The last article in our series how to build reliable financial management structure is obviously measuring the ROI of such investment. It's not that easy to isolate factors of cost, from benefits, especially the non-financial ones, like employee satisfaction, accuracy, and timeliness, which in a way or another will add the company profitability, by reduced cost, or at least the valuation of the company as part of the assets...
Effectively managing costs and evaluating the return on investment (ROI) are key to ensuring that your ERP implementation delivers value without exceeding budget. By carefully managing costs throughout the implementation process and continuously measuring ROI, you can maximize the benefits of the ERP system while controlling expenditures. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you manage costs and measure ROI effectively.
Step 1: Create a Detailed Budget for ERP Implementation
Start by creating a comprehensive budget that accounts for all costs associated with the ERP implementation. This includes not only the cost of the ERP software but also hardware, customization, training, and ongoing support.
- Budget Components to Consider: Software Licensing or Subscription Fees: Whether you’re purchasing a one-time license or subscribing to a cloud-based ERP, include these costs in your budget. Hardware Costs: If you’re hosting the ERP system on-premises, account for the costs of servers, networking equipment, and other hardware. Customization and Development: Estimate the costs for any customizations, integrations, or add-ons that will be required to tailor the ERP system to your business. Training and Support: Allocate funds for employee training, vendor support, and post-implementation assistance. Consulting Services: If you’re using third-party consultants to help with implementation, include their fees in the budget.
- Example: A medium-sized manufacturing company might budget $100,000 for ERP implementation, broken down as $50,000 for software, $20,000 for hardware, $15,000 for customization, and $15,000 for training and ongoing support.
- Tip: Build a contingency fund into your budget (typically 10-20%) to cover unexpected costs that may arise during the implementation process.
Step 2: Monitor Costs Throughout the Project
Once the budget is set, closely monitor expenditures throughout the implementation process to ensure that costs stay on track. Regular cost monitoring helps prevent overspending and allows you to make adjustments if needed.
- Cost Monitoring Strategies: Track Expenses by Phase: Break down the budget into phases (e.g., planning, implementation, training) and track actual costs against budgeted amounts for each phase. Regular Reviews: Hold regular budget review meetings with your finance team and project managers to assess how costs are tracking against the budget. Adjust as Needed: If certain areas are running over budget, identify where you can cut costs or adjust other areas to stay within the overall budget.
- Example: If the customization phase of the ERP implementation is running 15% over budget, you may need to reduce customization scope or reallocate funds from other areas, such as training, to cover the difference.
- Tip: Use project management software to track costs in real-time, so you can quickly identify any variances between actual expenditures and the original budget.
Step 3: Measure ROI Over Time
After the ERP system is implemented, it’s crucial to measure the ROI to ensure that the system is delivering the expected benefits. ROI is calculated by comparing the benefits gained from the ERP system against the costs incurred during implementation and ongoing usage.
- Calculating ROI: Total Cost of Ownership (TCO): Calculate the total cost of ownership over a set period (e.g., 3-5 years), including implementation costs, licensing fees, ongoing maintenance, and any operational costs related to the ERP. Quantifiable Benefits: Identify the financial gains from the ERP system, such as increased efficiency, reduced labor costs, improved inventory management, and faster order processing. These benefits can be quantified by comparing key metrics before and after implementation. ROI Formula: ROI=Net?Benefit?(Gains?-?Costs)Total?Costs×100\text{ROI} = \frac{\text{Net Benefit (Gains - Costs)}}{\text{Total Costs}} \times 100ROI=Total?CostsNet?Benefit?(Gains?-?Costs)×100
- Example: A logistics company that invested $200,000 in an ERP system sees a 15% reduction in order processing time, resulting in $300,000 in annual cost savings. The ROI calculation after one year might look like this:
\text{ROI} = \frac{\text{$300,000 - $200,000}}{\text{$200,000}} \times 100 = 50\%
- Tip: Measure ROI at regular intervals (e.g., quarterly or annually) to track how the system is performing over time and whether it continues to deliver the expected benefits.
Step 4: Identify Direct and Indirect Benefits
When measuring ROI, it’s important to account for both direct and indirect benefits of the ERP system.
- Direct Benefits: Cost Savings: Direct cost reductions, such as fewer errors in inventory management or reduced labor costs due to automation. Revenue Growth: Increased sales due to better customer relationship management or faster order processing.
- Indirect Benefits: Improved Decision-Making: Better access to real-time data can lead to more informed business decisions, which may not have an immediate financial impact but can improve long-term profitability. Employee Productivity: While it may be difficult to quantify, an ERP system that simplifies workflows can lead to improved employee productivity and satisfaction.
- Example: A retail business may see direct benefits such as reduced inventory carrying costs, while also experiencing indirect benefits like improved customer satisfaction due to faster delivery times.
- Tip: Include both tangible and intangible benefits when evaluating the success of your ERP implementation. Even benefits that are difficult to measure directly can have a significant impact on long-term business performance.
Step 5: Continuously Reevaluate Costs and Benefits
As your business grows and the ERP system evolves, continuously reevaluate the costs and benefits to ensure the system continues to deliver value. The benefits of the ERP system may increase over time as your team becomes more proficient with it and as new features are implemented.
- Reevaluation Steps: Annual Review: Conduct an annual review of the ERP system to assess ongoing costs (e.g., maintenance, updates) and compare them against the benefits gained. Optimization Opportunities: Look for ways to optimize the system further, such as automating additional processes or enhancing reporting features, to increase ROI. Adjust ROI Expectations: If the system isn’t delivering the expected ROI, identify areas for improvement or reconsider how the system is being used.
- Example: A company might find that after two years, additional modules could be added to automate marketing or customer service processes, further improving ROI.
- Tip: Continuously benchmark your ERP performance against industry standards to ensure your system remains competitive and continues to deliver a positive ROI.
Before you decide on the next development in your business, by implementing a new ERP, I advise you to read this article carefully, may be even before the first article in the series, because it will help you take the decision boldly and in full awareness. Should you need help identifying, and managing such projects, you may schedule a call to understand more here
.
