The (Revolutionary) Get-Hit-in-the-Face-with-a-Horse Diet!

A couple of weeks ago, my sister got hit in the face with a horse, and the pounds have been dropping off ever since. It seemed unfair to keep this revolutionary weight-loss breakthrough to ourselves, so I am writing to share it. We’ll get back to that.

First, a bit about horses and horse ownership. I made what turned out to be a surprising invitation to all manner of aspersions, most having something to do with elitism, when I mentioned in one of my recent columns, in a particular context, that I have a horse. I do, and I am not ashamed to admit it!

The ranting in question may have had its basis in passions having nothing to do with horses, and likely represented a small minority of readers; but I feel compelled to set the record straight just the same. While aristocracy might figure in the whole horsey thing for members of the British gentry, US Equestrian Team, and most entrants in the Kentucky Derby, that’s not the case for most of the rest of us. Having a horse is just a matter of priorities- like having a pool, for instance, or a snowmobile, or an ATV. It’s about what you love.

A lot of just plain country folk have horses. Decidedly un-aristocratic farmers and ranchers have horses. And so do a lot of people who just love them.

I am one of those, and so is my sister, and my niece-with whom this tale really begins. My sister’s daughter fell in love with equestrianism at a very young age, and did the customary thing: she pleaded and wheedled relentlessly. Eventually, my hard-working sister and brother-in-law relented when opportunity knocked. A young former racehorse, badly beaten up and abused by that notorious vocation, and with a serious injury requiring months of rehab with an uncertain outcome, was available at a bargain basement price. They bought him for my niece, who named him Beau, nurtured him back to health – and nurtured herself into an accomplished rider (for those who care, her specialty is eventing). My niece covers the costs of her horse’s upkeep by working at the barn.

I trust that will suffice to discourage vituperations by the anti-elitist cabal. Back to our regularly scheduled program.

A couple of weeks ago, my sister was walking next to Beau, on a lead rope, past a paddock. I forget the details, but for some reason, one of the horses in the paddock suddenly took off at a gallop, startling Beau, who swung his massive horsey head- right into my sister’s face. As noted, my sister has been losing weight hand over fist ever since.

And since in our culture, any way of losing weight fast is a good way, I thought it was time to introduce the “hit in the face with a horse” diet.

It’s new, and it works! No need to count calories! No need to exercise! It’s got that quintessential “just do this one thing and weight will fall off you” attribute that tends to make for best-sellers. I envision a book, perhaps a movie, and certainly the next big societal trend.

Now, admittedly, there are certain liabilities. My sister was knocked off her feet, and may have been briefly unconscious. She needed stitches in her eyelid, her lip was split open, and she was fortunate not to lose any teeth. She has a fracture running from her nose to her jaw, making chewing very painful. That probably accounts for the weight loss.

But those are just details. The basic gist is: get hit in the face with a horse, lose weight in a hurry. Since when do we care if the way we lose weight fast is actually a good idea?

After all, over recent years, I have been invited by various media to opine on astoundingly cockamamie lose-weight-fast strategies. There was the Dukan Diet, which was basically Atkins accelerated by extreme calorie restriction, and nicely presented with the flourish of a French accent. Far sillier was the HCG Diet, which invited people to spend a fortune on hormone injections that almost certainly did nothing, while adhering to a 500kcal/day diet, which obviously would have explained the rapid weight loss in the absence of the injections. Anyone remember Dumbo’s feather?

And then, there was one of my all-time favorites, the KE Diet, which provocatively also involved noses. This diet requires inserting a feeding tube through the nose, down the throat, and into the duodenum- with an infusion of a feeding solution in lieu of food.

In comparison to these, the get-hit-in-the-face-with-a-horse diet (how about we call it GHFH, and pronounce it like “guffaw”?) seems to produce comparably rapid weight loss. Of course, it’s a N of 1 thus far, but diets have made the best seller list with little more than that to back them up before, so let’s not split hairs.

Better still, there is no doctor visit required; well, unless you wind up needing stitches. There is no feeding solution, and no injections. And the whole thing could be free- if you can find a friend who will let you borrow the horse. Of course, there is a golden opportunity here for all good capitalists, so I suspect you will wind up needing to rent the horse. But one good clock in the face should do it, so it shouldn’t cost too much.

Anticipating the success of GHFH, I envision the inevitable sequels. The ultra-uber-GHFH Diet, in which you accelerate your weight loss by getting hit in the face with two horses. The GHFH Diet for kids, who only need to be hit in the face with ponies (this would be a picture book). The GHFH Diet cookbook- featuring all of the wonderful cuisine you can enjoy with a broken nose and jaw.

Of course, you can also lose weight- and find health- by eating well and exercising, no horse required. And as it happens, most people who lose weight and keep it off do exactly that. Admittedly, a world awash in junk food engineered to be addictive, the invention of labor-saving technology as the mother of sedentary necessity, and the hypocrisy of fretting about childhood obesity while continuing to market multi-colored marshmallows to kids as “part of a complete breakfast”- makes the job harder than it needs to be. But with the right skillpower, acquired on your own or with some help, you can get there from here.

But eating well and being physically active fails the “just do this one thing and weight will fall off like magic” test. In contrast, the GHFH diet fully satisfies it.

So, much as the idealist in me would like to keep advocating for eating well and being active, the pragmatist in me can see what our culture really needs. So it is with great pride and excitement (and regret that I have to share a commission with my sister) that I introduce the ground-breaking (not to mention nose-breaking) GHFH Diet! Because when all is said and done, you can lead a horse to water, but

-fin

PS- for the compassionate souls among you, I suspect you will want to know that my sister is on the mend, and gave her permission before I posted this column. When I read it to her, she did mention that it hurts to laugh. She invites you to check out her before/after photos at https://www.facebook.com/elizabeth.katz.9

Dr. David L. Katz has authored three editions of a leading nutrition textbook. He is editor-in-chief of the peer-reviewed journal, Childhood Obesity, and President of the American College of Lifestyle Medicine. He is the author of Disease Proof, and most recently, of the epic novel, reVision. He is the proud (and un-Knighted) owner of Troubadour, who has thus far withheld the favor of hitting him in the face.

www.davidkatzmd.com
www.turnthetidefoundation.org

https://www.loreofthecorners.com/

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Dr-David-L-Katz/114690721876253
https://twitter.com/DrDavidKatz
https://www.dhirubhai.net/pub/david-l-katz-md-mph/7/866/479/

Photo: Shutterstock.com

Sunny Otake

RN with experience in pediatrics, rehabilitation, telemetry and chemical dependency counseling

10 年

Glad she's on the mend! And is the horse doing okay, too? Another horse lover, here...

回复
Stephanie Servy

Senior Account Executive @ Brevium | Improving dramatically patient adherence and continuity of care

10 年

GHFH! :-)

回复
Elizabeth Katz

Professor at Towson University

10 年

In light of some of the comments, I thought I would weigh in - First, I am doing quite well and feeling much better - my teeth still hurt so the weight loss benefits continue. I was truly fortunate... I did not lose consciousness, kept all my teeth, was of sufficiently clear mind to be able to call a friend to take me to the emergency room, and was found not to have a concussion. With the exception of a couple of small scars and the weight loss, I do not expect to suffer any residual problems from the experience. My brother, David L. Katz, MD, MPH, did in fact text me to ask my permission to write this story and read it to me before he published it. I found it to be extremely funny and was glad my experience could benefit others in a meaningful way. I am a firm believer that laughter is the best medicine - despite the discomfort, my husband and I began making jokes about my experience and appearance as soon as he arrived in the emergency room. It helped us cope with the stress of waiting for hours to be seen, knowing that our kids were at home and we could not reassure them that I was ok, and it helped take our attention off how bad I really looked. I credit my rapid improvement to my family's wonderful sense of humor and their ability to laugh at and with me in the face of adversity! So keep laughing, it has excellent healing properties - perhaps it will be the next diet craze when GHFWH is ready for the glue factory!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

David L. Katz, MD, MPH的更多文章

  • The Better Assessment of Dietary Intake, Now

    The Better Assessment of Dietary Intake, Now

    A recent article in Science, citing a recent study in Nature Food, contends that we need a new and better way to…

    7 条评论
  • Ultra-Processed Foods: My Verdict

    Ultra-Processed Foods: My Verdict

    Guilty, as charged, in case you are quite short on time. If you have a minute, or ten, by all means- please read on.

    15 条评论
  • Of Blue Zones and Bull…Dozers

    Of Blue Zones and Bull…Dozers

    Since first learning of the Blue Zones over a decade ago, I have held them up as the most luminous, decisive…

    17 条评论
  • Correlation Isn’t Causation, Except When It Is

    Correlation Isn’t Causation, Except When It Is

    In the world at large- a clickbait, deepfake, soundbite world- nuance is everywhere on the ropes. We seek our answers…

    11 条评论
  • Food as Medicine: The Case for Measuring What We Intend to Manage

    Food as Medicine: The Case for Measuring What We Intend to Manage

    The Food-as-Medicine movement - a movement I applaud, in which I am involved, and arguably to which my whole career has…

    11 条评论
  • Nutrition Research, Olive Oil, and The Case for More 'And,' Less 'Or'

    Nutrition Research, Olive Oil, and The Case for More 'And,' Less 'Or'

    After some 40 years devoted to the science (and art) of applying nutrition to the promotion of human health, I hold…

    16 条评论
  • The Many Flavors of Optimal Nutrition

    The Many Flavors of Optimal Nutrition

    Some years ago, I wrote a commissioned article for a peer-reviewed compendium, entitled “Can We Say What Diet is Best…

    5 条评论
  • An Anti-Diet Antidote

    An Anti-Diet Antidote

    The “anti-diet” movement, we are told- specifically by The Washington Post and The Examination- began with good…

    22 条评论
  • Food as Medicine, and the Pseudo-Sophistication of Doubt

    Food as Medicine, and the Pseudo-Sophistication of Doubt

    A colleague and I recently had the opportunity to “pitch” what we do, what our company offers, to a convened group of…

    13 条评论
  • Of Course, Food-as-Medicine Works

    Of Course, Food-as-Medicine Works

    Diet in America, and much of the world, is badly broken. How badly? Poor overall diet quality is the single leading…

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了