5G – What’s The Difference Between Option 3, 3A And 3X?

As if there weren’t already enough deployment options for the upcoming 5G network standard, it turns out that for 5G Non-Standalone Option 3, there are actually 3 different variants: 3, 3A and 3X. So what exactly is the difference between them?

The GTI Whitepaper on 5G has a good description and graphics on page 14 so I’ll just summarize the affair here:

As I’ve described in previous posts, 5G Option 3 is the Non-Standalone architecture that still uses the 4G core network (the EPC). In addition, all different flavors of option 3 use the LTE base station as the signaling anchor, i.e. user connection management and radio link control for the combined 4G/5G base station is always managed by the LTE part. This is the same for all options!

At the edge of the EPC, the MME/S-GW are connected over the IP based S1 interface to the combined 4G/5G base station, i.e. the eNB (4G) and the gNB (5G). As the eNB and gNB are logically different components, there is a standardized IP interface between them, the X2 interface. If the eNB and gNB are combined into a single hardware node, the X2 interface is internal, logical, virtual, or whatever you want to call it. So in other words there is the triangle of MME/S-GW at the border of the core network connected to both the eNB and gNB of a combined 4G/5G base station site (over a single physical fiber backhaul connection) and a logical or physical IP interface between the 4G and 5G part of the base station. In other words, there are different options of how data can flow between the core network and the base station and between the two base station parts:

Option 3: In the plain option 3, all data to and from the network flows to and from the 4G part of the 4G/5G base station, i.e. to and from the eNB. The eNB

can then decide to forward part of the data to the 5G gNB part of the base station over the X2 interface. This means that the 5G gNB does not communicate with the 4G core network directly!

Option 3A: In this option, both the 4G gNB and the 5G gNB directly talk to the 4G core network but they do not directly talk with each other over the X2 interface. This means that there can be no load sharing of data over a single bearer over 4G and 5G. That means, for example, that the 4G part only handles the VoLTE voice traffic for a user while his Internet traffic is only handled by the 5G part of the base station. I’d say that in most deployment scenarios, this is not really an option if mobile devices move in and out of 5G network coverage continuously.

Option 3X: In this configuration, user data traffic directly flows to the 5G gNB part of the base station. From there, it is delivered over the air interface to the mobile device. It is also possible to forward a part of the data over the X2 interface to the 4G gNB part of the base station and from there to the UE. Slow data streams, e.g. VoLTE bearers with a different IP address than that used for Internet access can be directly delivered from the core network to the 4G gNB part of the 4G/5G base station. The advantage mentioned in the paper linked to above is that the 5G upgrade of the base station is likely to have the much better performing IP interface so it is better suited to handle the higher data rates that can be reached with a 4G/5G Non-Standalone network deployment.

So many options to choose from. That makes me wonder if 5G will become ‘the standard of many options’?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Abhijeet Kumar的更多文章

  • 5G NR PDCCH

    5G NR PDCCH

    What is PDCCH? The Physical Downlink Control Channel (PDCCH) is a critical physical channel in 5G NR (and earlier…

    4 条评论
  • Bandwidth Part 5G NR

    Bandwidth Part 5G NR

    What is a Bandwidth Part (BWP)? A Bandwidth Part is a subset of contiguous physical resource blocks (PRBs) within a…

    10 条评论
  • 5G NR HARQ Vs ARQ Process

    5G NR HARQ Vs ARQ Process

    1. Introduction to Error Control in 5G NR 5G NR employs a layered error-control strategy to balance speed, reliability,…

    14 条评论
  • 5G NR Physical Layer CRC and Code Block

    5G NR Physical Layer CRC and Code Block

    Cyclic Redundancy Check (CRC) and code block segmentation are fundamental 5G New Radio (NR) processes that ensure…

    1 条评论
  • DRX in 5G

    DRX in 5G

    Discontinuous Reception (DRX) in 5G is a critical power-saving mechanism designed to conserve battery life for User…

    2 条评论
  • 5G NR Registration and Authentication Process

    5G NR Registration and Authentication Process

    Let's study the 5G NR Registration Process in detail. 5G NR Registration and Authentication Procedure Let's start with…

    4 条评论
  • SRS in 5G by Abhijeet kumar

    SRS in 5G by Abhijeet kumar

    Did you know that the efficiency of 5G networks hinges significantly on the optimization of Sounding Reference Signals…

  • Non-RT RIC (O-RAN)

    Non-RT RIC (O-RAN)

    Open RAN (Open Radio Access Network) is a telecommunications initiative that promotes the development of an open and…

    1 条评论
  • SDAP Protocols

    SDAP Protocols

    Overview of SDAP SDAP is a protocol layer introduced in 5G networks that resides at the top most layer of the Radio…

    1 条评论
  • The transition from 5G to 6G

    The transition from 5G to 6G

    Dear valued reader, We are currently in the process of developing an article about 6G technology. While the…

    1 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了