Agile vs. Traditional Project Management. Key Takeaways from our webinar: ????

In our weekly webinar held last week, our speaker, Emmanuels Magaya discussed the differences and similarities between Agile vs Waterfall Project Management. Here are some of the key takeaways:

Understanding the Basics

• Waterfall: Is a sequential, linear approach with defined phases. Best suited for projects with clear requirements and minimal changes. ??
• Agile: is an iterative, flexible approach with continuous feedback. Ideal for projects with evolving requirements and a need for adaptability. ??
• Hybrid: combines elements of both can be effective for certain projects. ??

Key Differences

• Approach: Traditional is top-down (decisions and direction flow from the top of the organizational or project hierarchy down to the team), while Agile is bottom-up (where the team has more autonomy and decision-making power). ????
• Scope: Traditional focuses on the initial defined scope, while Agile allows for changes and flexibility. ????
• Timeline: Traditional has a fixed timeline, while Agile is adaptable. ????
• Delivery: Traditional delivers the entire project at the end, while Agile delivers working increments. ????
• Risk Management: Traditional focuses on upfront risk identification and mitigation, while Agile continuously assesses and manages risks throughout the project. ?????
• Stakeholder Engagement: Traditional stakeholder involvement is limited, while Agile emphasizes continuous engagement. ????
• Documentation: Traditional requires extensive documentation, while Agile prioritizes a working product over documentation. ????

When to Use Which

Waterfall: Is suitable for projects with:

1. Clearly defined requirements ??
2. Stable technology ??
3. Predictable timelines ??
4. Tasks have to be performed in a set sequence with one stage being completed before the next can start ??

Agile: Ideal for projects with:

1. Uncertain or evolving requirements ??
2. Complex problems ??
3. Innovative products ??
4. Short development cycles ??

Hybrid Approach

A hybrid approach is often used when:

1. Projects have a mix of predictable and unpredictable elements. For example, a software development project with a core framework that needs to be built using Waterfall, followed by Agile development for features and customizations.
2. Organizations have a mix of traditional and Agile teams. A hybrid approach can help bridge the gap between the two cultures and methodologies.
3. Projects require a combination of upfront planning and flexibility.

Hybrid can provide a structured framework with room for adaptation.

Interesting concepts discussed in the webinar:

Proof of Concept (PoC) - In Agile project management, a Proof of Concept (PoC) is a process or prototype used to demonstrate the feasibility of a particular approach, technology, or solution before fully committing to its implementation. The PoC is not a fully functional product but a simplified version designed to validate whether the core idea or technical approach will work as intended. The PoC aligns well with the iterative development process, allowing teams to test ideas, learn quickly, and adjust as needed without wasting significant time or resources.

Minimum Viable Product - In Agile project management, MVP stands for Minimum Viable Product. It refers to the most basic version of a product that is developed with just enough features to satisfy early customers and provide feedback for future development. The concept of MVP is critical in Agile because it supports the idea of delivering value to the customer quickly while minimizing risk and resource expenditure.

In summary, the choice between Waterfall and Agile depends on the specific project and organization. By understanding the key differences and considering the factors mentioned above, project managers can make informed decisions about which approach is best suited for their projects. ????

• Agile methodologies like Scrum and Kanban offer specific frameworks and practices within the Agile approach.
• It's important to choose the right Agile framework based on team size, project complexity, and organizational culture.
• Scaling Agile to large projects or organizations can require specific strategies and tools.
• Continuous learning and improvement are essential in both Agile and Waterfall environments.

In part 2 of this article, we will look at Which costs more: Agile vs Waterfall as well as how to transition between the 2.

Kindly subscribe to our newsletter so you stay updated on latest industry trends, job opportunities, training and upcoming events.

Click here to subscribe: https://mailchi.mp/e68e8f3ca3b7/subscribe-to-general-newsletter

You can connect with our speaker on; https://www.dhirubhai.net/in/emmanuelsmagaya/

If you are seeking PMO Advisory and Consulting or if your organization is looking to hire project management resources, kindly get in touch with our Project Advisory Team:

https://projectmanagers.co.za/hire-resources/

#projectmanagers #projectmanagersafrica #agile #waterfall #projectdelivery #projectteams #pmo #advisory #agilecoach #consulting #africa