Deep Thoughts About Taxes

Around 300 BC, the Greek philosopher Zeno of Citium and his followers gathered in Athens on a Stoa Poikile—a “painted porch”—to discuss how to live a virtuous life built around wisdom, temperance, justice, and courage. (I realize this isn’t what you expect from your favorite weekly tax column. Stick with me.) Zeno went on to influence future philosophers like Seneca, Epictetus, and perhaps most notably, the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius. Together, they became known as the Stoics, and their lessons are enjoying a renaissance today.

Most people understand the word “stoic” to mean repressing one’s emotions or simply enduring patiently. However, at its core, stoicism boils down to the notion that it’s not events that upset us so much as our reaction to those events. Stoics look at what happens around them and ask, “Can we control this?” If so, they fight the good fight. If not, they don’t waste time, energy, or emotional balance fighting a battle they can’t win. No amount of yelling at the airline representative is going to stop a summer storm that parks itself over O’Hare!

That same philosophy can help manage the infuriating gauntlet we laughingly refer to as “the tax system.” Former president Jimmy Carter campaigned against it as “a disgrace to the human race,” and 50 years later, his attack still holds true. There’s not a single sitting senator or representative who would defend the Internal Revenue Code as it currently stands. But sadly, today’s dysfunctional Congress would struggle just to pass a resolution declaring that ice cream tastes good, let alone craft a tax system that meets the needs of our modern economy. “Fixing” the tax code appears as likely as fixing that storm over O’Hare.

So , what do stoics do? They accept the tax code as it is, warts and all. Then, they work to control outcomes within that flawed system. That means planning to take advantage of the sometimes hidden, sometimes silly ways to legally pay less. (Seriously, can you imagine Marcus Aurelius meditating on the Augusta Rule?)

The next couple of years will be especially challenging for stoics looking to accept battles they can’t win. That’s because the current framework, enacted by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, turns into a pumpkin just like Cinderella’s carriage at midnight on December 31, 2025. At that moment, if Congress hasn’t acted, standard deductions, rates, and a host of other factors revert to their 2017 levels. That will mean trillions in higher taxes for most Americans. Now, there’s broad bipartisan agreement to extend most of the current rules, especially for individuals making under $400,000 per year. But who knows what might happen? As Mark Twain once said, “No American is safe when Congress is in session.”

What’s worse, we probably won’t have time to do much planning before whatever new rules Washington passes become law. In 2017, it took Congress until December 20 to send the White House a bill to sign. That meant planners had just 12 days’ notice before the 2018 rules and rates took effect. That’s actually a luxury compared to previous Congressional efforts. In 2012, Congress was faced with the challenge of extending rates from the 2010 Tax Relief Act that expired at midnight that year. They finally got the job done 11 hours after the deadline passed on New Year’s Day.

Most Americans who make enough money to benefit from professional tax services can expect a bumpy ride over the next couple of years. Don’t worry—we’ll be here to guide you through the things you can control to pay less, no matter who wins the election and what the rules look like.

Contact us at (562) 281-1040 or email us at [email protected] to smooth the upcoming bumpy ride.