The “AGE-OLD” Dilemma!

The “AGE-OLD” Dilemma!

“I choose not to invest if the founders are older than my threshold age,” an investor commented to me recently when I asked about his financing philosophy on start-ups.

On another occasion, the CEO of a start-up told me that he is adamant on hiring a HR Head who is younger than him; and mind you, the CEO is 35 years old (or young!) and aspires to build a youthful organisation.

I am 51 years old and finding it difficult to find an appropriate senior level job,” wrote one of my LinkedIn connections.

He hardly has 2 years of experience and yet he is resolute in becoming a manager,” whispered my HR Manager sometime back in the office.

I’m sure you hear these as often as I do at work. And it does seem apparent that age is not just a number at the work place as it is in life.

Let’s reflect on the most telling factor of age at work - is your boss older than you? Or on the contrary, are you younger than some of your direct reports (DRs)? Or do you personally prescribe to the adage that “age does not matter”? Hmm… you’ve got to be kidding! Age, as I’ve come to experience, is one of the most obsessed about aspects at work as much as it is in life!

I was 24 when I was promoted to be a manager with 6 DRs - 2 of whom were older than me. While the younger ones addressed me as “sir”, the remaining 2 seniors would call me by my 1st name – “Kamal”. I recall feeling nervous, especially in collective settings at work and during crucial discussions, when these gentlemen subtlety refused to acknowledge my seniority with the simple act of addressing me by my 1st name.

I always felt when people called me sir, I had an edge in the conversations and felt like a boss :) But more than being addressed that way it was the individual conversations where I felt a lack of control. I sensed a bit of imbalance in our relationship when senior people in my team talked to me and many a times felt they were undermining me as I was young. But maybe it was my lack of experience which made me feel that and made me over exert at times. But I am sure age was a factor in our relationship, either in my mind or theirs, we never got to talk about it though.

With ageing, I have got over my baggage on age influencing my evaluation of my equations with my DRs and bosses, I think. But I tend to argue that if the boss is older,  we tend to accept him relatively easier to start with. Our own need to check her/him out or to evaluate them reduce considerably. I tend to believe that we always have this nagging doubt about younger bosses and take more time to accept them. And since not accepting is not a choice, we choose to rationalize  her/his capability before settling down or moving on.

Why isn’t age just a number, we spend all our life living it, remember the consistent famous question throughout our child hood, “what’s your name baby and the follow up with , how old are you??”. We lived with this question long enough and it plays on our mind in the work equation too.

We also club our age card with our experience. You must be familiar with the following “age-old” claims:

  • I have a total of 20 years’ experience in HR
  • I have spent 5 years in the APAC region
  • I have been in leadership roles for 10 years now

One way or the other, we bring our age and the “experience that comes with age” to demonstrate our superiority at work and in the context of our job. This actually gets played out when we work together as boss and subordinate and we equate our relationship matrixes through age, experience and not to forget, gender. Sigh…I wish it was about common goals, mutual facilitation, trust, and the space we give each other.

In recent times, start-ups have definitely given a new spin to the age factor - the younger you are, the more “zing” you get. Our kids at home are redefining that phrase that “age is just a number” by being totally oblivious to the “power” that was once associated with age. I guess if we can live with this at home, workplaces will soon have to change to adapt to the same!

Strange that I’m discussing this as for over the past 2 decades of working, I’ve rarely had a boss younger than me but who’s not to say that I’m prepared for the eventuality?

Ripe mangoes are always tastier, but many raw mangoes have their own tingling impact!

If you enjoyed this post, please click the thumbs up icon above or share your thoughts in the comments section below. If you didn't then tell me why :)

First Published on: www.kamalkaranth.com


Meenal Gauri

Global Marketing & Sales | CTI Trained Coach | Business Transformation | Women in Leadership | Self Believer | Learner |

9 年

What you have written is true to the last word. In the relatively early stages of my career, I have myself experienced people having skepticism on my capabilities based on my age. I think people assume always work experience to be not experience of work you have done but years/age for which you have been working.

回复
Sanjana Ravindran

Calling out all the Hypocrisy and Doglapan.

9 年

Ageism, is stereotyping and discriminating against individuals or groups on the basis of their age. Unfortunately ageism is practiced openly and widely. Like racism, gender bias perceptions, ageism is only in the mind of the person and it makes it worse if the person is HR or CEO or someone else in position of authority. It is a big misconception that as employees tenure they loose their energy. The 35 years old CEO wants HR Manager younger than himself because he cannot manage his own ego. It takes a lot to be successful as a CEO and one of the thing that he has yet to learn is to manage his perceptions and biases. I hope that such CEOs remain few and do not head bigger companies or they will misuse their positions to layoff tenured employees inorder to showoff their young age

回复
Anand V Rao

TA outsourced programs (RPOs & MSPs) - Implementation, Ops, OpX | Talent supply-chain Ops, Staffing and Recruitment | Coaching, Mentoring, Training (yes, they differ from each other)

9 年

Yes, tastier mangoes are necessary to add taste, while the amount of tingle in the taste can be varied to suit the taste. Also, some roles/fields need the taste while some roles/fields need the tingle

回复
VISHNU SHANKER

NAB II LinkedIn Top Voice II Risk & Mitigation II Employment Laws II Corporate Governance II Strategic management II Disciplinary Management II POSH II Government Relations II Investigations II RBA

9 年

Excellent article sir.

回复

Kamal, firstly compliments for your thought provoking post. A few very quick views and ideas: 1.Demoograhics is driving economics and this shift at the intersection of work-life is undoubtedly here to stay. 2. We see 0 4 generations at play. New generation( millenial) was raised differently and bring a different set of paridigm and perspective and values .This is bound to change the way managing and leadership exists today.Each set comes with its merits and demerits. Example: GenY would expect to lead from the middle( hate top down to say so) but what's evident is they are not capable to do so often.Today's news how we see people start leaving startups. 3. Gen Z is started turning 13 and enough evidence suggest( given their traits) that they will surpass Gen Y. Baby boomers however don't want to retire and Gen X is in pressure due to such a vacuum. The best for each set of people : right experience defies any age, be ready, learn, collaborate and adapt quickly. That's the win-win & not what's typically we vs them....... I am ok to interact and share some cutting edge ideas further...... Am available at-9811270077 Vijay Rai

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Kamal Karanth的更多文章

  • An FIR on Captaincy

    An FIR on Captaincy

    The factors that anoint one to leadership can also bring them down? Though it seemed timely and logical, I was gutted…

    6 条评论
  • In Search of Unknown Angels

    In Search of Unknown Angels

    The paradox of how employers constantly discount their employees dreaming about their imaginary perfect employee…

    17 条评论
  • Hiring - a Cloning Faux pas?

    Hiring - a Cloning Faux pas?

    Our repeated hiring patterns are just like the definition of insanity? Doing the same thing over and over again but…

    2 条评论
  • Everybody can/not write!

    Everybody can/not write!

    Do you admire people's way of writing or their ability to connect to you or inspired by their writing discipline? There…

    9 条评论
  • What’s a good Severance Pay?

    What’s a good Severance Pay?

    Should we say don’t hire if you can’t afford to fire? When you are negotiating a new offer or joining a new employer…

    5 条评论
  • Passive Candidates! a Pipe Dream?

    Passive Candidates! a Pipe Dream?

    Is it worth your time to recruit people who are not looking for jobs, or such so-called passive candidates even exist?…

    3 条评论
  • Na Tired, Na Retired?

    Na Tired, Na Retired?

    When you retire, does your last held role define your self-esteem when you take up new roles? If you have superannuated…

    2 条评论
  • Time to Meet the New Interviewer & Jobseeker?

    Time to Meet the New Interviewer & Jobseeker?

    As lay-offs become common, will we find more honest job seekers and empathetic interviewers? Lay-offs have been like…

    29 条评论
  • Home Truths About Remote Working

    Home Truths About Remote Working

    Despite initial productivity gains, we could be overrating the benefits of ‘work from home’ “This April I am busy for a…

    26 条评论
  • The Bluff of "Quitting" Happily

    The Bluff of "Quitting" Happily

    Behind those laudatory send-off notes to CXOs there often lies a story of awkward endings, my column in today's Hindu…

    9 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了