404 Not Found! For Developers Which Is Better: Fixing or Relaxing?

As a Web Developer, ensuring a smooth and user-friendly experience is paramount. One common stumbling block that both developers and users encounter is the dreaded 404 error. When a page is not found, it can be frustrating for users and detrimental to your website's SEO.?

Recently, John Mueller, Senior Search Analyst /Search Relations team lead,?from Google addressed a query on Reddit that shed light on how to deal with thousands of 404 errors reported in Google Search Console. It turns out, the conventional wisdom of rushing to fix every 404 error may not always be the best approach. Let's dive into the details and gain a better understanding of when it's appropriate to let a 404 error occur.?

Understanding the Nature of 404 Errors?

A 404 error, also known as "Not Found," is an HTTP status code that surfaces when a user attempts to access a web page that does not exist on the server. This can occur for a variety of reasons, such as a mistyped URL, the removal of a page, or a broken link.?

Common reasons for 404 errors include:

• ?Internal Links to Non-Existent Pages: If your website contains links leading to pages that no longer exist, this will generate 404 errors.
• Search Engine Indexing Issues: Outdated or incorrect URLs in search engine indexes can lead users to encounter 404 errors when clicking on these outdated links.
• Spam Sites Linking to Non-Existent Pages: External spam sites may link to pages on your website that simply don't exist.
• Maintenance or Downtime: Websites may undergo maintenance or experience temporary downtime, causing users to see 404 errors when trying to access certain pages.
• Server Configuration Errors: Misconfigured server settings or a lack of appropriate directives can also result in 404 errors.

?Why Should Developers Care About 404 Errors??

Initially, 404 errors may appear as minor inconveniences. However, these errors carry significant consequences for both your website and its users:?

• Disrupted User Experience: Users find it incredibly frustrating to click on a promising link only to land on a 404 error page. It disrupts their flow and may drive them away from your site in search of a more seamless experience.
• SEO Implications: Search engines, including Google, closely monitor 404 errors. The presence of frequent 404 errors can negatively impact your site's search engine rankings, as it signals to search engines that your website may not be well-maintained.
• Missed Opportunities: Each 404 error isn't just an inconvenience; it represents a lost opportunity to engage your users with valuable content or drive conversions. When a user encounters a 404 error and subsequently leaves your site, you've forfeited a potential conversion or meaningful engagement.

?In essence, 404 errors are more than a minor annoyance – they can undermine user satisfaction, SEO efforts, and the overall success of your website.?

Dealing with Spam Sites and 404 Errors?

John Mueller's insights on 404 errors extend beyond their significance. The focus of the Reddit user's inquiry was 404 errors generated by spam sites linking to non-existent pages on their website. Mueller's response was straightforward, "If the page was not intended to exist in the first place, letting it return a 404 error is perfectly acceptable. In fact, it can serve as a useful reminder that you're effectively blocking the spammy attempts to create content on your website."

This insight is particularly valuable because it allows webmasters to prioritize addressing genuine issues rather than chasing down 404 errors stemming from spammy external links. It's a practical and efficient approach to maintaining your website's health and SEO performance.?

When Implementing Redirects, Proceed Cautiously?

Another critical consideration is the use of redirects. In some cases, webmasters may be tempted to create redirects to the homepage as a quick fix to avoid 404 errors. However, John Mueller advises against this practice, as it can potentially lead to "soft 404 errors." These soft 404 errors occur when a page returns a 200 status code (indicating success) instead of a 404 code, even though the page content essentially states that it doesn't exist.?

In summary, the key takeaway from John Mueller's insights is that a 404 error, in itself, is not necessarily an error that needs immediate fixing. If a page genuinely doesn't exist or wasn't intended to exist, it's entirely appropriate for it to return a 404 error. By doing so, you're effectively managing your website's content and preventing spam sites from impacting your SEO.?

This nuanced approach to handling 404 errors can save webmasters time and effort, allowing them to focus on addressing critical issues that genuinely affect their website's performance. It's a reminder that in the ever-evolving landscape of SEO, a deeper understanding of the intricacies can make a significant difference in your digital strategy.?

Stay Connected with Cogent?

We appreciate your subscription to our newsletter and hope to continue bringing you the most exciting updates from the tech world. Stay connected and informed with Cogent as we strive to keep you up-to-date with the latest trends and innovations in the industry.