Can This Hardy Band of Students Save the 10-K?
In our quest to chase perfection in corporate disclosure, we have a valuable resource we can tap into.
Fresh eyeballs.
Yes, the old problem of ensuring that disclosures work well for investors demands fresh thinking and new perspectives. Who better to provide that than a group of talented graduate students?
That’s why I’m thrilled about a new initiative that my organization, the Center for Audit Quality, has launched with the Institute for Corporate Responsibility at the George Washington (GW) University School of Business. It’s called the Initiative on Rethinking Financial Disclosure, and it responds directly to Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chair Mary Jo White’s challenge to streamline Form 10-K disclosure requirements.
Let’s take a closer look.
Teams Compete to Improve Disclosure Effectiveness, Eliminate Redundancy
The initiative is structured as a team competition. Several teams of graduate students at the GW School of Business will study the issues driving concerns over effective corporate disclosure. Each team will then review several Form 10-K reports from randomly selected Fortune 500 companies. Their mission: to improve the effectiveness of the disclosure for investors. The students can, for example, make specific recommendations on ways to reduce unnecessary or redundant reporting requirements, while maintaining the integrity and value of the information for investors.
Governance Experts on Board
Students aren’t going entirely alone on this. The initiative has organized an advisory committee co-chaired by the Honorable Cynthia Glassman, Senior Research Scholar at the Institute, and me. We’re very grateful for the academics, practitioners, and others who have volunteered for the advisory committee. They are:
- James Glassman, Chairman and CEO of Public Affairs Engagement and Visiting Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
- J. Richard Knop, GW Trustee and Managing Member, FedCap Partners
- David Martin, Partner, Covington & Burling
- Aeisha Mastagni, Investment Officer, Corporate Governance, CalSTRS
- Susan Phillips, Professor of Finance Emeritus and former Dean, The George Washington University School of Business
- Troy Paredes, Senior Strategy & Policy Advisor, PwC
- Harvey Pitt, Founder, Chief Executive Officer and a Managing Director, Kalorama Partners and Kalorama Legal Services
- Jason Polun, Director of US Equity Research, T. Rowe Price Associates
- Neila Radin, Senior Vice President and Associate General Counsel, JPMorgan Chase
- Amar Sarwal, Vice President and Chief Legal Strategist, Association of Corporate Counsel
Next Steps
The final projects will be presented for judging this September. Then, the most effective recommendations will be compiled into a report that will be submitted to the SEC in October 2014.
I wish these students the best of luck. Effective disclosure is a key component of world-class capital markets, and these students, working with their advisors, will have a chance to make a positive contribution to this important public policy dialogue.
I look forward to updating you on the initiative and, as always, welcome your thoughts in the comments.
Actor, TV Presenter, Speaker and Author
10 年I agree with David Guilford You can't have too much transparency. Companies too often still think that the business is 'theirs' and see the audit process as a 'spy' and resent any challenge to their processes. Well done for this new imitative, hope it comes to fruition.
President/Principal of Aleph Investments, LLC
10 年If I were doing your project, I would not have chosen any of your "governance experts." I would have chosen a group of lower level accounting users comprised of value investors, short sellers, and accounting analysts who are openly skeptical of GAAP.
I train the most client-focused Financial Services Professionals in the Gulf South.
10 年Excellent initiative, Cindy. Best of luck to both you and the students involved. There's no such thing as "too" transparent when it comes to the numbers.
--
10 年true ,it is nice to hear
HR/Admin Specialist Administrative assistant who is diligent and adaptable, has strong organizational abilities, and is well-versed in company policies and procedures.
10 年maybe, if only things are put in other