Is AI the Real Problem in Marketing, or Is It the Lack of Human Experience?

The Current Marketing Landscape

AI in marketing has become a divisive topic due to the combination of hiring less experienced talent and the increasing role of AI. Some view AI as a threat to creativity and human jobs, while others see it as a powerful tool for enhancing efficiency. This tension has created a critical point of discussion in the industry, especially as AI continues to transform how marketing strategies are developed and executed.

The Short-Term Cost Focus

Over the last decade, many companies have shifted their focus towards short-term ROI, often opting for lower-cost, less experienced hires. This cost-cutting approach has led to:

• Diminished overall customer experience and loyalty
• Decline in creative output quality
• Weakened brand connections
• Less impactful messaging

As McKinsey research shows, addressing individual touchpoints—such as a single marketing email or customer service call—without considering the entire customer journey results in merely incremental changes that fail to address core issues.

The Human Experience Gap

While cost-saving measures may benefit the bottom line, they sideline crucial expertise that seasoned marketers bring:

• Understanding of nuanced consumer behavior
• Brand storytelling capabilities
• Long-term strategic thinking
• Deep industry insights

This experience gap becomes particularly problematic as AI plays an increasingly influential role in marketing strategy development and execution.

When AI Gets the Blame: A Case Study

The 2019 Burger King campaign in Brazil serves as a cautionary tale. The AI-generated campaign, which created whopper-related videos, produced culturally insensitive content that sparked significant backlash. This incident demonstrates that AI itself isn't the problem—it's the lack of experienced oversight guiding these initiatives.

The Real Challenge: Finding the Right Balance

Agencies increasingly leverage AI to boost efficiency, but without experienced oversight, they risk:

• Missing brand alignment
• Losing messaging nuance
• Lacking strategic depth

Ironically, in the push for profit, these efficiency measures can become liabilities, leading to misaligned campaigns where AI often takes the blame for what is fundamentally a human expertise gap.

The Way Forward: Integrating Technology and Experience

The solution isn't to step back from AI but to build the right mix of technology and human expertise. This can be achieved through:

• Investment in multi-generational teams
• Continuous training programs
• Balanced approach to AI implementation
• Strategic oversight from experienced marketers

Multi-generational teams are particularly valuable as they bring:

• Diverse perspectives
• Mix of traditional and innovative approaches
• Understanding of both conventional marketing and AI-driven strategies
• Better balanced and more effective outcomes

Looking Ahead

The question isn't whether to use AI in marketing, but how to leverage it effectively while maintaining the human elements that make marketing truly impactful. By investing in both technological advancement and human expertise, organizations can create more powerful, nuanced, and effective marketing strategies.

---

What do you think? How can we balance the power of AI with the value of human experience in marketing?