ANALYSIS: Calls grow for Bolton impeachment testimony
January 27, 2020 23H06 GMT/ZULU
Related Topics
Image copyright
GETTY IMAGES
by Melissa Gruz and Biodun Iginla, BBC News Analysts, Washington
Pressure has grown for former National Security Adviser John Bolton to testify in the US President Donald Trump's impeachment trial.
Calls for his testimony come amid claims that the adviser directly linked Mr Trump to a plan to freeze aid to Ukraine in exchange for a political favour.
The claims, reportedly made in a book manuscript, are central to the trial that has resumed on Monday.
Mr Trump denies the charges.
But the claims allegedly made by Mr Bolton could damage the president's defence.
The president is accused of withholding military aid to pressure Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky to start a corruption investigation into Mr Biden, and his son Hunter.
Mr Trump told reporters last week that he did not want Mr Bolton to testify, citing national security concerns.
President Trump has repeatedly branded the impeachment proceedings a "witch hunt".
Media caption
Mitt Romney: 'Important to hear from John Bolton'
However, some Republicans have now said Mr Bolton should be heard from.
The claims emerged as the impeachment trial resumes on the Senate floor.
Speaking on the second day of Mr Trump's defence, attorney Kenneth Starr, warned senators that impeachment could become "normalised" and used as a weapon against future administrations.
Mr Starr was made famous for leading an investigation into President Bill Clinton that laid the foundation for the Democrat's 1998 impeachment.
"Like war, impeachment is hell," Mr Starr said on Monday. "It's filled with acrimony and divides the country like nothing else. Those of us who lived through the Clinton impeachment understand that in a deep and personal way."
WHAT DO THE NEW REPORTS ALLEGE?
On Sunday, the New York Times cited excerpts from an unpublished book by Mr Bolton, who was fired from the White House in early September.
They included claims that Mr Trump told Mr Bolton in August that he wanted to withhold $391 million (￡300 million) in security aid to Ukraine until officials there assisted with probes into Democrats, including Mr Biden.
- Could John Bolton be an impeachment game-changer?rrH?
- Trump impeachment trial: All you need to know
- Who's who in the Trump-Ukraine story?
If true, such a claim would undermine the main argument of Mr Trump's defence team that there was no "quid pro quo" offered aid in return for investigating Mr Biden.
"Bolton directly contradicts the heart of the President's defence," tweeted Democratic congressman Adam Schiff, who serves as the senior House prosecutor in the impeachment trial.
"If the trial is to be fair, Senators must insist that Mr Bolton be called as a witness, and provide his notes and other documents."
WILL IT CHANGE ANYTHING?
Analysis - Anthony Zurcher, BBC News
While John Bolton has said he's happy to appear before the Senate, whether he can do so starts with a question of simple maths. Are there four Republicans out of the 53 in the Senate interested enough in what he has to say to bring him in to testify?
While he clearly could be a key witness - revealing the motivations behind the hold on US aid to Ukraine and the president's involvement - calling him as a witness would plunge the Senate trial into the unknown.
Republicans have already said that if Bolton appears, they'll also subpoena the Bidens, the whistleblower and others. It could start a tit-for-tat that drags on for weeks, ending the prospects of a speedy conclusion to the proceedings.
What's more, there could be a legal battle over whether Bolton, if called, could be allowed to actually speak. The president has already hinted at a legal battle to stop him.
The truth - at least, Bolton's version of it - will eventually come out. The quandary for the handful of Senate Republicans on the fence about witnesses is whether they want to hear it now or keep the lid on things until after the president's likely acquittal.
WHAT HAS BEEN THE REACTION TO THE LATEST REVELATIONS?
Interest for Mr Bolton to testify grew following the New York Times report. Republican Senator Mitt Romney said: "I think it's increasingly likely that other Republicans will join those of us who think we should hear from John Bolton."
Susan Collins, a centrist Republican from Maine, tweeted: "The reports from John Bolton's book strengthen the case for witnesses".
Doug Jones, a Democratic senator from Alabama, said the body should issue a subpoena for the manuscript if Mr Bolton could not be brought to testify.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said that Republicans' refusal to call Mr Bolton and others is "now even more indefensible".
Skip Twitter post by @SpeakerPelosi
Nancy Pelosi
?
@SpeakerPelosi
Amb. Bolton reportedly heard directly from Trump that aid for Ukraine was tied to political investigations.
The refusal of the Senate to call for him, other relevant witnesses, and documents is now even more indefensible.
The choice is clear: our Constitution, or a cover-up. https://
twitter.com/maggienyt/stat
us/1221568821879885824
…
Maggie Haberman
?
@maggieNYT
SCOOP: Bolton book draft, circulated to associates and sent to WH for review process, describes a convo w POTUS where he says he doesn't want to release withheld aid till Ukraine turned over material related to investigations @nytmike and me
https://www.
nytimes.com/2020/01/26/us/
politics/trump-bolton-book-ukraine.html
…
74.2K
12:14 AM - Jan 27, 2020
Twitter Ads info and privacy
33.4K people are talking about this
End of Twitter post by @SpeakerPelosi
But Mr Trump denied the claim, writing on Twitter: "I NEVER told John Bolton that the aid to Ukraine was tied to investigations into Democrats, including the Bidens.
"In fact, he never complained about this at the time of his very public termination. If John Bolton said this, it was only to sell a book." Mr Bolton served as National Security Adviser to Mr Trump from April 2018 to September 2019, when his departure was announced on Twitter.
Mr Bolton's lawyers said the book's "pre-publication review process has been corrupted and that information has been disclosed by persons other than those properly involved in reviewing the manuscript".
They blamed the White House for the leak, which had received a copy to review it for any disclosure of classified information.
The Republican national party appeared to criticise Mr Bolton. "How convenient that this leaked info happened to be released at the same time pre-orders were made available for the book on Amazon," a party statement said. "What a joke".
Mr Bolton denied that there was coordination with the New York Times or anyone else regarding disclosures in his book.
The latest reports come after a video made public on Saturday showed Mr Trump ordering the removal of the US ambassador to Ukraine in 2018.
Mr Trump was impeached by the Democrat-led House of Representatives in December 2019, but a two-thirds majority in the Senate is required to remove him from office. With Republicans holding a 53-47 majority in the Senate, the outcome is unlikely.
He is the third president in US history to face an impeachment trial.
Media caption
In the footage from April 2018, Mr Trump can be heard saying "Get rid of her!"
What questions do you have about Donald Trump's impeachment trial?
In some cases your question will be published, displaying your name, age and location as you provide it, unless you state otherwise. Your contact details will never be published. Please ensure you have read our terms & conditions and privacy policy.
Use this form to ask your question:
0/140
Your contact info
We'll be in touch if we look into your question.
Submit
The BBC retains the right to select from these contributions based on editorial requirements and subject to online terms and conditions and BBC editorial guidelines. For more information about how the BBC handles your personal data, see here.
Made with Hearken
RELATED TOPICS
SHARE THIS STORY ABOUT SHARING
- Video
- Video of Donald Trump ordering removal envoy in Ukraine in 2018
- 26 January 2020
- Video
- Trump impeachment trial: Five possible twists ahead
- 21 January 2020
- Could John Bolton be an impeachment game-changer?
- 25 minutes ago
- Impeachment trial: Why did Pelosi use so many pens?
- 16 January 2020
- Trump impeachment: House sends historic case to Senate
- 15 January 2020
US & CANADA
US mourns basketball legend Kobe Bryant
- 27 January 2020
- From the section
- US & Canada
Full article US mourns basketball legend Kobe Bryant
SPORT 'A genius who had his controversies'
- 27 January 2020
- From the section
- Sport
Full article 'A genius who had his controversies'
Billie Eilish is the big winner at the Grammys
- 27 January 2020
- From the section
- Entertainment & Arts 290
- comments
Full article Billie Eilish is the big winner at the Grammys
More Videos from the BBC
- The dangerous downsides of a fitness obsession
- Could these ancient mummies be descended from Atlanteans?
- The teenage Dutch girls who seduced and killed Nazis
- 'I slept in the daytime because it was safer'
- US reporter's guilt over live TV backside slap
- Did Prince Charles snub US Vice-President Pence?
Elsewhere on BBC
- BBC News
- Swiss police 'exposed Russian spies in Davos'
- BBC News
- Woman dies in Australian lamington-eating contest
- BBC News
- Harry and Meghan's trademark bid challenged
You Might Also Like
- BBC Culture
- Is it time the all-white period drama was made extinct?
- BBC Future
- What the earliest life on Earth looked like
- BBC Travel
- The birthplace of Canada’s mountain culture
From Around the Web
- Read This Before You Renew Amazon Prime Again
- Wikibuy
- The Reason Banks Don't Recommend Reverse Mortgage
- Reverse Mortgage | Sponsored Links
- MBA Program - No Prior Qualification Needed
- MBA Degrees | Sponsored Listings
- Born Before 1985? Gov't Will Pay $271/Month Off Your Mortgage If You Qualify
- Mortgage Benefits
- Champagne Wishes with Delta Vacations!
- Travel Leaders
- [Photos] Look Closer, These Hilarious T-shirt Fails are Real
- Parentztalk
TOP STORIES
Prince Andrew 'uncooperative' over Epstein inquiry
US Attorney Geoffrey Berman says the FBI has contacted the Duke of York's lawyers.
Calls grow for Bolton testimony after book claim
FEATURES
Kobe Bryant: 'Genius who had his controversies'
How his hometown is mourning
'I was 90% dead': Henri's story of surviving Auschwitz
Could John Bolton be an impeachment game-changer?
The secret life of Yakuza women
High stakes, low chances for Trump peace plan
The fight for Kinshasa’s most vulnerable girls
China coronavirus: A visual guide
The 'spy scandal' that blew up a rocket scientist's career
ELSEWHERE ON THE BBC
Football phrases
15 sayings from around the world
MOST READ
- 1
- Prince Andrew 'uncooperative' over Epstein inquiry, US prosecutor says
- 2
- Kamali Gabbidon-Lynck: Fight breaks out in court as killers jailed
- 3
- Prince Harry: Rated People ad 'lookalike' on Twitter reaction
- 4
- Gary Lineker calls for 'voluntary' licence fee
- 5
- Sir Philip Pullman calls for 50p boycott over Oxford comma
- 6
- East Croydon railway station stabbing leaves man dead
- 7
- Kobe Bryant: Investigators work to determine crash cause
- 8
- Prostate overtakes breast as 'most common cancer'
- 9
- The Masked Singer: ITV apologises for Natalie Cole error
- 10
- Auschwitz 75 years on: William and Kate light candles to commemorate Holocaust
Posted by Biodun Iginla at 1:10 PM Email This
Labels: bbc news, John Bolton, Melissa Gruz and Biodun Iginla, Trump impeachment