Angels, Allies & Angst: A Manel Story
Bobbie Carlton
Founder/Speaker/Marketer/PR Thought Leader/Publisher/Editor-in-chief. Advocating for more women onstage
Recently, a local angel investor shared a redacted email with me and a small group of other “interested parties.”
He had been invited to participate in a panel discussion — a manel. (And, if you are unfamiliar with the term, that’s an all-male panel, a ridiculous situation in this day and age. It says that the event organizers couldn’t find a suitable woman for the panel.)?
His response to the invitation was to share his commitment to not participate in panels like this, especially ones where the panelists were all white men. Instead, he suggested the names of several women he knew who would fit the bill.?
The response from the organizer? “We didn't mean to exclude women. We didn't know anyone to ask.”?
I’m not buying this - it’s an excuse, and a poor one.
The more accurate response is, “It never occurred to us to specifically recruit a woman.” With the follow-up, “We will try to do better on future panels.”
That’s why we need to call out manels when we see them. Event organizers need to be made aware that they’re part of a systemic problem before they can step up to do something about it.
If the organizer has truly tapped out his network (pronoun intentional), there are many resources that will help.
Innovation Women was created specifically to solve this problem. Our free-for-event-managers database (SERIOUSLY, IT’S FREE FOR YOU) has literally thousands of speakers and subject matter experts, covering 190 industries, more than 7000 topics, in every state in the country and more than 50 other countries.
Event organizers can search the database by topic, industry, location, and title. Profiles contain headshots, biographies, links to social media, videos, topics covered, example talks and more. Many of them are speakers and subject matter experts who speak for visibility for themselves and their company. Innovation Women is not a traditional bureau. Our speakers can choose from several designations based on how and if they get compensated. Assuming the profile of our emailer, I found appropriate local speakers in about 10 seconds.
I raised money for Innovation Women in 2014 and rolled out the platform in 2015. We’ve grown the platform tremendously over the years and currently have:
In 2020, Innovation Women acquired Lioness Magazine, a digital magazine for female entrepreneurs. Lioness regularly features stories about startups, entrepreneurship, investing and investors.
Given all this, you'd expect that this resource, especially in the Boston area where I’m well known and frequently speak at events, would be more on certain people's radar.
OK, maybe you didn’t know (or think) about Innovation Women. But somehow, you also missed out on these resources as well:
We’re shining a light on issues like this because, well, the light bulb has to know it’s burnt out before it can change.
# # #
?
Women's Keynote Speaker: Leadership & Business ? Coach? Energizing Audiences with Engagement ?Be Powerful, Be You!? Women's ERG Top Speaker ?WSJ, NYT, Forbes, HR Mag ?From Gang Member to Bd Member
4 周Well said Bobbie. Innovation Women is a tremendous resource. I'm always fascinated that they don't do a search on LinkedIn.. Even noticing the Women in their network. It is that they don't ASK, don't think to ask, so how will they ever receive
Non Executive Director, advisor, investor
4 周We are in 2024 and this still happens. Crazy.
Founder & CEO of ESTE Leverage | Future-proofing Careers in Deep Tech & Impact Industries | Scaling Ventures for Revenue & Social Good
1 个月Thank you Bobbie for your work getting us on stage!
Work
1 个月What’s crazy is that many conference organizers are WOMEN. I have talked to them about MANELS and panels without underrepresented people, and many of them simply shrug their shoulders. There are some who were grateful when I connected them to potential speakers, and others that never bothered to follow up. So let’s hold EVERYONE accountable for this behavior, both men and WOMEN!
??Learn 3 Ways to Supercharge LinkedIn to Find a Job. FREE WEBINAR: CLICK HERE | I Help Job Seekers, Solopreneurs & B2B Sales Teams Unlock the Power of LinkedIn ???? | Always Teaching | Marketing Leader | Loves Pie ??
1 个月Adding a comment to help spread the word. You're an amazing woman, Bobbie. Thanks for all you do to help support women speakers.