The 80/20 Rule of Hiring: Forget the Resume, Can We Handle 40 Hours of You?
Leigh McKiernon
StratEx - Indonesia Headhunter | C-Level Recruitment | ex Korn Ferry
The job interview—that experience where you, the candidate, are thrust into the coliseum to face off against a job description that reads like it was written by an overenthusiastic intern with access to a thesaurus. The requirements? A PhD in Quantum Physics, 15 years of experience in a coding language that didn’t exist until last year, and the ability to lead a team of ninjas. But let's be real: companies don’t actually expect you to tick all those boxes. No, no, they’re only aiming for 80%.
And what about that final 20%? That’s where the real magic happens. By “magic,†I mean the kind of scrutiny that makes you question whether your existence is palatable enough to spend five days a week with these people. Forget technical skills; now you need to prove you’re the human equivalent of an office plant—easy to deal with, pleasant to look at, and, most importantly, not a threat to anyone’s fragile sense of workplace harmony. It’s not just about what you know—it’s about who you can pretend to be. Welcome to the nightmare that is modern hiring.
Job Requirements: A Wish List Written by Optimists on Steroids
Job descriptions are less a blueprint for the ideal employee and more like aspirational poetry. They’re a creative exercise where HR and the department head dream up a fantasy employee who probably doesn’t exist outside a Pixar movie. These wish lists are typically packed with buzzwords like "synergy" and "agile," as if using the word synergy somehow gives the company synergy. Throw in a few tech terms, and voilà , you have a job description that makes applicants wonder if they’re auditioning for a superhero role.
When companies post their job requirements, what they’re really saying is, “Look, we know what we want doesn’t exist, but it’s fun to dream.†Do they actually expect you to have mastery of 15 programming languages? No. Can you get away with knowing how to open a Google tab and type “best Python shortcuts� Absolutely. The truth is, they’re not looking for a polymath with the problem-solving abilities of Einstein and the coding skills of a Silicon Valley wunderkind—they just need someone who can navigate an Excel spreadsheet without requiring a week of intense training.
So, stop sweating over every bullet point in the job ad that reads like a dare. When they ask for someone who can “optimize cross-platform integration†and “lead a multidisciplinary team,†just know that most people in the company aren’t entirely sure what that means either. If you’re close enough—and by "close," we mean you can Google at least half of it—go ahead and hit that ‘Apply’ button.
The unspoken reality? They’re just hoping you’re competent enough to not make a disaster of things and chill enough to keep your cool when the office Wi-Fi crashes... again.
The 20% That Really Matters: Are You Fun, or at Least Tolerable?
The 20%—the part of the interview where, after you’ve convinced them you’re not a complete fraud, they ask themselves, “But could I stand sitting next to this person for 40 hours a week?†You thought the technical skills were the hard part? Think again. Now comes the real test: Are you likable? Or, more importantly, are you tolerable?
Companies aren’t just hiring someone to balance the books or code the next great app. No, they’re also hiring someone they don’t mind sharing awkward elevator rides with. You’re no longer just "applicant #257." You’re auditioning for the role of “Person We Won’t Roll Our Eyes At During Staff Meetings.â€
In today’s job market, more people get hired for their ability to be mildly entertaining during small talk than for their skill in using advanced Excel formulas. Can you crack a joke without sounding like a robot attempting humor for the first time? Can you respond to “How was your weekend?†with something better than “It was fine†without veering into TMI territory? If so, you’re ahead of the game.
Believe it or not, your ability to casually mention a Netflix series or bring in leftover cookies from a family event will likely weigh more than that five-day course you took on process optimization. No one’s explicitly telling you this, but trust me—being the person who lightens the mood with a well-timed joke or doughnut offering? That’s what’s going to make you stand out. Because in the end, companies want someone who won’t just get the job done but who also won’t cause the office’s collective soul to wither slowly over the course of a workweek.
领英推è
Technical Match? Pfft. Let’s Talk About “Culture Fitâ€
While technical skills can be learned, curing someone of an awkward or downright unpleasant personality? That’s a job for therapists, not HR. This is precisely why the phrase “culture fit†has become the corporate world’s version of a dating app profile. It’s not about how well you can code or balance spreadsheets—it’s about whether you can blend in with the rest of the office zoo.
And let’s not kid ourselves: “culture†here has nothing to do with how much you know about world affairs or whether you can say “thank you†in four languages. No, culture fit is much simpler. It boils down to one thing: Can you convincingly pretend to laugh at the boss’s terrible jokes? Will you join in on those awkward office icebreakers without rolling your eyes so hard they detach?
This is why interviewers will inexplicably spend more time asking about your hobbies than your actual qualifications. “Oh, you knit in your free time? Great! We have a craft circle!†Translation: “Please, for the love of God, be someone we can talk to when the Wi-Fi is down and we’re forced to make conversation.â€
Forget about the technical grilling sessions where you’re asked to solve complex algorithms. What really matters is whether you can navigate Casual Friday without committing an unspeakable fashion crime. Do you bring a "people person" vibe to the room? Can you be trusted not to drone on about profit margins at Happy Hour?
In the end, “culture fit†is just a fancy way of saying: Please don’t be a buzzkill. Because no matter how skilled you are, nobody wants to spend their workday trapped in a meeting with someone who makes time move backward.
Pretending to Care About the Job: A Necessary Evil
Let’s not sugarcoat it: No one’s childhood dream was to grow up and work at a logistics optimization startup or become employee #43 at a fintech firm named after an obscure Greek god. You didn’t spend your formative years thinking, “One day, I’ll optimize supply chains with AI!†No, you’re here because rent is due, and your student loans are a ticking time bomb.
But here’s the catch: despite the obvious fact that you’d rather be doing literally anything else, you’ve got to pretend to care. And not just about the paycheck—you’ve got to act like you care about their mission. That vague, buzzword-filled corporate mantra about “revolutionizing the industry†and “disrupting the local grocery store chain market†is now your new passion. You’ve got to sell it like you’re auditioning for a leading role in the next corporate training video.
Sure, deep down you know that their vision is really just a thinly veiled attempt to squeeze a few more dollars out of a saturated market, but hey, it’s showtime. Can you, with a straight face, nod enthusiastically when they talk about leveraging data-driven solutions to “transform customer experiences� Of course you can. And if you squint hard enough, maybe you’ll even convince yourself that you care—at least until 5:00 p.m.
The trick here is to strike the perfect balance between fake enthusiasm and believable engagement. You don’t need to be the office’s number one cheerleader, but you do need to convince your employers that you’re at least moderately interested in whatever shiny corporate goal they’ve slapped on the break room wall in Helvetica Bold. Nail this act, and you might even be able to ride that fa?ade all the way to your first performance review.
In the job interview, both sides are pretending harder than a middle school play. You, the candidate, are trying to convince them you’re their dream hire, even though you’re still Googling half the jargon from the job description. Meanwhile, the company is holding onto the fantasy that the perfect employee exists.
But let’s be real: they don’t need a unicorn, just someone who won’t set off a fire alarm by trying to toast a bagel in the office microwave. So, the next time you’re asked, “Do you have experience managing global cross-functional teams?†don’t break into a sweat. The truth is, the bar isn’t nearly as high as they make it seem. Be competent, likable, and—above all—someone who won’t turn the break room into a war zone over fridge etiquette.
Remember, job interviews aren’t about perfection. They’re about being 80% capable and 20% not-a-weirdo. And when in doubt, just compliment the interviewer’s shoes. It’s amazing how far a well-timed compliment can get you in the hiring process.
Founder of TraceWorthy Consulting, TraceWorks by TraceWorthy and Trace Elements
6 个月Brilliantly written and ever so true, thank you! We have made the mistake of hiring "talent" who do not pass our "no ***hole" test, and then paying the price. They tend to come in, stomp around on our culture, which we've worked hard to establish so that our teams are not dreading Mondays on Sundays, and then exit, leaving behind a trail of destruction. We see a pattern of recruiting in a hurry because we don't have enough staff overlap to sustain a hole in our team for long. Scarcity messes with us and we make a stupid decision. We are learning - often the hard way.
Aerospace & Defence | Sustainability | Seeing Beyond the Obvious |Scientific|Transitioning with Evidence & Social Responsible capital|Transformations that challenge norms
6 个月Productivity is a very different measure. Results and outcomes are paramount to both sides of the table. The minute JDs transform into SOWs , the game is different.The right picks and resulting outcomes are a natural consequence and not one to chase after on spreaddheets by operations. This is a lesson not simply from echelons of corporate governance but from some excellent trades people on assembly and maintenance lines.
Head of Legal and Compliance @ Global Excel | Compliance and Contracts Expert
6 个月I remember I went through 6 interviews once, HR Initial Interview, User Interview and I also Interview the User, HR Follow up Interview, Another User Interview (different User apparently), Decision Maker Interview and Technical Interview. I would say its not Ideal but it was comprehensive enough to have me wanting to Accept their offer eventually. ??
Martech | Branding & Innovation | Marketing | Strategy | Growth Marketing | Product Marketing | Data Science & Analytics | Sustainability | ESG.
6 个月The fantasy vs reality. A witty piece. It totally cracked me up ?????? Thank you for sharing this article whilst I start the week job hunting and applying for jobs in the region. Let’s see if I get any auditions soon.
Former Senior Deputy Director, Bank Indonesia | Columbia MBA | Economic Policy & Investment Strategy Advisor | Data-Driven Policy & Regulatory Expert | 28+ Years Central Banking Experience
6 个月Thank you for sharing this entertaining yet insightful article on the hiring process. It's a timely read as I prepare for my upcoming interview. I appreciate the reminder that while technical skills are important, being a good cultural fit and easy to work with are equally valuable. And while I won't be fixating on anyone's shoes, I'll certainly try to strike that balance of being 80% capable and 20% not-a-weirdo. Here's hoping I can navigate the interview process as smoothly as I can operate an office microwave!