America’s Position as a World Leader: A Force for Good or a Source of Global Tension?

Welcome to my LinkedIn newsletter! In each issue of Plan B Success, I'll be sharing my thoughts on personal, career and business growth with your success and life fulfillment in view. Subscribe?here to stay updated.

For decades, America has occupied a central position as a world leader, influencing international affairs economically, politically, and militarily.

Its involvement in global issues often evokes a range of emotions, from admiration to criticism. This role, forged in the aftermath of World War II and solidified during the Cold War, has shaped the modern world order.

But as the dynamics of global politics evolve, questions arise: Is America’s leadership making the world better or worse?

Historical Role of America as a Global Leader

America’s role as a world leader began in earnest post-World War II, when it emerged as one of the two superpowers alongside the Soviet Union. The establishment of global institutions like the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the World Bank saw American influence woven into the fabric of global governance. The U.S. also championed democratic values, free-market capitalism, and international cooperation through institutions like NATO.

The Cold War defined much of America’s foreign policy. Its leadership was characterized by a global effort to contain communism, marked by proxy wars, alliances, and the promotion of democracy. The fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 cemented America’s status as the world’s unipolar power, leading to what some called the “American century.”

America’s Contemporary Leadership

In the 21st century, America’s leadership has been both transformative and divisive. The U.S. has been instrumental in shaping the global economy, international security, technological advancement, and climate policy. However, its actions often spark global debates on whether America is a force for global good or a contributor to instability.

1. Global Economy: As the largest economy in the world, America’s policies on trade, monetary issues, and finance ripple across the globe. The dominance of the U.S. dollar as the world’s reserve currency ensures that American economic policies influence everything from inflation in emerging economies to investment flows worldwide. The U.S. has helped foster globalization, leading to unprecedented economic growth in many regions. Yet, it has also faced criticism for promoting trade deals and policies that benefit large corporations at the expense of local industries, workers, and environmental sustainability.
2. Military Influence and Global Security: America’s military presence is unmatched. With over 750 military bases in more than 80 countries and the largest defense budget in the world, the U.S. plays a critical role in global security. It has intervened in numerous conflicts, from Iraq and Afghanistan to Libya and Syria, under the banner of promoting democracy or fighting terrorism. While these interventions are often framed as humanitarian efforts, the results have been mixed. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, for instance, have been widely criticized for creating more instability, leading to power vacuums that were filled by extremist groups like ISIS. America’s military presence in certain regions is also seen as an occupation rather than a protective force, leading to anti-American sentiments and contributing to long-standing conflicts.
3. Champion of Democracy and Human Rights?: America often frames its foreign policy as a fight for democracy, freedom, and human rights. From its support of pro-democracy movements in Eastern Europe to sanctions on authoritarian regimes, the U.S. projects itself as a defender of liberal democratic values. However, this stance has sometimes been inconsistent. For instance, while America advocates for democracy in some regions, it maintains strong alliances with autocratic regimes like Saudi Arabia for strategic reasons, leading to accusations of hypocrisy.
4. Global Technology Leadership: American companies like Apple, Google, and Microsoft have revolutionized the global technology landscape. America’s technological leadership drives innovation in industries from AI to biotechnology, benefiting economies and improving standards of living worldwide. However, it also creates dependencies, with many countries reliant on American technology for critical infrastructure. This dominance can be seen as a double-edged sword — on one hand, driving global progress, while on the other, raising concerns about privacy, surveillance, and the monopolistic power of U.S.-based tech giants.
5. Climate Change and Environmental Leadership: Climate change has become a central issue of global leadership. While the U.S. government has taken significant steps to address climate change, such as rejoining the Paris Agreement under the Biden administration, it has also faced criticism for its historical role in carbon emissions and the influence of the fossil fuel industry on its policies. America’s leadership on environmental issues is vital, given that its domestic policies have global implications. But wavering commitments, such as the withdrawal from the Paris Agreement under the Trump administration, have led some to question the consistency and reliability of U.S. leadership on climate action.

Is America Making the World Better or Worse?

The answer to whether America’s leadership is making the world better or worse depends largely on perspective. Here are some contrasting views:

1. Making the World Better: Supporters of America’s global leadership argue that the U.S. has been a stabilizing force, promoting democratic values, providing humanitarian aid, and defending human rights around the world. America’s technological innovations, cultural exports, and military alliances have created a more interconnected and prosperous global society. Proponents of U.S. leadership point to instances where American intervention has halted atrocities, supported rebuilding efforts in post-conflict zones, and provided aid in times of crisis.
2. Making the World Worse: Critics argue that America’s pursuit of its national interests often comes at the expense of global stability. Military interventions in the Middle East, for instance, have led to long-term instability, civilian casualties, and displacement of populations. America’s economic policies, such as sanctions and trade wars, have often harmed the very people they are meant to help. Furthermore, the perception that America imposes its values on other nations can foster resentment, leading to anti-Americanism and fueling conflict.

Contradictions in U.S. Leadership

One of the biggest challenges to America’s global leadership is its internal contradictions. The U.S. promotes itself as a beacon of democracy, yet its own political system has faced significant challenges, such as increasing polarization, rising authoritarian tendencies, and widespread disinformation. The chaotic response to the COVID-19 pandemic, coupled with social unrest, has also damaged America’s image as a competent global leader.

Moreover, America’s leadership in addressing global issues like climate change is often undermined by its own domestic policies. While promoting environmental responsibility abroad, the U.S. remains one of the largest carbon emitters and has struggled to transition away from fossil fuels. This contradiction weakens its moral authority in global negotiations.

The Path Forward: Can America Rebuild its Leadership?

For America to remain a positive force in the world, it needs to reconcile these contradictions. A more balanced approach, focusing on diplomacy, sustainability, and multilateralism, could help the U.S. regain its credibility. Engaging with international institutions, fostering partnerships rather than imposing its will, and prioritizing global cooperation over unilateral action may enhance America’s position as a constructive leader.

In many ways, America’s role in the world is indispensable, but to make the world truly better, its leadership must evolve to be more inclusive, empathetic, and responsible. In an increasingly interconnected world, where power is shifting toward a multipolar order, the U.S. must transition from being a hegemon to being a partner — one that leads by example rather than dominance.

America’s position as a world leader is both a blessing and a burden.

Its influence has undeniably shaped the modern world, but the question of whether it makes the world better or worse hinges on how it uses that power. As global challenges like climate change, inequality, and geopolitical conflicts intensify, America has a choice: continue down the path of self-interest or rise to the occasion as a leader committed to global well-being. Only time will tell which course it chooses, but the world is watching.

Thank you for reading! I'd love to know your thoughts in the comments below. For more insights from my experiences as an executive and an entrepreneur in how we can harness the power of community to change our world, and to find success and fulfillment, be sure to subscribe to Plan B Success Newsletter .

Want to?SUPERCHARGE?your personal or business brand? To connect with me over a call, GO HERE?=> Grow & Monetize Your Brand

For more such interesting reads, SUBSCRIBE to Plan B Success Newsletter & don't forget to share with a friend!

And, for listening to more inspiring content,?SUBSCRIBE?to Plan B Success podcast on your fav platform, and to watch,?SUBSCRIBE?on YouTube !