If your reply rate is under 3%, you have a deliverability problem.
People try to fix reply rates by changing the CTA, tweaking the offer, or changing the subject line.
And while that’s something you have to do, it doesn’t end there…
Here’s how to fix your deliverability first, so you can actually get replies ??
1?? Check if your inbox is already flagged—pause and reset.
? If your reply rate suddenly drops to <3% overnight, you’ve been flagged.
? If you're getting under 3% replies for multiple campaigns, you're being deprioritized in inboxes.
Here’s what to do:
? Stop sending from that inbox immediately. Don’t make it worse.
? Rotate in fresh domains (at least 90+ days old) to take over volume.
? Test inbox placement. Use GlockApps or MailReach to see if you're hitting spam.
Fix your placement before changing anything else.
2?? Warm-up and aging is the new black.
No warm-up = no inbox = no replies.
How to fix it?
? Use a strong warm-up: 80% reply rate, mark emails as important, pull them out of spam.
? Google & Outlook need different warm-ups:
- Gmail: 14-30 days before outbound.
- Outlook: 60-90 days before outbound.
? Ramp volume up slowly: Start with 5 emails/day per inbox. Increase by 5 per day till 30.
The inboxes that are warmed properly are the ones that will get consistent replies.
3?? Stop using LinkedIn templates and overused scripts.
Spam filters don’t just look at who is sending. They use AI to track what’s being sent.
If you and 50 other senders are using the same generic “quick question” or “company + personalization” templates, forget it.
Instead:
? Rewrite scripts with unique sentence structures (based on proper segmentation and personalization)
? Use SpinTax to randomize phrasing at scale.
? Test your copy’s inbox placement before scaling volume.
Inbox first. Then optimize for replies.
4?? Keep your email-to-domain ratio lean.
Most people blast from the same domains until they burn them.
Instead, follow this:
? Gmail: 2 mailboxes per domain → 30 emails/day per inbox.
? Outlook: Just follow your provider recommended settings.
? Rotate domains every 2-3 weeks to avoid degradation.
?? If an inbox underperforms for more than 3 weeks, retire it and switch domains.
High reply rates come from fresh, trusted domains, and conversational copy.
I’m breaking this all down and solving real cases in a live webinar on Wednesday 12th of February.
?? Comment "Webinar" below, and I’ll get you in. ??