21ST CENTURY REGULATIONS FOR 21ST CENTURY TECHNOLOGIES: WHY THE FCC'S NET NEUTRALITY RULING IS A GAME-CHANGER FOR INNOVATION

While some regulators seem stuck in the 1930s and 40s, the FCC demonstrates a forward-thinking approach by recognizing that 21st-century technologies require 21st-century regulations. The FCC's net neutrality rule is a beacon for innovation in the U.S., ensuring that new technologies, applications, and services—whether running on blockchain or not—can compete fairly in the marketplace.

There was a time when choosing your phone or designing and running new applications on the nation’s telecom network was not an option. Before 1968, only Western Electric phones could be connected to a phone line because incumbents claimed other devices could damage the network. It took nearly 20 more years for the government to mandate that incumbents open the network to competitive providers.

The development of packet-switching protocols, like TCP/IP—which makes the modern Internet possible—was a giant leap forward. Today, voice calls, web pages, YouTube videos, and ChatGPT sessions are all just data packets traveling over the network.

Net neutrality ensures that network providers cannot discriminate by prioritizing data packets from some commercial providers over others.

Net Neutrality: A Catalyst for Innovation

Net neutrality is the principle that all internet traffic should be treated equally. This means that internet service providers (ISPs) cannot discriminate or charge differently based on user, content, website, platform, application, or method of communication. In essence, net neutrality ensures that the internet remains an open and fair platform where anyone can launch a website or service without fear of being throttled or blocked by ISPs.

This principle of equal treatment has enabled a plethora of home-grown internet applications that have become integral to our social and work lives. Platforms like YouTube, Netflix, Zoom, and Facetime are now core components of American (and global) culture. Without net neutrality, network providers could have blocked these services, favored their own, and stifled competition.

Fair regulations create a sandbox where creative ideas can flourish and be tested in the market. Blockchain-based solutions are poised for innovative designs on the modern internet, with the potential to revolutionize more than just finance. However, achieving this requires fair, clear, and smart regulations.

Net neutrality is crucial for innovators seeking to operate on the network. Consider generative AI or the blockchain-enabled affordable phone service offered by companies like Helium Mobile. These capabilities exemplify the original intent of the internet and net neutrality principles. Open network access is vital for their development and competitive health.

The FCC’s Ruling

The FCC's recent decision to reinstate net neutrality rules reverses the 2017 repeal, which had potentially allowed ISPs to favor certain services or websites over others. The reinstatement ensures that ISPs must continue to provide equal access to all internet content without giving preferential treatment to their services or to those who can afford to pay more.

Why This Matters for Web3 Startups

1. Ensuring Fair Competition: Net neutrality prevents ISPs from creating fast lanes for big corporations that can afford to pay for better service. This is crucial for Web3 startups, which often operate on limited budgets. It ensures that their decentralized applications (dApps) and services have the same opportunity to reach users as those of larger, established companies.
2. Encouraging Innovation: The Web3 space thrives on innovation, with new blockchain-based solutions emerging rapidly. By guaranteeing equal access to the internet, net neutrality fosters an environment where startups can experiment and innovate without the fear of being sidelined by ISPs favoring established players.
3. Boosting User Trust: Web3 is built on decentralization and trust. Net neutrality aligns with these principles by ensuring that no single entity can control or manipulate the flow of information on the internet. This boosts user confidence in Web3 platforms, encouraging wider adoption.
4. Facilitating Decentralization: The core ethos of Web3 is decentralization, removing intermediaries and giving power back to users. Net neutrality supports this by preventing ISPs from acting as gatekeepers, thereby promoting a more decentralized internet where users have greater control over their online experiences.

Real-World Implications

For Web3 startups, the reinstatement of net neutrality means more than just fair competition; it represents the possibility to thrive in a truly open internet. Here are a few specific benefits:

• Lower Barriers to Entry: Startups can enter the market without securing expensive deals with ISPs to ensure their services are delivered effectively. This lowers the financial barriers to entry and encourages a diverse range of new players in the Web3 space.
• Enhanced User Experience: With net neutrality, all users can access Web3 services without experiencing throttling or slower speeds. This ensures a consistent and high-quality user experience, which is critical for adopting new technologies.
• Global Reach: Web3 startups often aim for a global audience. Net neutrality ensures that their services can reach users worldwide without being hindered by regional ISP policies. This global accessibility is vital for the growth of the decentralized web.

?

Protecting New Competitors

Net neutrality guardrails protect new competitors like Helium Mobile from unfair network practices. Helium's decentralized system of internet-connected hotspots creates a dynamic network for wireless connectivity, challenging conventional wisdom about how phone networks are built and owned. Net neutrality allows Helium to innovate and compete with some of the most influential companies in the world, including network providers.

One of the many innovations enabled by blockchain is decentralized ownership of public infrastructure networks (DePIN) through token rewards for building and maintaining the network. In Helium's case, this innovation applies to wireless communications.

DePIN is uniquely positioned to solve problems like providing sustainable connectivity to rural and underserved communities by empowering them to create their own wireless infrastructure. However, the involvement of blockchain and tokens has led to regulatory uncertainty, stifling competition, innovation, and consumer opportunities.

The FCC has set a model for smart regulatory approaches by considering the evolution and development of the industry and markets it regulates. This approach maximizes future innovation while protecting consumers and critical infrastructure.

Other regulators should follow the FCC's example, engaging with innovating DePIN projects to understand the technology, innovation potential, and emerging capabilities that can transform infrastructure and consumer interaction. Protecting consumers from undue harm while enabling innovations that offer market choices will benefit U.S. consumers, society, and the economy in the next phase of the digital era.

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) recently reinstated net neutrality rules. This move is a game-changer for Web3 startups, promising an open and level playing field crucial for innovation and growth. But what exactly does this ruling entail, and why is it such a big deal for the burgeoning Web3 ecosystem?

The FCC’s decision to reinstate net neutrality is a major win for Web3 startups. It preserves the internet as an open platform where innovation can flourish, competition is fair, and users have equal access to information and services. For those building the next generation of decentralized applications, this ruling provides a stable foundation upon which they can grow and succeed. As the Web3 ecosystem evolves, net neutrality will be a cornerstone of its progress, ensuring that the digital future is open, fair, and decentralized.

?