Achieving the Ocean Commons

Achieving the Ocean Commons

Principles to sustain the value of the ocean now and for the?future

How do we govern and manage the ocean inside and outside of national jurisdiction in order to use it responsibly and assure its long-term potential? How do we collectively affirm the transformational change required to meet the conditions and challenges we face worldwide?

The world is connected, not divided, by the sea — through the circulation of protein, goods, people, and ideas. The ocean contains an enormous, unexplored inventory of medicinal cures, unlimited energy, and the desalinated drinking water that each of us needs in exactly the same amount each day, developed or developing, rich or poor, north or south, to survive. Climate change, extreme weather, and sea level rise can threaten anytime, anywhere, in a tumultuous instant making environmental refugees of us all. These are essential things, and we are living with them now.

Most of us are familiar from our colonial history lessons with the idea the commons, that central portion of land around which a settlement was built that was shared by all for pasturage of animals, agriculture, and general well-being. We may also be aware of the influential essay, “Tragedy of the Commons,” by ecologist Garrett Hardin, first published in Science in 1968, which describes a dilemma arising from a situation in which multiple individuals, acting independently and rationally consulting their own self-interest, will ultimately deplete a shared limited resource, even when it is clear that it is not in anyone’s long-term interest for this to happen.

Turning to the ocean, we realize that it is the greatest commons of them all. International law delimits national interest in ocean resources to an “exclusive economic zone” up to 200 miles offshore. The balance — that is, 64% of the ocean surface and 90% of its volume — lies outside such governance and includes the high seas, the ocean floor and subsoil, an enormous compendium of natural resources to include all marine species, minerals, chemicals, and genetic resources of incalculable value to human kind. This essential asset value must not be lost.

It is a vast challenge to protect, manage, and sustain such a resource, especially when agreement involves multiple levels of governance and a broad spectrum of public and private enterprise. The tragedy of the ocean commons is evinced by the intrusion of polluting elements from the nations and their self-interests that invade and destroy the shared value without constraint, without question.

In an article in the 2021 Proceedings of the US National Academy of Science, Joachim Claudet and colleagues argue for equity as the guiding principle for transformational change from our current model of governance. To begin, specifically in the ocean sector, they suggest three initiatives to unite scientific exploration of the ocean, deep sea research, and interdisciplinary, international collaboration: first, to construct or repurpose vessels as “a research fleet for the world,” ships and other data collection devices, positioned globally as platforms for research by scientists anywhere; second, to establish an International Deep Sea Station, comparable to the International Space Station, to help humankind understand and promote the ocean as an integrated, global, natural and social system available for our mutual benefit, and, third, to establish a Global Institute for the Ocean to engage the international community in the co-production of knowledge, the discovery, cataloguing and stewardship of ocean biodiversity, and the distribution of educational services worldwide through public access and engagement.

Finally, the authors suggest a specific governance structure for the vast areas that exist outside areas of national jurisdiction, that 64% of the total ocean surface, a radical shift from the present efforts to address and regulate activity there by sector, by treaty, and by regulation, an approach that is complicated, difficult, and not particularly successful to date, witness the conflict of national interests as seen in the climate negotiations and qualified outcome at COP26. Two alternatives are proposed: first, a public high level panel for the sustainable ocean, similar what has been established for a sustainable ocean economy, whereby 14 heads of state have created a unified partnership toward a common goal, executed independently from the confusion of interests and perspectives about the economic development and valuation of the ocean; and, second, a private partnership of international financial executives who would lead by example, incorporating the most effective, equitable practices into their business and recruiting others to accept equity and the principles of the commons, seriously and substantially, into their values, structures, and behaviors.

How do we govern, how do we manage the ocean inside and outside national jurisdiction, to use it responsibly, to sustain its value near and long-term, and to assure its potential forever for the benefit of all mankind? How do we affirm, not deny, the transformational change required to meet the conditions and challenges we now face worldwide? These suggestions are first steps in a different direction. The ocean is free of the geo-political boundaries that separate us and are the perimeters of our conflict. Can we manage it better, not apart? Can we realize the commonality of human experience through it, in it, for it, and for us all? The opportunity is there for a new uncommon common purpose.

No alt text provided for this image

PETER NEILL is founder and director of the World Ocean Observatory, a web-based place of exchange for information and educational services about the health of the world ocean. He is also host of World Ocean Radio, upon which this blog is inspired. World Ocean Radio celebrates 12 years this year, with more than 600 episodes produced to date.


Don Kent, Ph.D.

Well-being and prosperity for all through evidence-based conservation, leadership, and communication.

3 年

Thanks, Peter. Elinor Ostrom identified the following. Favorable common pool resource attributes include: ·??????Resources are used enough to warrant organizing. ·??????Resource condition, if deteriorated, can feasibly be improved. ·??????Reliable and valid indicators of resource condition are available at a relatively low cost. ·??????The flow of resource units (e.g., fish, trees, water) is relatively predictable. ·??????The resource area is small enough that users can develop accurate knowledge of internal microenvironments and external boundaries. ? Favorable common pool resource user attributes include: ·??????Users are dependent on the resources for a significant part of their livelihood. ·??????Users have a shared understanding of how the resource operates, and how their actions affect each other and the resource. ·??????Users can predict the future value of the resource with relative certainty. ·??????Users trust?each other and practice reciprocity. ·??????Users can establish access and harvesting rules without external authorities countermanding them. Users possess at least minimal organization and leadership?skills. Not so easy on a global basis, especially when trust is required.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Peter Neill的更多文章

  • World Water Day is March?22nd

    World Water Day is March?22nd

    From mountaintop to abyssal plain, water is the great circulatory system that connects all things. March 22 is World…

    2 条评论
  • Ocean Literacy: A Call to Action

    Ocean Literacy: A Call to Action

    In Venice, Italy, in 2024, a conference gathered to address today’s issues, and to produce the Venice Declaration for…

    4 条评论
  • At the Fishhouses: A Poem for a New Year

    At the Fishhouses: A Poem for a New Year

    I always had a daydream of being a lighthouse keeper, absolutely alone. .

    6 条评论
  • Educators are the Key

    Educators are the Key

    World Ocean Explorer at the National Marine Educators Conference: Sharing A Free Web-Based Immersion for the Classroom…

    4 条评论
  • An Ocean Literacy Declaration

    An Ocean Literacy Declaration

    The first Ocean Literacy World Conference was held in Venice, Italy 7–8 June 2024. The participants endorsed the Venice…

    4 条评论
  • Advocacy, Education & Communication Since 2003

    Advocacy, Education & Communication Since 2003

    World Ocean Observatory has been delivering dynamic educational resources for learning about climate and ocean through…

    1 条评论
  • January News from the W2O

    January News from the W2O

    ENTERING A THIRD DECADE As we enter a 21st year of advocating for the ocean, we are proud to boast a broader audience…

  • ADVANCING PUBLIC AWARENESS THROUGH EDUCATION, ADVOCACY, AND COMMUNICATION SINCE 2003

    ADVANCING PUBLIC AWARENESS THROUGH EDUCATION, ADVOCACY, AND COMMUNICATION SINCE 2003

    2023 has marked our twentieth year! As we turn toward a third decade, World Ocean Observatory remains energetic…

  • Insurance in a New Climate Era

    Insurance in a New Climate Era

    We are already seeing the key role played by insurance as we face the destructive consequence of extreme weather:…

  • RESCUE, part 33: A Personal Call to?Action

    RESCUE, part 33: A Personal Call to?Action

    A year ago, I began to prepare a plan for ocean conservation in the context of failure by the international community…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了