Earlier today, the NSW Supreme Court (McGrath J) delivered a judgment in the long running Laith & Fadi class action: Laith & Fadi Investments Pty Ltd v Fogo Brazilia Holdings Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 1508.
The decision concerned interlocutory applications filed by each of the first and second defendants, third defendant, and fourth defendant, seeking further security for their costs following termination of the lead plaintiffs’ funding agreement by their litigation funder. The lead plaintiffs (an impecunious corporation and an individual) contended that, if security was ordered, their claims were likely to be stultified.
The Court accepted that the lead plaintiffs were unable to meet an adverse costs order and that the lead plaintiffs were not only suing for their own benefit but also for the benefit of group members, having regard to the scope of the pleadings and the evidence filed by the lead plaintiffs in the main proceedings. In considering the lead plaintiffs’ evidence on the financial positions of those who will benefit from the litigation if it is successful, the Court held that the lead plaintiffs failed to discharge their onus of proof.
The Court ordered the lead plaintiffs to pay $1.3 million in security for the first and second defendants’ costs in three tranches, with the first tranche of $520,000 being payable within 14 days. If the lead plaintiffs fail to pay this security, the proceedings will be stayed as against the first and second defendants until such time as the payment is made.
The judgment is significant as it adds to a growing body of law on the principles applicable to applications for security for costs in a class action context.
Alexander Vial appeared unled for the successful first and second defendants.
A copy of the judgment is available here: https://lnkd.in/geHQJA4Q
For those interested, a link to the Laith & Fadi Class Action webpage is here:
https://lnkd.in/gaf2zVFa
#classactions #representativeproceedings #competitionandconsumerlaw #5wentworth
Attorney. Strategic Advisor. Innovator. Entrepreneur.
1 个月This will be of interest to LeadingAge Ohio members - this could have had devastating implications for the model of many Life Plan Communities / CCRCs.