By now, you’ve likely caught wind of Nutter Butter's viral success ??
LOUDMOUTH co-founder and creative director?RYAN ? BENSON?played a major role in planting the seeds of this absurdist strategy. During his time at the agency that operates the brand, he shaped the chaotic voice and direction Nutter Butter has now fully embraced.
BEFORE you overhaul your entire strategy, Ryan wants you to consider these 3 points:
1?? This strategy is uniquely Nutter Butter.
Sure, Nutter Butter is partially influenced by pop culture and trending formats, but the history of this persona comes from closely monitoring fans in the comments and replies. The strategy was forged as a direct response to the interactions the team noticed daily. Every step forward in strategic planning was a result of fan interaction and community response.
Look outward as much as you look inward. Elevate the discussions your followers are having in the comments. Let them influence you as much as you hope to influence them. Create an environment that makes followers feel like PART of the conversation, not simply the peanut gallery below a graphic.
2?? Don't rewrite what can instead be retold.
“Aidan” wasn’t born overnight - it’s the name of a brand superfan who had been lurking for years before his moment. The Nutter Butter Man is a character from the 1970s. Almost every step of the strategy behind Nutter Butter is tied to the consumer, the fans, and the community.
Don't try to reinvent your brand with a TikTok video. Social media is not meant to reinvent a brand's entire DNA, especially if that's not part of the overarching strategy. Often, the best stories are the ones already caked into the brand, and social media represents an arena in which we can retell those stories, again and again, in new formats, to new audiences.
To quote Dayna, “Younger generations are really good at sniffing out the bullshit... If the vibes are off, you’re done.”
3?? Community management and social listening are the heart and soul of this work, and they aren't uniform.
All plants require different care, from their dosage of sunlight to their ideal soil. Your community is no different. For some, this means replying to every comment, DM, or story tag. For others, it means infrequent yet impactful interactions. For still others, it's showing up in unexpected places.
Look to your community before taking drastic steps to alter your digital identity. Don't plan an engagement strategy based on the ideal state; build for the state your community is in today and develop a roadmap to bring it to that ideal state. If no one is listening, then you’re just posting to post.
All types of strategies can blossom when given the time, space, and care to grow into their foundation—it’s not all just feet squished into shoes full of peanut butter.
? Every time an exec says, “Be more like Nutter Butter," the cookie loses its peanut butter filling—and that’s the best part. ?