AI Fatigue and AI Phobia: Is Fear of AI Stalling HR’s Progress?

AI adoption is surging, with organisations around the world integrating AI-driven tools into their operations. According to Gartner, over 50% of companies have already implemented AI in some form, and this figure is expected to rise sharply. But beneath the excitement of these advancements lies a challenge that many HR professionals are beginning to face: AI fatigue.

This fatigue begs a critical question: With overwhelming workloads, how can HR teams realistically integrate AI without burning out? The pressures of adapting to new technologies while continuing to fulfil core responsibilities can be daunting. As a result, many HR leaders consider the idea of hiring a dedicated “AI Officer” to take the reins. But is this really the solution? Tess Hilson-Greener

Is Hiring an AI Officer a Quick Fix or a Long-Term Problem?

The logic behind hiring a dedicated AI professional is understandable. This individual can navigate the complexities of AI, ensuring compliance with regulations and facilitating integration between HR, IT, and legal teams. However, this solution often leads to the creation of silos. Can a single AI officer truly bridge the gap between departments, or does it risk creating a fragmented digital culture?

By positioning AI as the responsibility of one person, HR teams may find themselves detached from the very transformation reshaping their future. AI literacy becomes a skill set confined to one role, rather than being embedded across the HR function. This creates a dangerous precedent where HR professionals become observers rather than drivers of AI-powered change.

What Happens to HR If It Avoids AI Altogether?

Now, consider the alternative: What if HR avoids AI entirely? The truth is, those who shy away from developing AI skills will soon find themselves at a significant disadvantage. Job markets are increasingly prioritising AI literacy, and those without it risk becoming irrelevant in a future where data-driven decision-making and AI-enhanced strategies are the norm.

The workforce of tomorrow will favour professionals who can harness AI to improve efficiency, personalise the employee experience, and align people strategies with business goals. HR’s refusal to engage with AI isn’t an act of caution—it’s a fast-track to obsolescence.

Why Are HR Professionals Afraid of AI? Is It AI Phobia?

So, what’s driving this resistance? Is it a fear of complexity, fear of job loss, or something deeper? Perhaps what we’re seeing is the emergence of what can be called “AI Phobia.” This isn’t just a fear of the unknown; it’s the fear of losing control, of dehumanising HR, and of navigating a steep learning curve.

AI Phobia is about more than just misunderstanding the technology. It reflects a deeper concern that AI is moving too fast, that it’s too abstract or too impersonal to fit within HR’s traditionally human-centred approach. But this fear, like most phobias, is rooted in perception rather than reality.

Is AI Really a Threat to HR, or an Opportunity to Elevate the Profession?

In truth, AI offers HR professionals the chance to reclaim their strategic position at the forefront of organisational change. Is AI truly a threat, or could it be the key to empowering HR to focus on what matters most—people? By using AI to streamline administrative tasks, provide predictive insights, and craft personalised employee experiences, HR can elevate its impact within the organisation.

Rather than dehumanising the HR function, AI can enable professionals to enhance their human-centric work, building cultures that thrive on innovation and engagement.

How Can HR Overcome AI Phobia and Embrace the Future?

The solution to AI Phobia and AI fatigue lies in shifting our mindset. Should AI be seen as a burden, or as a tool for empowerment? Instead of relying on one AI expert, organisations should encourage AI literacy across HR teams, fostering a culture of continuous learning and digital innovation. AI doesn’t replace human strategy—it enhances it.

By addressing the fears surrounding AI and integrating it into HR in manageable, meaningful ways, HR can lead the way into the future of work. Avoiding AI won’t preserve HR’s relevance—embracing it will.

In the end, AI is not the adversary. The real risk is in being unprepared for the opportunities AI brings.

Read our AI Literacy Article next week. Join us for more AI in HR advice and news!