The authenticity vs. algorithm debate: How to balance both

Intro

Imagine showing up to a basketball game wearing football cleats. No matter how skilled you are, you won’t be able to move effectively or compete at your best. The same principle applies to content creation—if you ignore the rules of the platform you’re using, you’re setting yourself up for failure.

In today’s digital world, the debate about authenticity versus algorithmic optimization is more relevant than ever. We want to stay true to our values and communicate in a genuine way, but the pressure to “play the game” and maximize reach is undeniable. The fear of being invisible in a sea of content leads many to prioritize exposure over authenticity.

But is authenticity really disappearing, or is it evolving? And can you stay true to yourself while ensuring your content actually reaches the right people?

This article explores why authenticity is still your most powerful differentiator and why ignoring the algorithm is a mistake. Most importantly, it offers a roadmap to balance both, helping you build a brand that is both visible and valuable.

The myth of "pure" authenticity

One of the biggest misconceptions about authenticity in content creation is that it means “just being yourself” without considering structure, strategy, or distribution. While that sounds idealistic, it’s not very effective.

Authenticity isn’t about ignoring best practices. It’s about expressing yourself in a way that feels true to your values while being smart about how you present your message. Think about it like this:

• An artist who refuses to showcase their work will never be discovered.
• A musician who avoids streaming platforms limits their reach.
• A writer who doesn’t make their work readable won’t attract many readers.

Being authentic doesn’t mean ignoring the mechanics of visibility - it means using them to share your voice more effectively.

The power of the algorithm (and why it matters)

Algorithms often get a bad reputation, but at their core, they are designed to connect content with the right audience. Instead of demonizing them, learn how to use them to your advantage.

Each platform has its own "rules of the game" - for instance:

• LinkedIn prioritizes meaningful engagement - comments and thoughtful conversations matter more than simple likes.
• Instagram rewards consistency, short-form videos (Reels), and interactive elements like polls and questions.
• YouTube favors longer watch times - storytelling and pacing are key.
• Substack focuses on direct relationships - email open rates and reader engagement determine your reach.

Ignoring algorithms doesn’t make you more authentic - it just makes you invisible.

The winning formula: authenticity + value + algorithm awareness

So how do you strike the right balance? The answer lies in a three-part formula:

1. Authenticity: Your unique perspective, voice and experience: what makes your content stand out
2. Value: The impact your content has on your audience—does it educate, inspire, or entertain?
3. Algorithm awareness: Understanding basic distribution principles so your content reaches the people who need to see it.

Think of it like basketball: You could have the best shooting skills in the world, but if you don’t know the rules of the game, you won’t last long on the court. The same applies to content—you need both skill and strategy to succeed.

Imagine showing up to a basketball game wearing football cleats. No matter how skilled you are, you won’t be able to move effectively or compete at your best.

Practical steps: how to apply this in your content strategy

Here’s how you can merge authenticity with algorithm awareness:

1. Define your core message

? What do you stand for?

? What unique value do you bring?

? How do you want to be perceived?

Before thinking about algorithms, clarify your authentic voice and message.

2. Understand the platform-specific rules

? LinkedIn: Encourages thoughtful discussions and engagement.

? Instagram: Rewards consistency, video content, and interactive elements.

? YouTube: Prioritizes watch time and strong storytelling.

? Substack: Values deep connections with subscribers and direct engagement.

Each platform plays a different “game,” and knowing the rules helps your content perform better.

3. Optimize without losing your voice

? Use engaging headlines without resorting to clickbait.

? Format content for readability while keeping your tone natural.

? Post consistently, but don’t sacrifice depth for frequency.

4. Engage with your community

? Algorithms favor engagement, but real engagement comes from genuine conversations.

? Respond to comments, interact with your audience, and create a dialogue.

? Ask for feedback—what does your audience want more of?

5. Test, analyze, and adjust

? Review analytics to see what resonates.

? Stay flexible - what works today might change tomorrow.

? Adapt based on performance, but don’t chase trends mindlessly.

Final thoughts

authenticity and strategy can coexist.

The idea that you must choose between authenticity and algorithmic awareness is false. The most successful creators, brands, and professionals understand that both matter.

Being genuine doesn’t mean ignoring how content distribution works. And playing the algorithm doesn’t mean sacrificing your true voice. The key is to find the intersection - where meaningful content attracts real engagement and the algorithm rewards it naturally.

Your next steps:

1. Audit your content: Are you relying too much on algorithmic tricks at the cost of real value? Or are you being authentic but neglecting strategy?
2. Choose one platform to master: Learn its rules, experiment, and refine your approach.
3. Engage more actively: Authenticity shines through conversations. Start responding, interacting, and building relationships.
4. Commit to consistency: Show up regularly with content that reflects both your expertise and personality.
5. Refine your strategy: Define your Why, What, Who, How & When.

Authenticity + Value + Algorithm awareness = the winning formula.

The choice is yours: will you stay stuck in the cycle of creating content that disappears, or will you step up, own your voice, and play smart? Your audience is waiting—make your next move count.

• Let’s connect. Follow me here, on Substack & Instagram.
• Liked this article? Make sure to ?? click the like button
• Feedback or addition? Make sure to ?? comment.
• Know someone who would find this helpful? Make sure to ?? share this post.