24. Should You Seek Credentials or Not—Personal Context is Key: Overcoming Indecisiveness

Series Overview

No wonder you sometimes feel hesitant and indecisive when receiving advice from AI, experts, social media, or loved ones, as these sources often provide conflicting guidance, which only adds to your confusion. This happens because no one understands your personal context better than you do. Without that context, external input can feel irrelevant. The key is to integrate outside advice with your own decision-making skills.

That’s why the "Personal Context is Key: Overcoming Indecisiveness" series has come to life. It presents two opposing viewpoints on a given topic, illustrating that while both perspectives have compelling arguments and solid foundations, the ultimate right choice for you depends only on your current situation and unique circumstances. Thus, understanding and applying your personal context is essential for making decisions that truly align with your capabilities, needs, and goals.

- Oh snap! You have an idea for this series that you'd like to share with the public? My platform is open for any contributions, whether it's just a topic suggestion or a complete article. All contributions will be credited!

Article #24: Should You Seek Credentials or Not?

A renowned doctor graduated from a prestigious medical school, achieving exceptional milestones and a remarkable professional track record. On the other hand, a young entrepreneur graduated from a local college and went on to establish a multimillion-dollar company that is now publicly traded. Both individuals reached extraordinary heights in their careers, yet their paths to success differ significantly: one heavily relied on credentials, while the other rose without any prominent ones. This contrast raises an intriguing question: should you seek credentials or not?

Types of Credentials

According to BC Diploma, by dictionary definition, a credential is essentially proof of who you are and what you have achieved. Credentials can be divided into the following general categories:

1. Academic Credentials: These encompass degrees, certifications, licenses, and diplomas earned through formal education. They serve as evidence of academic achievement and subject matter expertise.
2. Professional Credentials: These are typically issued by professional organizations or regulatory bodies. They often include licenses required to practice a specific profession (e.g., medical or legal licenses) or certifications validating specialized skills.
3. Work Experience and Testimonial Credentials: These include documented proof of professional achievements and endorsements, such as work experience letters, references from previous employers, and testimonials from clients or colleagues.

There are many factors that affect the importance and validity of Credentials.?

• Context and Culture: Geographical and cultural differences play a major role. Identity credentials, for example, may be crucial in some countries but less relevant in others. Similarly, family lineage may matter in traditional societies but not in merit-based ones.
• Industry Requirements: Certain sectors, like healthcare or law, prioritize academic and professional credentials due to regulatory standards, while creative fields may value experience and portfolios more.
• Global and Technological Trends: Credentials like internationally recognized certifications or digital micro-certifications have gained prominence in globally connected and tech-driven industries.
• Reputation of Issuers: Credentials from well-known institutions or reputable organizations hold more weight and are often perceived as more credible.
• Evolving Alternatives: Skills-based hiring, portfolios, and demonstrable work experience are becoming viable substitutes or supplements to traditional academic and professional credentials, especially in innovative fields.

Viewpoint 1: You Should Seek Credentials

In a world of abundance, one effective way to stand out is through your resume, where specific credentials can make a significant impact. As Erik Simins highlights in his article "What are Credentials and Why are Credentials Important?", having the right credentials is crucial for making your application stand out. With businesses increasingly shifting to remote work, applicants from all around the world are competing for the same positions, making job markets more competitive than ever.

Even if you meet all the qualifications listed in a job posting, having additional relevant credentials can set your application apart from others. Credentials can also lead to higher-paying opportunities. When you hold a certification or diploma in a particular field, you are often able to command a higher wage and receive benefits, such as medical insurance.

Furthermore, credentials help build credibility, offering employers tangible proof of your expertise. According to BC Diploma, credentials are more than just documents; they validate your competence, training, and professional commitment. They can also provide valuable networking opportunities. Individuals with similar credentials often share passions and foster a mindset of continuous learning. Additionally, credentials from reputable institutions often grant access to professional networks, alumni groups, or industry events that can lead to career opportunities and collaborations.

On a more personal level, credentials offer a sense of recognition and respect. They enhance your reputation, earning respect within your field and from peers, boosting confidence and influence. Moreover, credentials encourage accountability, creating a sense of responsibility for maintaining ethical and professional standards, particularly in fields that directly affect public well-being.

Viewpoint 2: You Should Not Seek Credentials

Credentials don't always indicate a person's ability to perform a job. As Wade Foster mentions in his article "Why Credentials Are Useless and How to Spot Capable People Who Genuinely Love Their Jobs", many of the best professionals he’s worked with didn’t have solid credentials. A list of qualifications may show how well someone can navigate bureaucratic systems, but it’s not a reliable predictor of success. What matters most is whether someone can do the job. In many industries today, experience is valued more than credentials, as employers look for proof of practical knowledge, often through situational questions during interviews.

Moreover, credentials lack standardization, with varying quality and relevance across industries. Without a universally recognized system, some credentials might not hold much value. Over-relying on credentials can also lead to overlooking talented individuals who may lack formal qualifications but possess the necessary skills. In rapidly changing job markets, particularly in fields like tech or digital marketing, staying current with trends and tools may outweigh traditional credentials.

On a personal level, the increasing importance of soft skills—such as communication, adaptability, and emotional intelligence—further reduces the weight of credentials, as these qualities aren’t always measured by formal qualifications. Additionally, creativity and innovation are essential traits that credentials don't directly nurture. Relying on credentials for self-worth can also be harmful, creating pressure to meet external expectations. True fulfillment comes from aligning your career with your values and passions, not from a list of credentials. Personal development is about emotional intelligence, adaptability, and the ability to navigate life’s complexities, qualities that credentials don’t always capture. Ultimately, credentials may limit your potential by pushing you to follow conventional pathways, rather than encouraging a unique, fulfilling journey.

Samar's Two Cents

As a 22-year-old navigating the challenge of separating my self-worth from my credentials while still feeling the need to prove myself in a highly competitive world, I’ve come to realize that balance lies in perspective. It’s important to reassess why we pursue certain credentials—whether they stem from genuine desire or external validation—while also acknowledging that continuous learning is essential. More importantly, real-world experience fosters the creativity, innovation, and soft skills that are increasingly?valuable?today.

Wafa's Two Cents

Credentials and experience go hand in hand. Credentials, such as degrees from top institutions or experience at top companies, are valuable for building a career. However, the pitfall lies in overemphasizing these external achievements without a clear personal vision or plan. If you focus too much on accumulating prestigious credentials or high-profile experiences, you may end up on a path shaped more by societal or professional expectations than by your own values, goals, and vision. The key is to treat credentials and experience as tools for growth, not as the sole framework for your career. A well-defined plan ensures that these external elements support your unique vision rather than pushing you toward a conventional idea of success.

As the proverb goes,

• "In the sea of competition, credentials are your lighthouse.", or
• "True worth is shown in action, not in paper."

Samar Kamaleddine | HR Professional | Bachelor of Business Administration @University of Balamand

Wafa Damlaj, MHRM | HR Leader @Amazon | HR PhD Student @University of Texas at Tyler