10 Reasons Why People Resist AI, and It's Deeply Rooted in Psychology

I’ve been fascinated with psychology since I was a teenager.

In fact, I started reading about social psychology and about how to interpret body language when I was still in high school.

I was struggling with English, as it was not my first language, and I wanted to learn other ways to interpret why people behave in certain ways and how those behaviors exhibited themselves. This early interest in understanding human behavior has continued to shape my perspective, especially now as I delve into the world of AI.

Despite AI’s potential to drive efficiency, innovation, and competitive advantage, the path to AI adoption is often met with resistance.

This resistance to change is a fascinating and complex phenomenon deeply rooted in human psychology.

To gain deeper insights, I decided to explore psychological principles and mental models that could help explain why people often resist using new technology.

What I found was a fascinating mix of cognitive biases, emotional responses, and social influences that collectively contribute to this resistance.

In this article, I will cover ten different psychological principles and mental models that prevent rapid AI adoption. Each principle offers a unique lens through which to understand the reluctance to embrace new technology.

Understanding the psychological underpinnings of resistance can empower us to create more effective change management strategies.

There is power in knowing. Knowledge is power.

If we are equipped with knowledge, we can address resistance more effectively and pave the way for smoother transitions to innovative technologies.

Let's dive in.

1. Status Quo Bias

People naturally prefer to maintain their current situation, a tendency known as status quo bias. This bias leads individuals to resist change because they perceive the potential losses from adopting new technology as outweighing the possible benefits.

Example: A company introduces a new AI-powered project management tool. Employees resist using it because they are comfortable with the current tool, even though it has fewer features. They perceive the effort needed to learn the new tool as not worth the potential benefits.

Suggestion: Conduct hands-on workshops where employees can explore the new AI tool in a supportive environment. Provide quick reference guides and immediate troubleshooting support to help them get started and see immediate benefits.

2. Loss Aversion

Loss aversion is the tendency to prefer avoiding losses over acquiring equivalent gains. New technology often requires an investment of time, effort, and sometimes money, leading to perceived losses that people are reluctant to accept.

Example: A bank rolls out a new AI-powered mobile app. Customers are hesitant to switch because they fear losing access to their account information or encountering security issues, even though the new app promises better functionality and security.

Suggestion: Organize a small pilot group to use the AI app and share their positive experiences with others. Provide a hotline for immediate assistance to address any concerns as they arise.

3. Cognitive Dissonance

Cognitive dissonance occurs when people experience discomfort from holding conflicting beliefs or attitudes. If someone has invested time and effort in learning and mastering an existing technology, adopting a new one can create dissonance because it implies that the old technology might not have been the best choice.

Example: An organization implements a new AI-driven CRM system. Salespeople resist because they have spent years mastering the old system. Adopting the new one creates discomfort as it suggests their previous efforts might have been in vain.

Suggestion: Acknowledge the value of their past efforts and show how their existing skills will ease the transition. Provide a side-by-side comparison to demonstrate the improvements and efficiencies of the new AI system.

4. Fear of the Unknown

Uncertainty can cause anxiety, and new technology often comes with unknowns. People might worry about their ability to learn and use the new technology effectively, the stability and security of the technology, and its impact on their job or daily routine.

Example: A hospital adopts a new AI-based electronic health record (EHR) system. Doctors and nurses are anxious about the change because they are unsure how it will affect their workflow and patient care, leading to resistance.

Suggestion: Arrange for a series of demo sessions where employees can see the AI system in action. Allow them to interact with the system in a risk-free environment, such as a simulated setup, to build familiarity and reduce uncertainty.

5. Habitual Behavior

Habits are powerful drivers of behavior. Once people become accustomed to a particular way of doing things, it can be challenging to break these habits and adopt new routines. This is often rooted in the automaticity of behavior, where actions are performed without conscious thought due to repetition.

Example: A school introduces AI-powered tablets for classroom learning. Teachers resist using them because they are used to traditional teaching methods and find it hard to change their established routines.

Suggestion: Start by integrating the AI technology gradually, beginning with small, manageable changes that can be easily incorporated into existing routines. Highlight how the new technology can complement and enhance traditional methods rather than replace them.

6. Perceived Self-Efficacy

Self-efficacy refers to an individual’s belief in their capacity to execute behaviors necessary to produce specific performance attainments. If people doubt their ability to learn and use new technology, they are less likely to adopt it.

Example: A company transitions to a new AI-driven data analytics platform. Employees are reluctant to use it because they doubt their ability to learn the new system, fearing it is too complex and will make their jobs harder.

Suggestion: Offer bite-sized, interactive tutorials and provide immediate feedback on progress. Celebrate small victories to build confidence and show that learning the new AI system is achievable.

7. Social Influence and Norms

People are influenced by the behaviors and attitudes of those around them. If peers and colleagues are resistant to new technology, individuals are more likely to conform to this resistance due to social norms and the desire to fit in.

Example: A team within a corporation starts using a new AI-powered collaboration tool. Other teams resist adopting it because the majority of their colleagues are sticking with the old tool, creating a social norm of non-adoption.

Suggestion: Highlight early adopters and their successes through internal communications and meetings. Create incentives for teams to adopt the new AI tool and celebrate those who lead the way.

8. Endowment Effect

The endowment effect is the tendency for people to value things more highly simply because they own them. This can lead to an overvaluation of the current technology they are using and a reluctance to switch to a new one.

Example: An individual has been using a particular brand of smartphone for years. When a new, superior AI-powered brand is introduced, they resist switching because they value their current phone more highly simply because they own it.

Suggestion: Allow users to test the new AI technology alongside their current one for a short period, highlighting the advantages and superior features of the new option through direct comparison.

9. Sunk Cost Fallacy

People are often reluctant to abandon a technology they have invested significant time, effort, or money into, even if a better option is available. This is known as the sunk cost fallacy, where past investments irrationally influence current decisions.

Example: A company has invested heavily in a legacy software system over the years. Despite a new, more efficient AI system being available, management resists switching due to the significant past investment in the old system.

Suggestion: Emphasize the future benefits and potential savings of the new AI system. Present a clear timeline for return on investment (ROI) that highlights long-term gains and reduced operational costs.

10. Confirmation Bias

Once people form an opinion about a new technology, they tend to seek out information that confirms their belief and ignore information that contradicts it. This can reinforce resistance if they initially perceive the new technology negatively.

Example: A business adopts a new AI-driven cloud storage service. Some employees initially have a negative opinion of the service. They then only seek out and highlight information that confirms their view, ignoring any positive feedback or benefits the new service offers.

Suggestion: Encourage open discussions where all perspectives are heard. Present balanced information, including both pros and cons, and provide evidence-based data to address concerns. Showcase testimonials from trusted sources to help shift negative perceptions.

TL;DR

Understanding the psychological principles that contribute to resistance can help to implement AI more effectively.

As a quick summary, here are some actionable strategies to overcome these barriers:

• Communicate Benefits Clearly: Highlight the advantages of the new technology, focusing on how it will improve efficiency, productivity, and overall experience.
• Provide Training and Support: Offer comprehensive training sessions and ongoing support to build confidence and competence in using AI.
• Create a Positive Change Narrative: Frame the change as an exciting and beneficial development. Share success stories and case studies that illustrate the positive impact of AI.
• Involve Key Stakeholders Early: Engage influential team members and stakeholders in the decision-making process to gain their support and address their concerns early on.
• Encourage a Growth Mindset: Promote a culture that values learning and adaptability. Encourage employees to view the adoption of AI as an opportunity for growth and development.
• Address Emotional Concerns: Acknowledge and empathize with the emotional responses that change can elicit. Provide a platform for employees to voice their concerns and offer reassurance.
• Gradual Implementation: Implement the new technology in phases, allowing time for adjustment and reducing the perceived risk associated with the change.
• Reward Adoption: Recognize and reward early adopters and those who actively support the transition, creating positive reinforcement for others to follow.

? If you've enjoyed reading this article, subscribe to my newsletter for AI business insights, frameworks, unique perspectives, tools and more: https://sparkchange.beehiiv.com/subscribe