August update

As of August 2024, the mid-market private equity (PE) sector in North America is navigating a complex and dynamic environment, shaped by a mix of economic uncertainty, evolving market conditions, and strategic shifts within the industry. The mid-market, generally comprising companies with enterprise values between $50 million and $500 million, remains a vital segment of the broader private equity landscape, driving growth and innovation across a variety of industries. However, the journey through 2024 has been anything but straightforward.

The Impact of Economic Conditions on Mid-Market PE

At the beginning of the year, the mid-market PE sector entered 2024 with high expectations, particularly regarding interest rate cuts from the Federal Reserve. Many firms anticipated multiple rate reductions, which would have made debt financing more accessible and spurred deal activity. However, the reality has been more restrained. The Federal Reserve has maintained a cautious stance, leaving interest rates higher than many in the industry had hoped.

This higher interest rate environment has had a tangible impact on deal-making. Borrowing costs have remained elevated, which has tempered the pace of acquisitions and made financing less attractive for leveraged buyouts (LBOs). Firms have been forced to adjust their expectations, often opting for smaller, more strategic acquisitions or focusing on operational improvements within their existing portfolios rather than pursuing aggressive expansion.

Looking ahead, there is a growing anticipation that the Fed might enact its first rate cut in September 2024, as market conditions evolve. However, any rate reduction this year is expected to be modest, with experts predicting potentially only one or two small cuts by the end of 2024.

Evolving Credit Markets: A Silver Lining

Despite the challenges posed by higher base interest rates, the credit markets have provided some relief. Increased competition within the private credit sector, along with a revival of the syndicated loan market, has led to narrower spreads— the additional interest charged over base rates. This competitive pressure has allowed PE firms to secure financing at more favorable terms than they might have expected, given the broader economic conditions.

For instance, mid-market deals in sectors like healthcare and technology have continued to move forward, thanks in part to these improved credit conditions. Firms have successfully navigated this environment by focusing on industries with strong fundamentals and growth potential, allowing them to justify the higher costs of capital with the promise of robust returns.

Fundraising: A Tale of Two Markets

Fundraising in 2024 has been a mixed bag for mid-market PE firms. Established firms with strong track records have generally fared well, continuing to attract significant investor commitments despite the economic headwinds, signalling confidence from institutional investors in their ability to navigate the current market.

However, newer and smaller PE firms have faced greater challenges in raising capital. The heightened caution among investors has led to longer fundraising cycles and more stringent due diligence processes. Investors are increasingly selective, favoring firms that can clearly articulate their strategies for delivering value in a more challenging economic environment.

?

The Road Ahead: What to Expect for the Rest of 2024

Looking ahead, the mid-market private equity sector is likely to see continued adaptation and strategic recalibration. Here are some key trends to watch:

Selective Deal-Making

Given the higher cost of capital, PE firms will likely continue to be more selective in their deal-making. We can expect a focus on high-quality assets in sectors with resilient growth prospects, such as healthcare, technology, and business services. These sectors have proven to be relatively insulated from broader economic volatility and offer opportunities for operational improvement and innovation.

Operational Value Creation

With financing less attractive, there will be an increased emphasis on creating value through operational improvements rather than financial engineering. Firms will focus on enhancing the performance of their portfolio companies, driving efficiencies, and investing in growth initiatives that can deliver returns even in a slower economic environment.

Fundraising Challenges and Opportunities

For the remainder of the year, we can expect a continued bifurcation in the fundraising landscape. Top-tier firms with proven track records will likely continue to attract capital, while others may struggle. This environment will reward firms that can demonstrate a clear, differentiated strategy and a strong track record of success.

Increased M&A Activity as Valuations Stabilize

As the year progresses, there may be a slight uptick in M&A activity, especially if interest rates stabilize or begin to decline modestly. Valuations, which have been under pressure due to higher borrowing costs, may start to stabilize, leading to more alignment between buyers and sellers. This could unlock more deal opportunities, particularly in sectors where valuations had previously been too high for deals to make economic sense.

Conclusion: A Year of Strategic Patience and Opportunism

2024 has proven to be a year of strategic patience for the mid-market private equity sector in North America. Firms have had to navigate a more challenging economic environment, with fewer rate cuts than expected and higher borrowing costs. However, the resilience of the sector is evident in the continued deal activity, especially in high-growth areas, and the successful fundraising efforts of well-established firms.

As we move through the latter half of the year, the key for PE firms will be to remain agile, focusing on operational improvements, selective deal-making, and maintaining strong relationships with investors. Those that can adapt to the current conditions and capitalize on the opportunities that do arise will be well-positioned for success as we head into 2025.

ABOUT TIPPING POINT GLOBAL EXECUTIVE SEARCH

Headquartered in North America, we are a Mid-Market and Private Equity Executive Search firm. We specialize in providing executive search solutions to high-growth private equity firms and mid-market, owner-led, private companies. Since 2008 we have offered incomparable executive search services and value to our clients, maintaining our reputation for reliability and excellence.

Over the past 15 years, Tipping Point Global Executive Search has been intrinsic in supporting and facilitating our clients’ growth and scaling plans. Our specialized Mid-Market and Private Equity Executive Search solutions provide an essential and effective service to clients looking to accelerate growth, revenue, and market share. Our clients rely on us to source and recruit CEO, C-Suite, and Senior Executive level talent, across every industry, discipline, and function.