#28 Narratives

#28 Narratives

Hi all,

Even when you dive deep into some topics, read books, travel, or do whatever, the way to connect to people is through narratives—stories you can relate to. I have had some ‘narrative times’ lately. In a few days, I went from the summer palace of the Pope in Rome with Bforgood, discussing with a bunch of people about leadership, crossroads and narratives, to a philosophy festival in Amsterdam (Brainwashfestival), where it was shown that narratives (in this case a performance by an author playing a politician) can make a difference.

Many forget that every human interaction is based on a narrative — a structured story or account that interprets and communicates human experiences, often with an underlying purpose or meaning. They offer frameworks that help individuals and communities interpret their lives, actions, and the world around them.

For instance, philosophers like Paul Ricoeur and Alasdair MacIntyre argue that narratives shape our moral and existential understanding. According to Ricoeur, narratives mediate between our lived experiences and the interpretations we form of them, helping us place events in a coherent framework of beginning, middle, and end. Meanwhile, MacIntyre posits that humans are "story-telling animals," asserting that narratives are essential to moral development as they give context to virtues, values, and choices throughout a lifetime.

I am not a philosopher. I am an economist. I have seen that many (macro) economists strongly believe in their theories as an objective kind of truth, no matter how often it is falsified. That is how we get to the idea that green growth is possible: not because there is a reality that shows its possibility, but because we have a narrative, an intrinsic conviction that it is possible. You can argue against it regarding rational arguments; that does not matter. Even if it is demonstrated that the current narrative does not deliver a good life for all people and living creatures in the future, the narrative (or paradigm) stays strong.

So, we need to change the narrative. However, this might be the most challenging task we have today. I want to highlight two examples of new narratives: Pope Frances’ Laudato Si’ and Kohei Saito’s ecological reinterpretation of Marx.

A new narrative—almost like a new religion, a firm conviction—that everyone will embrace is probably more important than innovation. We have all the solutions; we only need to believe those solutions and ideas are our new narrative instead of a sobering outlook for our future. But to get there, we probably first must understand that we always live in a narrative.

A warning: part of this blog is more philosophical than economic (only one graph!). However, it is critical to understand that narratives are ultimately what drive societies from one stage to another. If more people believe a different narrative, it will create a new reality. In other words, the stronger the latest narratives, the stronger the feedback loop in a system that moves a system towards a tipping point.


See for the rest on my substack.

Maria Dolores Sanchez Galera

Engaged with integral human development

4 个月

I really believe that our narratives define our existences and that every meeting impacts our narratives. They of course define paradigms, I would like to know how we could engage financial and political actors more with the concrete narrative of Laudato Si' that is already suggesting transformational action paths at everyone's reach? I am sure it could become viral, exactly like it has been studied by Shiller. What do you think? Where are the resistances coming from?

回复
Lars Grote

Filmmaker / I help purpose-driven organisations craft meaningful audiovisual stories that let them thrive and spark change.

4 个月

“We have all the solutions; we only need to believe those solutions and ideas are our new narrative instead of a sobering outlook for our future.” I agree Hans Stegeman. And I’d like to add that there are already lots of story’s out there, that if uncovered and told, would move people to become allies through narrative transportation and character identification. We see ourselves in the stories of others and what sticks is the universal message - like for example: “a bright future is possible.” Also interesting, a book called “The Story Paradox” by Jonathan Gottschall where the author describes how story’s can tear down societies, but also build them up.

回复
Victoria Ramsden

Ethics | Social Responsibility | Sustainability

4 个月

You articulate some key points about narratives.?As an Exec & Leadership Coach educated in environmental governance working with mission driven businesses, I know that?as individual human beings, we each have our own map & story of the world.?None is right or wrong although of course when it comes to organising resources for survival, we come together in groups with those who look like us and seem to share similar maps and beliefs as our own.?Sadly as humans, we tend to see those not like us as “wrong” driven by our unconscious limiting beliefs, grounded in fear. ? Using coaching techniques, it is possible to identify those limiting beliefs which underpin current unsustainable and inequitable narratives WITHOUT JUDGEMENT and begin to cultivate more compassionate and empowering beliefs and narratives.? Through those same coaching techniques, it is also possible to see that those who are at face value “different” to us, share many of the same values.? You always write such thoughtful and compelling pieces. Your insights through your financial and economic lens and position are very important.?I can’t wait for your next piece.

回复
Adriaan Strijers

Bedrijfsjournalistiek

4 个月

Zeer nuttig

回复
Angela Liu

ANZ ????澳新银行 ????Privat Banquer????

4 个月

Much gratitude for sharing your view Hans Stegeman up for debate is science a belief system or a religion? ??

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Hans Stegeman的更多文章

  • #35 Collapsology

    #35 Collapsology

    It’s unbearable—at least for me. In a world that should be focused on securing the future of humanity (and countless…

    57 条评论
  • #34 Tipping points and radical change

    #34 Tipping points and radical change

    Hi all, Since I lowered the frequency of this newsletter, I have always worried that I will miss out on telling someone…

    5 条评论
  • Searching for tipping points

    Searching for tipping points

    Hi all, We live in brutal times. Times where we have reached (already!) 1.

    12 条评论
  • #33 A Look at Outlooks

    #33 A Look at Outlooks

    Hi all, Sometimes, your own body surprises you much like an economy does. Take my recent bike accident, for instance—I…

    3 条评论
  • The Rising Democratic Deficit of Capitalism

    The Rising Democratic Deficit of Capitalism

    Hi all, I published an essay in Vrij Nederland (in Dutch) last month, just before Christmas. This version has…

    11 条评论
  • #32 The European dream differs from the American dream

    #32 The European dream differs from the American dream

    It's almost Christmas break. And I finally had the chance to look into the Draghi Report on the competitiveness of the…

    37 条评论
  • #31 Tipping Points Investing

    #31 Tipping Points Investing

    Hi all, The idea of tipping points is gaining more traction every day. For one, a tipping point is a way to express the…

    15 条评论
  • #30 Something has to change in the governance of the commons

    #30 Something has to change in the governance of the commons

    Hi all, We’ve just witnessed two critical COPs: the Biodiversity COP16 and the Climate COP29. Yet, their outcomes offer…

    17 条评论
  • #29 Coping with reality

    #29 Coping with reality

    It is hard to stay positive. The Trump election, a Dutch extreme right party in the government, Europe changing its…

    13 条评论
  • #27 Big questions

    #27 Big questions

    Hi all, I have travelled extensively over the last few weeks and encountered many inspiring discussions, ideas, and…

    5 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了