28. Should You Judge Others or Not? —Personal Context is Key: Overcoming Indecisiveness

Series Overview

No wonder you sometimes feel hesitant and indecisive when receiving advice from AI, experts, social media, or loved ones, as these sources often provide conflicting guidance, which only adds to your confusion. This happens because no one understands your personal context better than you do. Without that context, external input can feel irrelevant. The key is to integrate outside advice with your own decision-making skills.

That’s why the "Personal Context is Key: Overcoming Indecisiveness" series has come to life. It presents two opposing viewpoints on a given topic, illustrating that while both perspectives have compelling arguments and solid foundations, the ultimate right choice for you depends only on your current situation and unique circumstances. Thus, understanding and applying your personal context is essential for making decisions that truly align with your capabilities, needs, and goals.

- Oh snap! You have an idea for this series that you'd like to share with the public? My platform is open for any contributions, whether it's just a topic suggestion or a complete article. All contributions will be credited!

Article #28: Should You Judge Others or Not?

Judging others is something we all do, whether consciously or unconsciously. It’s a natural part of human behavior, helping us assess people and situations to navigate social interactions. However, judgment also carries significant ethical, psychological, and social implications. Some argue that judging others can be harmful, creating negativity and reinforcing biases, while others believe that judgment, when used constructively, is essential for decision-making and moral development.

Viewpoint 1: Do NOT Judge Others

Many experts highlight the dangers of judgment, emphasizing how it can negatively impact our well-being and relationships. Here’s why refraining from judgment can be beneficial:

1. Judging Others Can Harm Our Mental Health

According to Cope Psychology, constantly evaluating and criticizing others fosters a negative mindset. This negativity doesn’t just affect how we perceive people but also contributes to increased stress, anxiety, and dissatisfaction in our own lives. When we judge others harshly, we tend to judge ourselves in the same way, creating a cycle of self-criticism and mental strain.

2. Judgment Reinforces Biases and Prevents Growth

The article from Mind Voyage explains that judgment is often based on preconceived notions and unconscious biases rather than objective reality. By jumping to conclusions about people based on limited information, we close ourselves off from understanding their true character and circumstances. This prevents personal growth, limits our ability to connect with others, and can reinforce societal prejudices.

3. It Damages Relationships and Reduces Empathy

The Fisher College of Business highlights that when we judge others too quickly, we erode trust and connection. People who feel judged may become defensive, leading to weaker personal and professional relationships. By avoiding judgment, we cultivate empathy, open-mindedness, and deeper understanding of those around us.

Viewpoint 2: Judge Others

While many argue against judgment, others believe that it is necessary for personal safety, decision-making, and moral development. The key is to judge wisely and with good intent. Here’s why judgment can be beneficial:

1. Judgment Helps Us Make Better Decisions

According to Mike Robbins, judgment is a tool for discernment. We judge situations, behaviors, and people to assess risks and make informed choices. For example, evaluating someone’s reliability is essential when choosing friends, partners, or employees. When used thoughtfully, judgment helps us navigate life effectively.

2. It Reinforces Moral and Ethical Standards

The article from Samaritan Ministries argues that judgment plays a crucial role in upholding moral values. If we never judged harmful behaviors, society would lack accountability. Judgment allows us to distinguish right from wrong and maintain a sense of justice. Constructive judgment ensures that we encourage ethical behavior while discouraging harmful actions.

3. Observing and Evaluating Others Helps Us Improve Ourselves

Judging others isn’t always negative—it can serve as a mirror for self-reflection. As Robbins explains, when we recognize traits we dislike in others, it often points to areas we need to work on in ourselves. This type of judgment can be an opportunity for personal growth and self-awareness rather than mere criticism.

Finding the Balance:

Since judgment has both harmful and beneficial aspects, the key lies in using it mindfully and ethically. Here’s how we can strike a balance:

1. Be Aware of Your Intentions

Before judging someone, ask yourself: Am I doing this to understand or to criticize? Constructive judgment aims to evaluate situations for growth and learning, while negative judgment often stems from insecurity or prejudice.

2. Focus on Actions, Not Character

Judging people’s entire identity based on a single action is unfair. Instead, evaluate specific behaviors rather than labeling someone as “good” or “bad.” This approach allows for fairer assessments and healthier interactions.

3. Practice Empathy and Open-mindedness

Even when judgment is necessary, it should come with understanding and compassion. Recognizing that everyone has unique experiences and struggles can help us judge less harshly and more wisely.

Samar’s Two Cents:?

The debate over whether we should judge others isn’t about choosing one side or the other—it’s about understanding when judgment is helpful and when it is harmful. While excessive judgment can lead to negativity, thoughtful evaluation of our judgement is crucial as it helps us practice self-awareness, empathy, and open mindedness.

Wafa's Two Cents:

Negative emotions tied to judgment don’t necessarily indicate something wrong with the judgment itself. However, negative outcomes suggest that the judgment may be flawed, unfair, or lacking in perspective. Before making a judgment, reflect on your past experiences. If your judgments have led to negative outcomes, take time to refine your approach. If they’ve resulted in fair and constructive outcomes, you're likely on the right track.

As the proverb goes,

• "People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.", or
• "Better safe than sorry."

Samar Kamaleddine | HR Professional | Bachelor of Business Administration @University of Balamand

Wafa Damlaj, MHRM | HR Leader @Amazon | HR PhD Student @University of Texas at Tyler