Will the audit challenger brand of the future look like this?

Will the audit challenger brand of the future look like this?

Our recent report on the audit industry argues that there’s a role for a challenger brand in the audit industry. But what would it look like? We sent an intrepid analyst into the future to find out…

THE SCENE: THE SPARKLING FOYER OF AUDITMAGIC, INC. 

THE DATE: NOVEMBER 2, 2029.

ANALYST: I’m speaking to you today from the control centre of Auditmagic, the firm that’s shaking the audit business to its foundations. Around me are screens, showing in real time the amount of data being gathered and checked by this extraordinary business. And, of course, it’s not just financial data that’s being gathered here, but environmental data, information on gender diversity and equal pay, and a whole host of other areas. I can see data coming in from operations in Asia, from Europe, and, no doubt in the future, from the proposed missions to Mars. With me is AuditMagic’s Chief Executive, Melanie Fremantle. Melanie, this is a remarkable achievement. How did you do it?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: Well, it wasn’t just me, of course! [LAUGHS] My honest view is that this was a disruption waiting to happen. Change couldn’t have come too soon. It may have taken the finance function by surprise, but there were plenty of other people in organisations who could read the writing on the wall…

ANALYST: … Which was?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: That technology was going to change everything. At the time we started, almost everyone’s attention, on both the supply and demand side, was focused on what the regulator might do next. Yet it was quite obvious that technology was opening up all sorts of possibilities when it came to both the scope of the audit process—who talks about sampling now?—and its efficiency. Once we’d built the ‘bots and algorithms that could ensure our data gathering software could adapt to the systems and infrastructure of any organisation, then there really wasn’t anything that could stop us. As you can see when you look around you, none of this looks like the office of an audit firm. We don’t have ranks of people at banks of desks, trawling through figures and reports. We have people who write programmes, data scientists and analysts.

ANALYST: But you don’t have many?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: That’s true. We looked at the people-less factors that were being built 10 years ago and asked ourselves why we couldn’t apply that same thinking to professional services. Of course, there’s plenty of complexity in what we’ve designed. We’ve had to design systems that monitor systems otherwise the traditional audit firms would have simply reinvented themselves as the people who check systems.

ANALYST: You haven’t completely replaced those audit firms, have you?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: That’s also true, and why would we want to. It was never part of our plan to offer audit opinions. That’s high-risk work that’s rightly very expensive to provide, and it’s simply not the market we’re in. We have decent margins because we use a lot of technology, not because we charge high prices.

ANALYST: Was success just about technology?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: [LAUGHS AGAIN.] No, that was a big lesson for us. We thought that, if we developed clever software, that would be enough, but we quickly realised we had to look and sound different. We had to rock up with the coolest-sounding software on the planet. Suits were banned: Everyone is in jeans and T-shirts. In retrospect, we realise it was classic challenger brand stuff.

ANALYST: Hence the name?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: Indeed. I mean we could hardly call ourselves XY&Z Partners, could we? Getting organisations to change the way they bought audit services depended on two things. The first was to get them to recognise that what they’d thought of as one thing—the audit process—was in fact two things: A data gathering process, that was highly dependent on technology; and the traditional audit opinion. Once we’d got them over that conceptual barrier, the next challenge was to persuade them that they could give the data gathering work, not to one of the generic tech IT behemoths, but to a virtual start up.

ANALYST: And how did you manage that?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: By being cool. It sounds silly, but never underestimate the magnetic pull of being seen to be cool. You’d think audit committees are some of the most conservative collections of people on the planet, and they can be, but there’s always been plenty of latent frustration there. When we offered them an audit that used data and advanced analytics to predict problems, not simply report them, they were all over us. They wanted to disrupt audit: We just gave them the means.

ANALYST: So, what’s next?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: That’s a tough one to answer. We’ve got a commanding share of the audit data gathering market, so we could spend the next 10 years hoovering up the rest. Or…

ANALYST: Or?

MELANIE FREMANTLE: We could sell ourselves to an audit firm.

Okumu p'Okech Luryan DMan MSc ACIS FCMI FIC

Managing Partner at Noh-Vald Consultancy

5 年

Probably yes. Timeless, strong and upright.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Fiona Czerniawska的更多文章

  • Sustainability: The execution gap

    Sustainability: The execution gap

    Our research suggests that the intention at the top of organisations to invest in responding to climate change and…

    4 条评论
  • Light at the end of the funnel? Why consulting firms need to think again about how clients buy

    Light at the end of the funnel? Why consulting firms need to think again about how clients buy

    Anyone involved in the marketing of consulting and other professional services will be familiar with the funnel, which…

    2 条评论
  • The delivery gap

    The delivery gap

    Bigger, bolder goal-setting at the very top is outrunning organisations’ capacity to deliver. But this may turn out to…

  • Advisory to advocacy: Will 2022 see a major shift in the behaviour of professional services firms?

    Advisory to advocacy: Will 2022 see a major shift in the behaviour of professional services firms?

    The need for greater sustainability is driving many conversations between professional services firms and their…

  • Making every face-to-face meeting count

    Making every face-to-face meeting count

    On December 7th 2021, I sat in a meeting room in our offices. Notionally taking part in a Zoom call, I was mostly just…

    1 条评论
  • Is outsourcing the new restructuring?

    Is outsourcing the new restructuring?

    Research we carried out in late 2021 suggests that the sudden surge of interest in outsourcing— which began during the…

    1 条评论
  • Consulting: Disruption again, but this time from the supply side

    Consulting: Disruption again, but this time from the supply side

    I’ve written before about if, when, and how the consulting industry will be disrupted, often suggesting that the forces…

    3 条评论
  • Consulting—running out of fuel?

    Consulting—running out of fuel?

    The consulting industry, having successfully navigated one crisis, is now facing another. Throughout most of last week…

    2 条评论
  • Getting the message

    Getting the message

    In February 2020, a message in a bottle washed ashore at St Aubin beach in the Channel Islands, 82 years after it had…

  • Micro-disruption in consulting?

    Micro-disruption in consulting?

    The disruption promised in consulting has been a long time coming. Perhaps we’re thinking about it in the wrong way.

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了