Construction projects inherently involve various risks that need to be allocated between the contracting parties. Proper risk allocation ensures that the parties are aware of their responsibilities and potential liabilities, facilitating smoother project execution. Below are the key risks typically addressed in construction contracts:
Quantities
One of the significant uncertainties in construction projects is the volume of resources required. The approach to handling this risk differs based on the type of contract:
- Lump Sum Contracts: Under a lump sum contract, the contractor is paid a fixed amount for the entire project, regardless of the actual quantities of resources used. This places the risk of resource volumes on the contractor, who must accurately estimate the quantities required when formulating their bid. If the contractor underestimates the resources, they bear the financial burden of acquiring additional materials or labor without additional compensation. Conversely, if they overestimate, they benefit from any cost savings. This fixed-price nature incentivizes the contractor to manage resources efficiently but also requires a comprehensive understanding of the project scope and potential challenges.
- Re-measurement Contracts: Also known as unit price contracts, these involve the parties agreeing on unit rates for specific resources or tasks. Payment is based on the actual quantities used, as measured during the project. This means that the employer bears the risk of variations in quantities. If more resources are needed than initially estimated, the employer pays for the additional quantities at the agreed-upon rates. This approach provides flexibility to account for unforeseen changes in resource needs but requires detailed and accurate measurement and verification processes to ensure fair payment.
Errors in Employer-Provided Information
In construction projects, it is common for the employer to provide the contractor with a range of information necessary for planning and executing the work. This includes:
- Specifications: Detailed descriptions of the work required, materials to be used, and standards to be met.
- Site Information: Data about the location, condition, and characteristics of the site where the construction will occur.
- Permits and Approvals: Information on the necessary permits, licenses, and regulatory approvals required for the project.
- Access and Logistics: Details on how the contractor can access the site, including any restrictions or logistical challenges.
The risk associated with the accuracy of this information can be allocated in different ways:
- Non-reliance Basis: If the information is provided "for information only," the contractor assumes the risk of any errors or inaccuracies. The contractor must independently verify the information and cannot claim additional time or costs if the information proves to be incorrect or incomplete. This approach emphasizes the contractor's responsibility for due diligence and independent assessment.
- Employer Assumes Risk: Alternatively, the employer may accept some or all of the risk related to the accuracy of the provided information. In this scenario, the contract may include provisions for time extensions or cost adjustments if errors or omissions in the information lead to delays or additional expenses. This can create a more collaborative approach, where both parties share responsibility for ensuring the information's accuracy and addressing any discrepancies.
Unforeseen Ground Conditions
Unforeseen ground conditions, such as unexpected soil properties, rock formations, or groundwater levels, can significantly impact construction projects. These conditions can necessitate changes in construction methods, delay progress, and increase costs. Contracts address this risk through specific provisions:
- Geotechnical Surveys: Employers often commission detailed geotechnical surveys to provide contractors with information about the site conditions. However, these surveys may not always capture every possible subsurface condition.
- Contractual Clauses: Contracts typically include clauses that outline how unforeseen ground conditions will be handled. These clauses may allow for extensions of time and additional compensation if the contractor encounters conditions that were not reasonably foreseeable based on the information provided.
- Tender Pricing: Contractors need to consider potential unforeseen ground conditions when preparing their bids. Including contingencies for such risks can help manage the financial impact if they occur.
Force Majeure
Force majeure refers to events beyond the control of the parties that can delay, impair, or prevent the performance of contractual obligations. These events can include natural disasters, war, pandemics, and other extraordinary occurrences. The treatment of force majeure varies by legal system:
- Civil Law Systems: Many civil law jurisdictions, such as those influenced by French or German law, have well-defined concepts like imprévision (French) and rebus sic stantibus (German), which allow for contract adjustment in the face of unforeseen and extraordinary events that make performance excessively burdensome or impossible.
- Common Law Systems: Common law systems, including English law, do not have a general theory of force majeure. Instead, force majeure must be expressly defined and provided for in the contract. The contract typically lists specific events considered as force majeure and outlines the consequences, such as time extensions or termination rights.
- FIDIC and Standard Forms: Standard form contracts, such as those from FIDIC (International Federation of Consulting Engineers), include detailed provisions for force majeure (now often referred to as "Exceptional Events"). These provisions define what constitutes a force majeure event, the notice requirements, and the relief available to the affected party.
Change in Law
Changes in law during the course of a project can affect the obligations and costs for both parties:
- Default Position: Generally, each party is expected to comply with existing laws at the time of contract execution.
- Contractual Provisions: Contracts may include specific clauses addressing changes in law. These clauses can provide for time extensions, additional costs, or adjustments to the contract price to account for the impact of new or amended laws. This ensures that neither party is unduly penalized for legal changes beyond their control.
Delay
Delays are a critical risk in construction projects, and contracts manage this risk through several mechanisms:
- Time for Completion: Contracts specify a date or period by which the contractor must complete the works. Failure to meet this deadline can result in liquidated damages, which are predetermined sums payable by the contractor for each day of delay.
- Extension of Time: Contracts should allow for extensions of time if delays are caused by events beyond the contractor's control, such as acts of prevention by the employer, force majeure events, or other specified causes. This ensures that the contractor is not unfairly penalized for delays they could not prevent.
Performance Guarantees
Performance guarantees ensure that the constructed facility meets specified performance criteria, especially in projects involving process plants or facilities that produce a product:
- Testing and Commissioning: Contracts outline a regime for testing and commissioning the facility to verify its performance. This includes specific tests, criteria, and timelines.
- Remedies for Non-Performance: If the facility fails to meet the performance guarantees, the contract typically allows the contractor to rectify the issues. If the contractor cannot achieve the required performance, they may be required to pay liquidated damages to compensate the employer. Some contracts also specify minimum performance levels, below which the employer can reject the facility.
Indemnification
Indemnity clauses allocate primary responsibility for certain adverse events to one party, who must hold the other party harmless against the consequences:
- Third-Party Claims: Indemnity clauses often cover third-party claims arising from the contractor's activities. For example, the contractor may indemnify the employer against claims for personal injury or property damage caused by the contractor's negligence.
- Re-allocation of Risk: These clauses re-allocate risk between the parties, ensuring that the party best able to manage the risk assumes responsibility for it.
Insurance
Insurance is a critical mechanism for managing insurable risks in construction projects:
- Mandated Insurances: Contracts may specify that parties must obtain and maintain certain types of insurance, such as liability insurance, property insurance, and workers' compensation insurance. This ensures that financial protection is in place for various risks.
- FIDIC Forms: Standard contracts like FIDIC pre-allocate responsibility for obtaining specific insurances. For example, the contractor may be required to insure the works against damage, while the employer may need to obtain insurance for third-party liability. The allocation of insurance responsibilities helps to clarify which party bears the financial risk for different types of losses.
For Claims and Contracts management services contact [email protected]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
?????????? ???? ????????????:
???????????????????????? ???????????????? ????????????:
?????? ???????? ???? ?????? / ???????????????????????? ??????????????????:
?????????????????????? ??????????????????:
#constructionclaims #delayanalysis #SCL #Constructioncontracts #contractmanagement #claimsmanagement #Delayclaims #variationclaims
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
