AI in the Library: Decision Time!

AI in the Library: Decision Time!

While artificial intelligence holds tremendous potential for libraries, it also comes with significant concerns and the potential for harm. We find ourselves sailing uncertain waters; there are few guardrails governing AI's use. Even as we acknowledge this truth, we must also note that library staff are already experimenting with the use of AI chatbots (most commonly ChatGPT), generative AI design tools (like Midjourney), and other variations of AI technology. In short, we have great potential, pitfalls, and a total lack of clarity. It is only through the thoughtful development of policy, procedure, and professionals that we can hope to articulate a vision for the ethical use of AI in our libraries.

AI generated image of a humanoid robot sitting at a desk with a stack of papers scattered about. They are in a quiet office setting.
Generated using Midjourney. Prompts: robot sitting at a desk with a stack of paper contracts. inside of a quiet library. --ar 16:9.

Policy & Procedure Considerations

Whether we develop new policy specific to AI, or view AI through the lens of existing library policy, some considerations include:

Privacy

Simply put, if something is free, then you're the product. AI models are constantly collecting data as they interact with users, train, and evolve. This can have dire consequences, as Samsung recently discovered. Samsung engineers had been using ChatGPT to check source code, only for those trade secrets to be leaked outside of the company. One can easily see library staff leveraging the same or similar technology as a writing assistant, brainstorming tool, etc, only to inadvertently reveal confidential patron information.

Intellectual Property

There has been a proliferation of AI tools that take text prompts from users to generate images (and other media). Design software Canva, already quite popular in libraries, itself has a "Text to Image Tool". To date, the US Copyright Office has determined that since AI art is not the product of "human authorship," it is ineligible for copyright protection. While that may give some clarity (for the time being) on the output of generative AI tools, the trickier ethical piece involves how these models are built. That process includes training the AI model on hundred of millions (even billions) of images on the web, often without the consent of the original artist. To be clear, legal does not necessarily equate to ethical!

Transparency

When we utilize the product of AI, should we let our patrons know? How do we do so? Transparency for an AI generated image might mean citing the program used, along with the specific text prompts employed. Do we acknowledge the use (and extent) of AI-generated copy in our newsletter? That particular distinction, while important early on, may soon seem quaint with the synergy of generative AI and Microsoft Office.

AI generated image of a person using a computer in a darkened room. There is an ominous glow. The screen is bright.
Generated using Midjourney. Prompt: person using a computer in a darkened room that is otherwise empty. ominous glow from computer screen. dramatic. --ar 16:9

Investing in AI

Once we establish some ground rules for the ethical use of AI in our libraries, we can then determine what specific technologies and platforms to invest in. One aspect of investment is financial; many services that are initially free (again with you being the product), will grow in sophistication and eventually cost money. Others are freemium; ChatGPT's free model comes without the guarantee of uptime during high traffic hours, and the access is to a less powerful set of features. In a work setting, you will need more certainty than freemium can provide.

Aside from investing money into AI, you must also invest in your staff; namely through training. Such training is multi-faceted. It should cover:

  • How does the tool work?
  • What are some use cases?
  • How can it be used in a way that conforms with library policy (including data retention)?

Until Next Time!

AI is a truly disruptive technology that is moving with a speed I cannot say I have seen before! A feeling of bewilderment is understandable--I feel it too! That said, the time has come to take a deep breath and get to work laying a foundation of policy guidelines and staff development as we navigate the uncertain road ahead.


Shameless Plug!

I hope you've found this post useful! If you're looking for a speaker for your event feel free to reach out! I cover emerging technologies, staff training, library tech trends, tech on a budget, change management, and more!

Matthew Mayton

Archivist at Arkansas State University

9 个月

I want to say thank you for posting this article. This helped me develop my portion of a presentation on developing ethical AI policies in higher ed and libraries for GAIL.

Theresa Longe

Customer Support | Helpdesk & Ticketing Systems | Zendesk | HubSpot | Library & Information Services

1 年

Very insightful content. Thank you Nick Tanzi !

Saket Sharma

Library Assistant - Central Sanskrit University

1 年

Any AI for repharasing nd grammar ??? Free

回复

I have played a bit with ChatGPT and can see its potential for online reference services.

Joseph Panozzo

MLIS, MBA, Public Library Attendant, Paralegal/Legal Assistant, Archivist, Public Records Researcher, Proofreader, Substitute Teacher, Teacher’s Aide.

1 年

Good explanation.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Nick Tanzi的更多文章

  • Library Tech Trends for 2025

    Library Tech Trends for 2025

    From AI disruption to increasing financial strain on our digital collections, the year 2025 promises to be filled with…

    11 条评论
  • The Library's Value is Increased in the Age of AI

    The Library's Value is Increased in the Age of AI

    Whenever an emerging technology arises, there are inevitably those who will question the value and relevance of the…

    26 条评论
  • Talking Tech: Libraries and Navigating Change

    Talking Tech: Libraries and Navigating Change

    I recently had the opportunity to appear as a guest on the Maryland State Library Agency (MSLA) Podcast with…

    3 条评论
  • The Dangers of AI Avoidance in Libraries

    The Dangers of AI Avoidance in Libraries

    As we continue to identify the pitfalls of using artificial intelligence within a library setting, it is also important…

    35 条评论
  • Artificial Intelligence Opportunities for Libraries

    Artificial Intelligence Opportunities for Libraries

    The age of AI presents many unique challenges for libraries--but also real opportunities. In many ways, disruption is a…

    11 条评论
  • AI & Libraries: Notes from the Field

    AI & Libraries: Notes from the Field

    The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence is prompting libraries to increasingly define their relationship with…

    5 条评论
  • Library Technology Trends for 2024

    Library Technology Trends for 2024

    What are the library tech trends for 2024? In many ways we can expect a year that will be shaped by artificial…

    22 条评论
  • Planning for AI in Your Library When So Much Is Uncertain

    Planning for AI in Your Library When So Much Is Uncertain

    When I speak with library professionals in the U.S.

    7 条评论
  • Best Technologies for Public Libraries: an exploration

    Best Technologies for Public Libraries: an exploration

    I recently had the pleasure to present the seminar "Best Technologies for Public Libraries: Embracing Innovation in…

    7 条评论
  • AI & the Library: Looking for rules!

    AI & the Library: Looking for rules!

    The age of AI necessitates that libraries develop policy and procedure governing the use of the technology within our…

    11 条评论

社区洞察