Apple Pay Revolution: Unlocking the potential of NFC

Apple is not just a giant known for building some beautiful devices, like the Mac book Air and the iPhone. But also for capturing 90% of the wallets business in the US. And they recently processed $6 trillion of transactions.

But the road has not always been rosy for Apple, who after recently after a lawsuit was filed against them, decided to open up their NFC payment chips for third party developers. And this promises to bring about? a lot of innovation to the ecosystem.

P.S.: To Read the newsletter with all the infographics and reference links, please do refer to my substack.

SO this edition of The Fintech Chronicler, is a deep dive into the business of Apple Pay.

Would you rather hear this content? Then click here for the recording of this.

Apple Pay at a glance

In the ever-evolving landscape of digital payments, Apple Pay stands out as a transformative force. Launched in 2014, Apple Pay has grown into a robust ecosystem that integrates seamlessly with Apple's suite of devices, offering users a secure and convenient way to manage their finances.?

Since its launch, Apple Pay has expanded rapidly, becoming the leading mobile payment platform in the U.S. It supports most major credit and debit cards, and its compatibility with contactless payment systems has made it a staple for millions of users. Apple Pay's integration with the Apple ecosystem, including Apple Cash and the Apple Card, further enhances its appeal.

Apple Cash

Apple Pay offers a suite of products that cater to various financial needs, seamlessly integrating into the Apple ecosystem to enhance user convenience and security. One of its key offerings is Apple Cash, a digital card within the Wallet app that functions similarly to a debit card. Apple Cash allows users to send and receive money through the Messages app or directly from the Wallet app, making peer-to-peer payments straightforward and efficient. It is particularly useful for families, as parents can set up Apple Cash Family to provide their children with financial independence while maintaining oversight. Additionally, transferring funds from Apple Cash to a bank account is a simple process, further enhancing its utility for everyday transactions.

Apple Pay Later

Apple Pay Later is Apple's entry into the burgeoning buy now, pay later market. This service allows users to split purchases into four equal payments over six weeks, with no interest or fees, providing a flexible payment option for larger purchases. Apple Pay Later is seamlessly integrated with the Apple Pay platform, ensuring that all transactions are secure, utilizing Face ID, Touch ID, or a passcode for authentication. This service not only caters to consumers looking for manageable payment plans but also aligns with the growing trend of alternative financing options, positioning Apple Pay as a comprehensive solution for modern financial needs.

?

Apple Card

Another significant product in the Apple Pay lineup is the?Apple Card, a credit card designed by Apple and issued by Goldman Sachs. The Apple Card stands out with its unique features, such as Daily Cash back on purchases—1% with the physical card, 2% with Apple Pay, and 3% on Apple products and select partners. It boasts no fees, detailed spending summaries, and robust security measures, making it an attractive option for consumers. Despite its sleek titanium design and user-friendly features, the Apple Card has faced challenges, including financial losses for Goldman Sachs and customer service issues. These challenges have prompted Goldman Sachs to reconsider its partnership with Apple, highlighting the complexities of managing a consumer credit product in a competitive market.

?

Fall out with Goldman Sachs?

Despite its popularity, the Apple Card has faced significant challenges, particularly in terms of profitability for its banking partner, Goldman Sachs. The card offers attractive features such as no fees, Daily Cash rewards of up to 3% on purchases, and seamless integration with Apple Pay. However, these consumer-friendly features have not translated into financial success for Goldman Sachs, which has reported over $1 billion in losses since the partnership began. he absence of fees, coupled with Apple's demand for broad approval of applicants, including those with lower credit scores, has resulted in higher-than-expected credit losses for Goldman Sachs.

The economic model of the Apple Card is heavily reliant on transaction volumes and interest from outstanding balances, but the card's design encourages users to minimize interest payments. This has contributed to the financial strain on Goldman Sachs, which has had to set aside significant reserves to cover potential nonpayments.

Furthermore, the operational challenges, such as managing a high volume of customer disputes and adhering to Apple's unique billing cycle requirements, have added to the bank's difficulties.? These factors, combined with regulatory scrutiny from bodies like the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, have made the partnership increasingly untenable for Goldman Sachs.

Given these challenges, Goldman Sachs is reportedly seeking to exit the Apple Card partnership, potentially transferring it to another financial institution such as American Express or Synchrony Financial. This strategic shift aligns with Goldman Sachs' broader move to step back from consumer lending and refocus on its core business area.

The decision to end the partnership reflects the complexities of balancing consumer-friendly features with profitability in the competitive credit card market. As Goldman Sachs navigates this transition, the future of the Apple Card remains uncertain, with potential changes in its management and structure on the horizon.

Apple NFC and the Anti Trust Lawsuit

The European Commission initiated an antitrust investigation against Apple, accusing the company of abusing its dominant market position by restricting third-party access to NFC technology on iOS devices. This exclusivity forced users to rely solely on Apple Pay for contactless payments, stifling competition and innovation in the mobile payments market. In response to regulatory pressure, Apple proposed commitments to open its NFC technology to third-party developers, allowing them to access NFC functionality via APIs without needing to use Apple Pay or Apple Wallet. This move aims to address competition concerns and prevent potential fines that could have reached billions of dollars.

In parallel, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has filed an antitrust lawsuit against Apple, alleging that the company's practices violate antitrust laws by monopolizing the smartphone market. The DOJ's complaint centers around Apple's restriction of third-party access to the NFC chip, which limits the functionality of third-party digital wallets and other applications on iOS devices. The lawsuit claims that Apple's closed ecosystem suppresses competition and innovation, drawing parallels to previous antitrust cases against other tech giants. This legal action is part of a broader effort to challenge Apple's control over its ecosystem and ensure a competitive market environment.

Apple's decision to open its NFC technology marks a significant shift in its strategy, driven by regulatory pressures and legal challenges. By allowing third-party developers to access NFC capabilities, Apple is fostering a more competitive environment in the mobile payments space. This change not only benefits developers by enabling them to create a wider range of NFC-enabled applications but also enhances consumer choice and flexibility. However, developers will need to navigate commercial agreements with Apple and comply with security and privacy standards to access the NFC APIs, presenting both opportunities and challenges in this evolving landscape.

The future of Apple NFC and the payment ecosystem

Opening up Apple's NFC technology to third-party developers is poised to bring a wave of innovations across various sectors. With the release of iOS 18.1, developers now have access to NFC and Secure Element APIs, allowing them to create applications that leverage NFC technology for a wide range of functionalities beyond just payments. This move is expected to foster increased competition and innovation, enabling developers to offer new and enhanced services directly within their apps, independent of Apple Pay and Apple Wallet.

?

One of the most significant areas of innovation is in digital identification and access. Developers can now create apps that use NFC for digital keys, allowing users to unlock cars, homes, and hotel rooms with their iPhones. This capability extends to corporate badges and student IDs, streamlining access control and identification processes. Additionally, the ability to support closed-loop transit fares and merchant loyalty programs opens up new opportunities for businesses to enhance customer engagement and streamline operations.

Furthermore, the expanded NFC capabilities are expected to lead to the development of apps that support government IDs, event tickets, and more. This broadening of use cases not only enhances consumer convenience but also encourages developers to innovate and differentiate their offerings. By allowing third-party developers to access the NFC chip, Apple is creating a more competitive environment that could lead to improved user experiences and a wider array of NFC-enabled services. However, developers must navigate Apple's commercial agreements and comply with security and privacy standards to fully leverage these new capabilities.

?

?

?

?