The Insult That Catapulted My Career
J.T. O'Donnell
Founder & CEO, Work It DAILY | Board of Directors, McCoy | Career & Professional Development | Job Search | HR & Recruiting | Employer Branding | Recruitment Marketing | Talent Management | Executive Coaching
In 2007, I did a fair amount of work with corporate executive teams on the subject of coaching their entry-level employees - also referred to as Gen Y. I had been hired to explain the mindset of this new generation of workers and how to coach them in their careers. It was a subject I had come to care a lot about. In the year leading up to the corporate work, I had seen a dramatic increase in the number of young people coming to me for coaching. The confusion and distress over their careers was so intense, I would use the term “on-set career crisis” to describe how acute the pain of early career development was for them.
A Generation Punished by Rewards
When teaching the executive sessions, my favorite reference to explain what Gen Y was experiencing professionally was a book by Alfie Kohn entitled, “Punished by Rewards: The Problem with A’s, Praise, and Other Bribes.” The book had been written long before we adopted the terms “Helicopter Parents” and “Boomerang Kids” (Also known as KIPPERS – Kids In Parents Pockets Eating Retirement Savings.). Kohn was ahead of his time. In the book , he points out how Gen Y was a product of a society that used too many external motivators to get them to take action. The result was a generation who lacked intrinsic motivation – a/k/a the desire to do things for the sake of doing them. Moreover, it showed that all the positive reinforcement they got (i.e. everyone gets a trophy for showing up) created a very negative side effect: Gen Y was petrified of not being able to live up to the potential society had told them they not only possessed, but were obligated to make good on.
Gen Y Expert Told Me Off
The reaction to my presentations had been positive enough that it made me think I should explore ways to coach young professionals on a larger scale. I decided to start researching ways to do that. I looked for fellow career experts that where coaching Gen Y and reached out to them. One of them had become a very outspoken proponent for the generation. This person's work was cited in the media and had a new business that focused on helping young professionals which was growing nicely. So, I reached out and asked if we could grab a call to discuss the topic of Gen Y and got a “yes.” I was psyched.
Foolish me.
Since I initiated the meeting, I lead the conversation. I shared how I got into career coaching and talked about my experience with the Gen Y and the managers who were frustrated in leading them. I outlined my recent work with young professionals and how I thought we could be serving them better. I then asked the question, “What are your thoughts?” What I expected was an engaging conversation about the topic. What I got was the following:
“I think you should stick to coaching mommies like yourself. You don’t know what you are talking about.” I’m pretty sure a few more things were said, but at that point, I was so struck, it was lost on me.
Then there was…
Silence.
Crickets.
Finally, an out-of-body experience where I remember saying something to the effect of, “Oh. Wow. Really? Well I guess I appreciate your honesty. Thanks for your time.”
Anger, Fear, Sadness & Anger Again (Thank Goodness!)
I hung up the phone and was fuming. I mean really, really mad. Then, the self-doubt kicked in. Was this person right? Was I off-track? This coach certainly had a lot of success in the space if you based it on media attention, so perhaps I sounded like a complete idiot and got justly put in my place?
My anger turned to fear and sadness. I spent the afternoon in a haze of confusion. How could I have been so crazy? What was I thinking? Geez. Did I just humiliate myself, or what?
I processed the event for several more hours until my husband came home from work. At which point, I promptly sat him down and gave him the blow-by-blow. I could feel my energy rising, my anger showing, and my voice speed and tone increasing. I got it all off my chest. When I was done, I stared at him.
Then there was…
Silence.
Crickets.
Finally, an in-my-body experience where I remember watching a huge grin cross my husband’s face and an even bigger laugh come out of his mouth as he said. “Good. I’m glad it happened. It’s clearly lit a fire under your ass. That always gets you doing your best work. Go prove the coach wrong.”
Your Passion for Solving a Problem Doesn’t Require Validation – So Don’t Ask for It!
My hubby was right. (But then, he has a knack for being helpful. Read here…)
How could I possibly let one person derail me from what I felt was right? Why couldn’t I do it my way? And more importantly, why was I looking for this expert’s approval? The only validation I really needed was from the young professionals who benefited from my work. That would be the true and only test of whether what I was doing was worthwhile. I was guilty of looking for an external motivator, when all I needed was to follow my internal one. I wanted to help Gen Y and, darn it, that’s what I was going to do. End of story. No validation necessary!
Thanks for the Insult - No Really, I Mean It!
Fast forward to today, and I’ve worked with hundreds of recent grads to show them how to find career satisfaction on their own terms. I absolutely love working with young people because they are incredible learners. They still see the world is full of professional possibilities - all they need is some guidance, 20 seconds of career courage, and the skill development necessary to make their career goals a reality. That I can do.
I look back now and have to thank that expert for the insult. Without it, I’m not sure I’d be where I am today.
How about you? What insult got you to pursue a new avenue in your career?
Or, did an insult or criticism make you give up on pursuing a career path? If so, I hope this story inspires you to use their negativity to your advantage.
If you want to read more of what I've written, check out my articles on Inc.com.
P.S. - First time reading my posts? Thanks for taking the time to stop by! Not only do I write for Linkedin, but I'm also founder of a popular career advice site,CAREEREALISM,and currently run the career coaching program,CareerHMO. I hope you'll check them both out!
If you enjoyed reading this article, you may also like:
CAREEREALISM’s Founder, J.T. O’Donnell is a nationally syndicated career expert and workplace consultant who helps American workers of all ages find greater professional satisfaction. Her book, CAREEREALISM: The Smart Approach to a Satisfying Career, outlines her highly successful career-coaching methodology. Purchase her e-book of CAREEREALISM for only $9.95 by clicking here !
Image credit: Shutterstock
Talent Acquisition at Arcadis ?? Resilience ?? Improving Quality of Life
9 年The first thing I do when faced with an insult or unfair criticism (from someone whose opinion I might actually care about) is to ask myself what is in it for them. What is their motivation? In a situation like yours, I too would get angry. Anger is a valid and very motivating response in such a situation. In the end, the only person I need to prove something to is myself.
Canadian Tire Bank | Collections and Sales Professional
9 年Sometimes these insults are actually good for you especially when it lights a fire in you and not just under your butt
J.T. O'Donnell another great sharing. Thank you so much!
Business Development Exec??Coach & Mentor??Category Development Specialist??Customer Centric Focused??Perpetual Student Of Life??Inspiring Others To Make A Difference??
9 年I love this Story TJ and it does remind me a lot of so of my own experences. Creativity and individuality are sometimes perceived by some as dangerous trates. It's passion that drives a person to a solution and persistence, driven by an inquisitive nature, that often finds resistance. Some people are ahead of their time, not because of poor timing but more from poor realization by others in their field. It's too many smart people living in a comfort zone that hold back progress. Thinking on a completely different level to everyone else is what is needed to bring about change.
International Speaker | Workshop Facilitator | Storyteller | Musician | Gallup StrengthsFinder Coach | 360+Episodes Podcast Host | Author | Job Interview Coach
9 年What an excellent story, J.T.! Thanks for sharing.