5 Common Mistakes First-Time Managers Make and How to Avoid Them

Nearly 50% of newly promoted managers underperform in their roles for up to 18 months, according to Forbes. The combination of high exposure, the risk of failure, and the pressure of new responsibilities makes first-time managers particularly vulnerable.

To avoid these pitfalls and set yourself up for success, consider these five common mistakes first-time managers often make and strategies to avoid them.

Mistake #1: Not Realizing You’re on Stage

As a new manager, you may not fully grasp how much your team members are watching your words and actions. Everything you do is now under scrutiny, and your behavior sets the tone for your team.

How to Avoid It

• Gain Self-Awareness: Understand that your role has changed, and with it, the way others perceive you. Reflect on how your actions and words influence your team.
• Communicate Mindfully: In meetings and one-on-one interactions, be deliberate about how you communicate. Use clear, positive language and body language that conveys confidence and approachability.
• Model Desired Behaviors: Demonstrate the behaviors you expect from your team, such as punctuality, respect, and diligence.

Mistake #2: Choosing Pride Over Humility

Pretending to know everything can prevent you from learning and growing in your new role. It can also alienate your team and lead to poor decision-making.

How to Avoid It

• Ask Thoughtful Questions: Embrace a learning mindset. Don’t be afraid to ask questions to fill knowledge gaps and gather necessary information.
• Admit When You Don’t Know: Demonstrating humility by admitting when you don’t know something builds trust and encourages a culture of continuous learning.
• Seek Input from Others: Involve your team in problem-solving and decision-making. This not only improves outcomes but also fosters a collaborative environment.

Mistake #3: Neglecting to Consider All Your Stakeholders

Focusing only on your direct reports and immediate tasks can lead to overlooking other important stakeholders who influence your success.

How to Avoid It

• Identify Key Stakeholders: Map out all stakeholders who have formal or informal power over the areas tied to your goals. This includes decision-makers in other departments and their allies.
• Build Relationships: Cultivate relationships with these stakeholders to understand their perspectives and interests. This can help you navigate the organizational landscape more effectively.
• Communicate Regularly: Keep stakeholders informed about your projects and seek their feedback. This ensures alignment and support for your initiatives.

Mistake #4: Sticking to What You Already Know

Relying solely on your existing skills and knowledge can hinder your growth and the development of your team. Your role now requires a broader skill set, including delegation and feedback.

How to Avoid It

• Learn to Delegate: Recognize that your job is to develop others. Delegate tasks appropriately to empower your team and free up your time for higher-level responsibilities.
• Provide Constructive Feedback: Regularly give feedback to help your team members grow. Use specific, actionable, and balanced feedback to guide their development.
• Embrace Continuous Learning: Stay open to new ideas and methods. Invest in your own development through training, reading, and seeking mentorship.

Mistake #5: Failing to Ask for Feedback

Not seeking feedback can lead to misalignment with expectations and hinder your ability to improve. Understanding how others perceive your actions and decisions is crucial for your success.

How to Avoid It

• Solicit Regular Feedback: Actively seek feedback from your team, peers, and superiors. This helps you gauge how well you are meeting expectations and identify areas for improvement.
• Create a Feedback Culture: Encourage open communication and make it safe for others to provide honest feedback. This fosters trust and continuous improvement.
• Act on Feedback: Use the feedback you receive to make adjustments in your approach. Show that you value input by implementing changes based on the feedback.

Transitioning to a managerial role comes with its challenges, but by being aware of these common mistakes and implementing strategies to avoid them, you can set yourself up for success. Realize the significance of your new role, embrace humility, consider all stakeholders, expand your skill set, and actively seek feedback. By doing so, you’ll not only enhance your own performance but also build a stronger, more cohesive, and more effective team.

For more insights and practical advice on leadership development, subscribe to my LinkedIn newsletter, New Manager Playbook. It's where I share tips and experiences to help new managers become effective leaders. Also, check out my LinkedIn posts on leadership and strategic planning for new managers. Let's connect and grow together.