Analysis of Swami Vivekananda’s Philosophy Using the PASSIONIT+PRUTL Framework

Analysis of Swami Vivekananda’s Philosophy Using the PASSION+PRUTL Framework

The PASSION+PRUTL framework offers a comprehensive lens for evaluating Swami Vivekananda's philosophy, bridging dimensions of soul, materialism, realism, and transcendence. Let's analyze how each dimension aligns with or critiques his vision.

PASSION Dimensions Analysis

1. Probing (Inquiry into Truth)

• Strength: Vivekananda's philosophy is deeply probing, encouraging individuals to question traditional beliefs and explore the essence of existence. His emphasis on Advaita Vedanta aligns with probing as it challenges dualistic notions and conventional religiosity.
• Reality Check: While probing promotes intellectual inquiry, it may alienate those who rely on simpler, emotional frameworks of faith. Many people find it difficult to internalize abstract concepts like “Oneness” without tangible examples. Can a society embedded in dualism or ritualism evolve rapidly toward non-dualistic thinking without losing its cultural identity?

2. Innovating (New Spiritual Paradigms)

• Strength: Vivekananda innovatively combined spirituality and practicality, emphasizing service (Karma Yoga) as a path to realization. His approach to serving humanity as worship was revolutionary for its time.
• Reality Check: Innovation often requires sustained efforts to integrate with existing societal structures. The philosophy risks being confined to intellectual elites rather than reaching masses who may prioritize ritualism or material needs over abstract spiritual goals.

3. Acting (Implementation of Ideas)

• Strength: Vivekananda’s life was a testament to action, from founding the Ramakrishna Mission to addressing the Parliament of the World’s Religions. His philosophy motivated individuals to take tangible steps toward spiritual growth and social service.
• Reality Check: The gap between his ideals and their practical adoption remains significant. Despite his call for selfless service, modern society often prioritizes individualism and materialism, diluting the impact of his teachings.

4. Scoping (Universal Application)

• Strength: Vivekananda's message of oneness and religious harmony has universal appeal. His vision of unity across faiths aligns with a global perspective.
• Reality Check: The universality of his philosophy may not resonate in regions entrenched in exclusivist ideologies. Can the philosophy of oneness bridge the divides of nationalism, political conflicts, or economic disparities?

5. Setting (Frameworks for Growth)

• Strength: The frameworks Vivekananda established—Karma Yoga, Advaita Vedanta, and Seva (service)—offer scalable models for personal and societal growth.
• Reality Check: These frameworks demand a level of self-discipline and introspection that modern, fast-paced societies often lack.

6. Owning (Personal Responsibility)

• Strength: Vivekananda’s teachings emphasize self-reliance and inner strength, resonating with individual ownership of one’s spiritual journey.
• Reality Check: The responsibility can feel overwhelming for individuals conditioned to seek external solutions through rituals or intermediaries.

7. Nurturing (Sustained Evolution)

• Strength: His philosophy nurtures a long-term vision of spiritual and social harmony. It focuses on developing inner strength, compassion, and universal brotherhood.
• Reality Check: Sustaining such ideals requires a collective shift, which can be undermined by societal distractions like materialism and political polarization.

PRUTL Dimensions Analysis

1. Positive Soul (Spiritual Awakening)

• Vivekananda’s philosophy champions the awakening of the divine within, fostering compassion and interconnectedness.
• Reality Check: How many truly awaken to this potential in a world driven by ego and individualism?

2. Negative Soul (Ego and Division)

• His teachings caution against ego, which leads to division and conflict.
• Reality Check: Ego-driven conflicts—religious, political, or personal—remain a barrier to the realization of his ideals.

3. Positive Materialism (Constructive Use of Resources)

• Vivekananda encouraged leveraging material resources for societal good, such as education and service.
• Reality Check: Modern materialism often skews toward greed and consumption rather than constructive use.

4. Negative Materialism (Excess and Exploitation)

• He criticized blind materialism and excess, urging focus on inner wealth.
• Reality Check: The global trend toward consumerism challenges this principle, creating a dissonance between his ideals and contemporary life.

Framework Reality Checks

1. Philosophy vs. Practicality: Advaita’s abstract nature makes it intellectually appealing but practically inaccessible for the masses. Dualism might better serve those seeking simpler, more relatable spiritual frameworks.
2. Cultural and Social Limitations: Can societies entrenched in rituals, caste hierarchies, or religious dogmas adopt the egalitarian ideals of Vivekananda without significant resistance?
3. Materialism vs. Spiritualism: His emphasis on spirituality over materialism clashes with the reality of economic aspirations in modern societies.
4. Global Adoption of Oneness: Political, economic, and religious divides make it challenging to universally adopt his vision of oneness.
5. Sustained Relevance: As societies evolve, the challenge lies in ensuring his teachings remain relevant amid technological and cultural shifts.

The PASSION+PRUTL framework reveals that Swami Vivekananda’s philosophy is visionary, fostering spiritual growth, compassion, and service. However, its practical adoption faces challenges: societal conditioning, materialistic distractions, and philosophical abstraction. While his teachings serve as a beacon of hope, they demand a collective awakening and commitment to bridge the gap between ideals and reality.

By addressing these gaps, societies can better align with his vision, creating a harmonious balance between the soul’s evolution and material progress.

?