"Anyone can be a manager regardless of whether they studied management or not"
Oh, for sure! 'Cause, you know, just about anyone could be a manager; very much like just about anyone could be a neurosurgeon or a rocket scientist. Why bother with years of specialized studying when you can just wing it and the fate of the organizations and people's livelihoods? ??
It's really rather fascinating how we do not apply the same rationale to any other areas. Could you imagine walking up to a civil engineer and saying, "Anyone can build a bridge!" or a psychiatrist and saying, "Anyone can prescribe mental health medication!" Management? Pfft, so easy that a child could do it!
Let's ignore, for a moment, that specialization is a thing in much of everything else. We think nothing of specialized degrees for robotics or biotechnology, not to mention environmental law. But managing? Nah, that's just telling people what to do!
It's sweet how people boil management down to "bossing other people around." After all, strategic planning, organizational behavior, financial analysis, and leadership psychology are clearly just fancy terms for "common sense." Didn't all of you know that you can master optimizing complex systems and motivating diverse teams during a coffee break?
Just the comparison of management with other disciplines is inspiring. If engineers build bridges, then in a related way, managers build and maintain entire organizational structures. Where doctors heal individuals, managers guarantee whole companies' health. Of course, let's imagine you only need to make a roster and send some emails.
Maybe, just maybe, we could apply a smidgen of critical thinking before dismissing whole fields of study? Here's an idea: instead of us assuming expertise in things we know little about, we might, I don't know, educate ourselves on the complexities involved? But that would require effort, and it's so much easier to make sweeping generalizations, isn't it?
Next time you're tempted to trivialize a profession, pause to consider this: Would I want an amateur making critical decisions that affect hundreds of lives and millions in resources? If the answer is no, perhaps it is time to reconsider that "anyone can do" mentality. Just a thought!
Jacob Stoller - we're so glad you participated in the Seminar and got so much out of it!