Addressing the Long-Term Challenges of Transitioning to ASTM C595 Blended Cements - Part 2

by Jon S. Belkowitz, PhD, PE

The rapid shift from ASTM C150 Portland Cements to ASTM C595 Blended Cements, particularly Type 1L, was supposed to herald a new era of sustainability for the construction industry. However, this premature transition, often implemented without adequate evaluation of its implications, has introduced a range of long-term challenges that concrete producers and construction professionals must reckon with. While its environmental advantages are undeniable, Type 1L presents performance concerns that could undermine the quality and durability of concrete projects if not corrected.

In this continuation of our earlier discussion, we’ll explore the long-term impacts of adopting Type 1L cement, including early and later-age cracking, susceptibility to wear, and chemical vulnerabilities. More importantly, we’ll provide actionable solutions to correct these issues and ensure the successful integration of Type 1L into next-generation construction practices.

Unpacking the Core Issues

1. Early and Later-Age Cracking

One of the most immediate and persistent challenges of Type 1L cement is cracking:

• Early-Age Cracking: The high cement surface area and increased fines content of blended cements monopolize water within the mix, reducing bleed water that typically forms a protective layer against evaporation. This leads to premature plastic shrinkage and cracking, exacerbated by factors like wind, low humidity, and direct sunlight.
• Later-Age Cracking: Over time, drying shrinkage becomes evident as the water-starved mix undergoes further volume changes. This results in tensile stresses that cause cracks to form and propagate in hardened concrete.

2. Susceptibility to Wear

Cracking not only jeopardizes structural integrity but also leaves the concrete more vulnerable to external forces:

• Dynamic Loading: Structures subjected to repeated traffic or load cycles can see cracks widen due to reduced structural robustness.
• Abrasive Forces: Cracks introduce pathways for abrasive particulates, accelerating surface erosion and degradation.
• Deicing Salt & Brine Attack: Cracking provides entry points for deicing agents that lead to the formation of calcium oxychloride compounds, severely weakening the concrete by chemical reaction.
• Early Onset Alkali-Silica Reaction (ASR) & Corrosion: Cracks create conduits for moisture and aggressive ions to reach embedded steel, triggering premature corrosion and alkali-silica reaction, both of which significantly shorten the lifespan of concrete structures.

These performance flaws not only result in higher rates of failure but also compromise the sustainability intentions behind the use of blended cements like Type 1L.

Steps to Correct Long-Term Issues with Type 1L Cement

To address these challenges, it’s essential to return to fundamentals while adapting to the unique characteristics of Type 1L cement. Here are the corrective measures you can implement:

1. Prioritize a Robust Curing System

A proactive curing approach is non-negotiable when working with Type 1L cement. The increased fines content in this cement increases water demand. Without adequate water supply during the curing process, proper hydration and microstructural development cannot occur, leaving the concrete weak and vulnerable.

• Actionable Steps: Use curing methods such as water curing, wet burlap, or curing compounds consistently, even when environmental conditions don't seem challenging. Keep in mind that Type 1L makes water retention an even greater priority.

2. Stop Starving the Mix of Water

Many practitioners rely heavily on chemical admixtures to adjust workability and performance, often at the expense of water content. With Type 1L, this can be detrimental, as the blend already contains additives that influence the water demand.

• Actionable Steps: Revisit your mix design and add back water to ensure sufficient hydration. Focus on maintaining the water-cement ratio within an optimal range that balances workability with strength development. Remember, Type 1L is a "blended cement," with hidden components that may already act as water reducers. Don’t deprive your mix of the water it needs to hydrate fully.

3. Collaborate, Experiment, and Execute Trials

Good concrete practices demand that every new material undergo rigorous evaluation before being deployed in large-scale projects. The same principle applies to Type 1L cement.

• Laboratory Testing: Simulate and monitor compressive strength, workability, shrinkage, and cracking tendencies under varied conditions.
• Field Trials: Build trial walls, slabs, or blocks in controlled environments to study the material's real-world performance comprehensively. Test different mix designs and exposure scenarios to understand and mitigate issues before committing on-site.
• Collaborate with Universities: Establish partnerships with academic institutions with expertise in cement materials, ensuring your testing processes are informed by research and complemented by leading-edge analytical methods.

4. Monitor Wear and Chemical Resistance

Recognize that the structural vulnerabilities caused by cracking make Type 1L blended cements more prone to wear and chemical degradation.

• Actionable Steps: Incorporate durability-enhancing measures in your mix designs, such as silica fume or pozzolanic materials, which can improve reactivity and mitigate cracking risks. Additionally, implement routine inspections of the placed concrete to identify early signs of wear and apply corrective measures where needed.

5. Educate Your Team and Stakeholders

Strong team communication and knowledge sharing are critical for addressing the unique challenges of Type 1L cement. Ensure team members fully understand the material's characteristics and its potential pitfalls. This knowledge ensures your team will look for and implement the solutions outlined here.

Achieving Sustainable Success with Type 1L Cement

Transitioning to ASTM C595 blended cements like Type 1L doesn’t have to mean sacrificing quality for sustainability. With a methodical approach and a commitment to fundamental concrete practices, construction professionals and concrete producers can overcome the material’s challenges and harness its benefits.

Remember, the goal of sustainability is rendered incomplete if early cracking, wear, and chemical vulnerabilities lead to premature structural failure. Take the time to cure meticulously, adjust mix designs prudently, and trial new materials vigorously. Not only will this help to meet industry standards but will ultimately restore confidence in this environmentally promising but challenging cement.

By choosing to refine your processes, you’ll not only ensure long-lasting concrete structures but also contribute to the broader goal of building a sustainable future for the construction industry.

For further insights or to learn how we can support your projects with Type 1L cement, contact us at Intelligent Concrete—it’s not just our field of expertise; it’s our passion.

www.Intelligent-Concrete.com

#ConcreteMixDesign #RawMaterials #ConstructionInnovation #ConcreteQuality #EngineeringExcellence #ConcreteDesign #BuildingMaterials #StructuralEngineering #ConcreteInnovation #JonBelkowitz #intelligentconcrete #build #builder #contractor #Engineer #designer #archtiect #concreteperformance #specificer #specification #beton

Learn more from Intelligent Concrete LLC:

+ Whitney Belkowitz, President and CEO: https://bit.ly/3uAWBKR

+ Jon Belkowitz, Chief Technical Officer: https://bit.ly/3eV79yJ

Check Out Our Podcast - https://apple.co/2x79fFg