Aurora 2024 Renewables & Batteries Summit in Berlin

Aurora 2024 Renewables & Batteries Summit in Berlin

TLDR:

  • The German government is focusing on building out the grid to avoid having to split Germany into different price zones.
  • Battery storage will not receive subsidies from the German government.
  • More updates regarding the planned capacity mechanism will be published this summer.
  • CfDs are needed to reach capacity targets, as PPA prices are too low.

Annual conference about the German Market

Aurora Energy Research ’s annual conference about the state and future of the German Energy Transition took place on 28.05.2025. It included a keynote by the undersecretary Dr. Nimmermann about the strategy of the German government, as well as presentations by Aurora and panel discussions.

Keynote by the permanent secretary

Source: Aurora Energy Research

The focus of the German government is on grid/system stability and energy security through:

  • building out the grid,
  • keeping a fleet of gas-fired powerplants that can be converted to hydrogen use and
  • speeding up the permitting and grid connection process

A conference with KfW is planned for July in Frankfurt to discuss with private capital providers what the right framework should be to attract private investment for the build-out and modernisation of the German electricity infrastructure.

Further details about the upcoming capacity mechanism will be published this summer. But no decision has been made so far on whether it will be a capacity market or some form of hedging mechanism.

The government wants to avoid having to split Germany into different price zones and is considering some form of additional grid charges to send locational price signals.

Battery storage deployment is working well and, therefore, doesn’t need government subsidies and is not included in the government’s long-term supply and demand modelling.

The current EEG subsidy tender system must be replaced by a two-way CfD mechanism to comply with EU regulations.

More demand and supply flexibility is needed to ensure system stability, and renewable energy asset owners need to accept curtailment as part of their business case.

Keynote: Rentability of PPA and merchant solar PV

Source: Aurora Energy Research

New solar PV projects in Germany that plan to sell their electricity on a merchant basis or via a PPA are currently not profitable if your cost of capital is higher than 5%. This is not forecasted to change until 2036 at the earliest. PPAs will, therefore, remain a niche product that only a few project owners will choose.

To reach the capacity increase targets, the government will instead rely on CfDs, and capacity limitations have been ruled out so far, unlike in the UK.

Government-backed CfDs are less risky than PPAs, and this will lower the cost of capital for renewable energy investments.

Panel Discussion: State of the Energy Transition

Source: Aurora Energy Research

The panel broadly agreed that investors and lenders see three critical topics in Germany:

  1. PPAs are a niche product and not financially attractive. The EEG and CfDs will drive the capacity build-out.
  2. If the government wants to avoid introducing different price zones, the transmission network needs to be expanded, and some form of locational pricing needs to be introduced through grid charges.
  3. Germany has a long way to go to encourage demand flexibility. However, supply flexibility is also needed, which will be achieved through more storage capacity and more frequent curtailment of renewable energy generators. This will reduce the frequency of hours with negative electricity prices, but there will be more hours with near-zero prices.

Keynote: co-location in Germany

Source: Aurora Energy Research

Whilst co-location would be a logical choice for the German electricity market with its increasing number of hours with negative prices, the current regulations don’t allow for a profitable business model.

Co-located batteries that receive subsidies are only allowed to be charged from the connected renewable energy generator. This will change in 2026, but the government hasn’t published the details yet.

This situation frustrates investors as other countries have more straightforward metering concepts and are more flexible on how the battery is charged.

Panel discussion: Does co-location make sense

Source: Aurora Energy Research

The panel mirrored the keynote by expressing frustration around the co-location regulation and that the business case doesn’t work in Germany.

An interesting assessment from one panellist was BESS developers shouldn’t pin too much hope on the future capacity mechanism, as gas-fired power plants tend to win most contracts in other European markets.

#Germany #netzero #energytransition #climatechange #renewables #solar #BESS #storage #grid #CfD #PPA #colocation #investment

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Andre Gentil-Kraatz的更多文章

  • Summary of REMA update February 2025

    Summary of REMA update February 2025

    DESNEZ hosted a webinar on 06 February 2025 to provide an update on the REMA process. This was the first update since…

  • Wood Mackenzie London Renewables Briefing 2024

    Wood Mackenzie London Renewables Briefing 2024

    Wood Mackenzie’s annual Renewables Briefing took place on 30 April 2024 in London. They are a consultancy that provides…

  • Solar & Storage Live London 2024

    Solar & Storage Live London 2024

    The Solar & Storage Live expo is happening today and tomorrow in London. I went there this morning, and here are my key…

  • Second REMA consultation: Highlights

    Second REMA consultation: Highlights

    The second consultation of the Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA) is open until 07 May 2024. It is part…

  • Reform of network charges in the UK

    Reform of network charges in the UK

    TLDR: Network charges need to be reformed because they are not set up for a world with many renewable energy…

  • WFW Spotlight Series: Germany

    WFW Spotlight Series: Germany

    Introduction The Watson Farley & Williams (WFW) spotlight series of events highlights one country at each event, and…

  • Consultation on the UK’s new long-duration storage framework

    Consultation on the UK’s new long-duration storage framework

    The 2021 call for evidence had identified revenue uncertainty and high up-front costs as significant hurdles preventing…

  • REMA: Nodal or Zonal Pricing?

    REMA: Nodal or Zonal Pricing?

    REMA and the coming changes in the UK electricity market The energy transition brings significant changes that require…

  • CMS Breakfast Seminar: Co-location of storage and renewable generation

    CMS Breakfast Seminar: Co-location of storage and renewable generation

    Introduction The intermittent generation profile of wind and solar farms is one of the main challenges of the energy…

    1 条评论
  • Why is Italy the new hot BESS market?

    Why is Italy the new hot BESS market?

    BESS = Battery Energy Storage System TLDR (Too Long, Didn’t Read) Italy is an attractive market if you enter early and…

社区洞察