Using feedback effectively in game design increases the power of the narrative. By categorising feedback, balancing conflicting views and staying true to the essence of the story, you can integrate player comments harmoniously into the game's narrative. This both maintains narrative fluency and enriches the player experience. ->Classify the Feedback ->Balance Conflicting Feedback ->Stay True to the Core Narrative

Playtestter feedback is essential for a good game deisgn. Good playtestter feedback is like the taste test of a master chef. It can make or break your game. The cycle can be something like; Feedback received Revise the game design Playtest the game Do this until theres a great feedback regarding the coherence.

When facing issues with narrative coherence, playtester feedback is invaluable. I approach it by first identifying recurring concerns and patterns. Then, I break down the feedback into actionable changes while maintaining the core vision of the story. Collaborating with writers and designers, we iterate on key narrative elements, ensuring clarity and consistency. Engaging playtesters again to validate changes ensures the narrative stays immersive. This feedback-driven process not only strengthens the story but also aligns it with player expectations for a more engaging experience.

The first step is to define the pillars of your game narrative. What story are you planning to tell? What subtext do you want your game to deliver? Addressing player feedback can be tricky; you never want to stray from your basic objectives, but of course you want to listen to player feedback. Still, player feedback is better at identifying "there is an issue here" than "this is the way to solve it." Almost never do what the most vocal critics is say the right thing to do; the right thing to do is decide, okay, there is an issue, how do I resolve that problem while remaining true to the vision of of the game.

What I would like to do: - check the feedback to find the exact portions of the game where narrative coherence lacks - extract the basics of the issue and find a way to improve it, starting with simple changes and then going into fine detail - improve the game with the settled solutions - repeat