Anti Sh*t Tech

Anti Sh*t Tech

Prem Kumar gets me! He said before our Live that I am anti sh*t tech. ????

I remember smelly blue rollered photocopies in the 1970s, Beta and VHS players in the 1980s, and the excitement of owning a typewriter with a correction key in the early 1990s; no more Tippex! The joy that came from shifting from a corded to a cordless phone and using my first remote. I recall using my first computer, email and mobile phone and the life-changing impact of the internet. I began working from home in 2009 using a browser, Skype and mobile. As a Gen-X, I have embraced plenty of technological change and ditched plenty of sh*t tech.

It is amusing how many HR tech vendors erroneously think I hate tech because my first book is titled The Robot-Proof Recruiter. Thankfully, readers know the truth!

Not everyone can do recruitment, though everyone likes to think they can. So, I dislike technology that is created by someone who has never spent time finding, engaging, wooing, negotiating, and everything else entailed with keeping people in a hiring process and converting them to a new starter, for another person.

The best technology for talent acquisition or agencies is created by or with the input of recruiters and enables the delivery of a better experience for hiring managers, talent acquisition/recruiters and candidates. It creates ease! It supports and enables.

The best technology vendors listen to their clients and don't add unnecessary steps or block progress. Their tech doesn't cause a TA pro to burst into tears because all the extra clicks in the new system flared up their carpel tunnel. It doesn't lead to a deluge of applications and undue stress because it doesn't allow knock-out questions per role. And that's just the first two examples I thought of!

Keeping it real

I avoid the vendor agenda; promoting tech for gain whether it helps recruiters or not. I only standby technology that saves you time, money and hassle. If you see my name associated with technology, know I rate it because I see the bigger and more concerning picture.

As company leaders face pressure from boards and shareholders to outcompete with technology and cut costs, TA pros must know what technology is available, realistic, and its limitations. I teach my clients in workshops and webinars or mentoring, to be ready to prove why AI cannot replace talent acquisition; they know how to show their value, and provide wisdom and possible solutions, that make the C-suite see them as strategic.

Ask vendors tough questions - this is not the time for people-pleasing.

At IHR Live last week, I asked a vendor about bias in the tool. His arms crossed as he said, 'Humans are biased!' I replied, 'Indeed they are but I just told the overflowing crowd at my talk to drill into how the algorithms are created and how you are mitigating against bias.' Only then did he explain and uncross his arms.

Repeatedly I ask vendors, how does this save recruiters and managers time, money and hassle? How does this deliver value and a better experience to the users and poor people stuck in the hiring process?

Don't be fobbed off by any vendors. You need this information to have realistic and knowledgeable conversations with leadership. (Also read Matt Charney's thoughts in this piece! I cannot wait for the follow-up.)


Decorative image talking about a new challenge for recruiters - click for link and info
Challenge link! ??

Not sh*t tech

Right before I was to chat with Prem about Humanly's Conversational AI, I read this post from Martyn Redstone. He knows a lot about the topic and explains tech in layman's terms, which is super helpful. Be sure to subscribe to his newsletter too.

Screenshot of Martyn Redstones LinkedIn post. Follow the link for the info as it is quite long.

I was introduced to Humanly by Bennett Sung, and have mentioned their tech in both my first book and Reboot Hiring, so it is fair to say I am a fan. However, if Prem had attempted to fob me off or evaded my questions, he'd have lost trust. Instead, he answered me clearly and without defensiveness.

My favourite part of their tech is the 'flight recorder box' which helps mitigate against bias or unfairness. To know how Humanly's conversational AI helps high-volume recruiters and desk-less employees save time, money and hassle when hiring, give it a listen!

Other not sh*t tech

I have a long list of tech I love for its ability to support the work I do and help you all.

What's your favourite tech? What makes it so?

What questions do you like to ask vendors before buying tech?



Thank you to everyone who has subscribed to this newsletter & shares each edition. ??????

I usually publish at 7.30 am UK time every other Wednesday. Subscribe & click the ?? on my profile to see future posts, or receive it by email by turning this feature on in your settings.

Decorative image only

Recruiters and TA leaders:


Curious souls:


Originally posted at KatrinaCollier.com

Susan Akers

Talent Acquisition Partner (on Career Break)

5 个月

Spot on Katrina. I don't know how many poorly thought through and useless "recruiter" systems I have used over the years and one of my common responses has been - did they actually have a recruiter involved in creating this or even just to test this for them? Unnecessarily overcomplicated, or so simple that all it can do is very very basic stuff while frustrating the recruiter and increasing costs and time to get talent. Management should get their own TA teams to beta test the heck out of any system they are looking to purchase, otherwise they will find themselves keeping a useless system (because it cost them a bomb) or replacing it with another one a couple of years down the track. Don't get me started on assessment tools that have so much inbuilt bias!

Dr. Chantelle Brandt Larsen DBA, MA, FCIPD??????????????????????

??Elevating Equity for All! ?? - build culture, innovation and growth with trailblazers: Top Down Equitable Boards | Across Workplaces Equity AI & Human Design | Equity Bottom Up @Grassroots. A 25+ years portfolio.

5 个月

Na…. think having an excellent bull s*** radar on tech it’s an asset ??

Jeremy A. Lyons

Your Source for All Things RecOps | Helping Make RecOps Accessible Since 2022

5 个月

I think this article needs to be said louder for the people in the back because it is so spot on!

Dirk Spencer

Senior Executive Sourcer at Empower Pharmacy supporting our headquarters team in Houston, Texas.

5 个月

Martyn Redstone how much of this chatbot LLM vs AEO in your opinion? I've latched on the Answer Engine Optimization buzzword and its cause more than one vendor kabuki demo to commit software seppuku. If AI takes 10X the effort, energy, how does thay play out on the LLM chatbot? (thanks). Any goto sources you can recommend on your POV on the language training or questions to ask beyond the points you've made here?

Milana Kutli?

IT recruiter | Helping companies to find & retain highly skilled IT talent | Founder & CEO at HR Story

5 个月

Yes yes yes, on the dot! I hate when people provide novelty solutions without those solutions actually offering any improvements. It's just novelty for the sake of...novelty. And, the worst of it is that those solutions are often created by people who aren't even in the industry where the problem exists in the first place, so they don't understand the problem at all. Love this!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Katrina Collier ????????的更多文章

  • AI Snake Oil: Recruiters Beware

    AI Snake Oil: Recruiters Beware

    For those of us who have experienced previous recruitment fads, the trend of placing AI in front of everything is all…

    48 条评论
  • Hiring Is Personal

    Hiring Is Personal

    Think about it. It's your partnership with the manager, your understanding of who they need to hire, and your job to go…

    27 条评论
  • What If It's Not Apathy?

    What If It's Not Apathy?

    What if it's self-sacrifice? What if it's self-harm? What if we can no longer be impassive or indifferent? In…

    8 条评论
  • Ageism: TA Against TA

    Ageism: TA Against TA

    Over the last year or so, I have seen ageism play out repeatedly in the TA profession against their TA peers. You've…

    45 条评论
  • What If It's Not Quixotic?

    What If It's Not Quixotic?

    My father was born in 1929 and as a teenager in Australia vividly remembered World War 2. My father was Jewish—he…

    4 条评论
  • Unsubstitutable Recruiters

    Unsubstitutable Recruiters

    Matt Ballantine wrote in a post last week: People will not be replaced by AI, but they might be substituted by…

    24 条评论
  • What If It's Not Answerable?

    What If It's Not Answerable?

    What happens when you haven't got an answer or, worse, say the wrong thing? It's awkward. That feeling of damned if you…

    9 条评论
  • Stop Hiring Humans ????

    Stop Hiring Humans ????

    On Christmas Day, ironically, a post appeared in my Instagram feed screaming, "Stop Hiring Humans!" The image below was…

    16 条评论
  • What If It's Not Pleasing?

    What If It's Not Pleasing?

    Publishing this between Christmas and New Year may be the silliest thing to do during the festive season but this…

    6 条评论
  • Recruiters, 6 Things To Leave In 2024

    Recruiters, 6 Things To Leave In 2024

    In time-honoured tradition, my final article of 2024 contains things I would love the talent acquisition and…

    37 条评论