Scott Negri

Owner of SKN Properties

9 年

Another well written article John!

回复
Dixie Divine

CEO/Broker/Founding Principal of Prime Commercial, Inc. and Prime Commercial Management, Inc.

9 年

Great article John.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

John McNellis的更多文章

  • CRE: Waiting for Cheaper Money

    CRE: Waiting for Cheaper Money

    In Samuel Beckett’s masterpiece Waiting for Godot, his principal characters Vladimir and Estragon stand around the…

    3 条评论
  • Revive our Downtowns? Recall Government Workers

    Revive our Downtowns? Recall Government Workers

    The old joke goes like this: a visiting dignitary asks a mayor how many people work at city hall. The mayor scratches…

    11 条评论
  • Kathleen (Taffy) McNellis 1949-2024

    Kathleen (Taffy) McNellis 1949-2024

    My sister passed last week after a decades’ long struggle with syringomyelia (a severe spinal cord disorder). A…

    152 条评论
  • How Remote Work slammed San Francisco's Apartment Market

    How Remote Work slammed San Francisco's Apartment Market

    Rather than another dreary epistle about San Francisco, this is a tale about the only law of economics worth knowing…

    8 条评论
  • AI's White-Collar Road Kill

    AI's White-Collar Road Kill

    Journalists may be worse off than polar bears. After all, cold winters may return someday but AI isn’t going anywhere.

    12 条评论
  • Scout's Honor Audio Book Now Available

    Scout's Honor Audio Book Now Available

    After losing everything but his life, a young man forges a new identity for himself in the jungles of Vietnam and on…

    1 条评论
  • Retail Vacancy Taxes: Empty Stores, Empty Logic

    Retail Vacancy Taxes: Empty Stores, Empty Logic

    Palo Alto’s city council is considering a “vacancy tax” on empty shop space in its downtown, penalizing owners stuck…

    21 条评论
  • The Pacaso of Time Shares

    The Pacaso of Time Shares

    More often than not, the movie bad guy is a drug lord or a nature-paving developer. While these two villains seemingly…

    5 条评论
  • America Rightly Viewed

    America Rightly Viewed

    I have a very smart, middle-aged son who has lived his entire life in Europe. Inspired by the Fourth of July and our…

    29 条评论
  • Resuscitation Hardware?

    Resuscitation Hardware?

    I shorted a stock once. As a Kmart landlord 20 years ago, I saw firsthand how badly that discounter was run.

    10 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了