(1st Cir. 2023)--Personal Jurisdiction--Cappello v. Restaurant Depot, LLC, No. 23-1368

JUSTIA OPINION SUMMARY: The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reviewed an appeal concerning personal jurisdiction in a case centered on foodborne illness. Anthony Cappello, a resident of New Hampshire, had consumed a salad from a New Jersey deli, which he alleged was contaminated with E. coli. Following his diagnosis, Cappello filed a lawsuit against the deli, the company that sold the lettuce to the deli (Restaurant Depot, LLC), the distributor of the lettuce (D'Arrigo Brothers, Co.), the grower of the lettuce (Adam Brothers Farming, Inc.), and one hundred John Does. Cappello later dismissed his claims against all defendants except for Restaurant Depot and D'Arrigo Brothers. Both companies moved to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction, arguing that Cappello's claims did not arise from their contacts with New Hampshire. The District Court dismissed the case, and Cappello appealed. The Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's decision, albeit on different grounds. The court held that Cappello failed to demonstrate the necessary element of relatedness required to establish specific personal jurisdiction under the due process clause. Neither defendant's contacts with New Hampshire were instrumental in the formation or breach of the contract related to the sale of the salad, nor were they related to the tort claims. The court found that the defendants' contacts with New Hampshire were not sufficiently related to Cappello's claims to establish personal jurisdiction.https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/ca1/23-1368/23-1368-2023-12-28.pdf?ts=1703806228